WEBVTT 00:01:01.687 --> 00:01:04.189 Excuse me? There's no way it says it's sold out. 00:01:04.898 --> 00:01:07.192 I checked that it's already been shipped. 00:01:07.276 --> 00:01:08.277 Yes. 00:01:08.360 --> 00:01:11.154 It should arrive sometime in the morning of the ninth for you. 00:01:11.238 --> 00:01:12.698 CHOI JIN-PYO 00:01:12.781 --> 00:01:13.907 I did check the size. 00:01:14.533 --> 00:01:16.118 All right. Have a good one. 00:01:17.202 --> 00:01:18.328 Hello, this is Raon. 00:01:18.412 --> 00:01:19.246 Gosh. 00:01:19.329 --> 00:01:20.330 Yes, ma'am. 00:01:21.373 --> 00:01:24.001 Yes, the item you returned was confirmed to be defective. 00:01:24.793 --> 00:01:25.669 Yes. 00:01:25.752 --> 00:01:28.255 CHOI JIN-HO: I REWROTE MY COVER LETTER LIKE YOU TOLD ME TO! 00:01:28.338 --> 00:01:31.508 -That was fast. -Or would you prefer to get a refund? 00:01:33.635 --> 00:01:36.221 ATTACHED FILE: COVER LETTER.DOC 00:01:36.305 --> 00:01:38.098 DOWNLOADING 00:01:45.981 --> 00:01:47.858 DOCUMENT CREATED WITH APPLICATION PROGRAHM NOT RELATED TO MACROSOFT OFFICE 00:01:47.941 --> 00:01:49.151 ALLOW CONTENT 00:01:49.985 --> 00:01:50.861 What? 00:02:00.078 --> 00:02:01.246 Hey, Jin-pyo. What's up? 00:02:01.330 --> 00:02:03.790 Your cover letter file won't open. Send it again. 00:02:04.416 --> 00:02:06.043 I'll take a look at it at home. 00:02:06.126 --> 00:02:07.544 I didn't send it to you. 00:02:08.253 --> 00:02:09.338 You didn't? 00:02:19.056 --> 00:02:20.057 What? 00:02:21.183 --> 00:02:22.100 What? 00:02:24.895 --> 00:02:26.021 I'll see you tomorrow. 00:02:27.064 --> 00:02:28.982 Mr. Choi! 00:02:37.240 --> 00:02:38.116 What? 00:02:39.284 --> 00:02:40.118 What? 00:02:44.289 --> 00:02:45.248 Jin-pyo. 00:02:46.124 --> 00:02:47.125 Jin-pyo? 00:02:48.335 --> 00:02:49.294 What's wrong? 00:02:53.340 --> 00:02:55.008 Sir, I… 00:02:56.176 --> 00:02:57.177 I think they got me. 00:02:57.260 --> 00:02:58.470 What do you mean? 00:02:59.721 --> 00:03:00.972 Spear Phishing. 00:03:07.771 --> 00:03:13.693 CASE 15 SAYING AND DOING THINGS NOT ASKED 00:03:28.667 --> 00:03:30.252 I don't think… 00:03:30.961 --> 00:03:33.130 you and I should date. 00:03:37.801 --> 00:03:41.221 Why are you saying that all of a sudden? 00:03:42.347 --> 00:03:44.057 I'm sorry. 00:04:34.608 --> 00:04:36.693 You have to stay strong, okay? 00:04:36.777 --> 00:04:37.944 I am staying strong. 00:04:38.028 --> 00:04:40.030 -I'm fine. Don't worry. -All right. 00:04:44.701 --> 00:04:46.870 Attorney Jung! 00:04:49.790 --> 00:04:50.916 What? 00:04:50.999 --> 00:04:52.125 Attorney Woo. 00:04:52.751 --> 00:04:54.085 What brings you here? 00:04:54.169 --> 00:04:55.754 The subway brought me here. 00:04:55.837 --> 00:04:57.756 No. I mean… 00:04:58.465 --> 00:05:01.009 Why are you here when you should be at work? 00:05:01.092 --> 00:05:04.179 Right. I wanted to see you, Attorney Jung. 00:05:05.472 --> 00:05:07.599 Because if something goes wrong and you die, 00:05:07.682 --> 00:05:09.518 I won't be able to see you again. 00:05:10.018 --> 00:05:10.977 Excuse me? 00:05:11.061 --> 00:05:12.479 Mom. 00:05:12.562 --> 00:05:14.898 Attorney Woo didn't mean it in a bad way. 00:05:14.981 --> 00:05:16.358 Say hi. This is my mom. 00:05:17.108 --> 00:05:19.528 Hello. My name is Woo Young-woo. 00:05:19.611 --> 00:05:20.987 Whether it's read straight or flipped, it's still Woo Young-woo. 00:05:21.071 --> 00:05:23.406 Kayak, deed, rotator, noon, racecar, Woo Young-woo. 00:05:23.490 --> 00:05:27.118 -What? -Mom, I told you. 00:05:27.202 --> 00:05:29.162 Korea's number one in the world in treating stomach cancer. 00:05:29.246 --> 00:05:32.874 So with surgery, the survival rate is over 70 percent. 00:05:32.958 --> 00:05:34.125 Don't worry. 00:05:34.209 --> 00:05:38.255 That's because that number also includes cases of early detection. 00:05:38.338 --> 00:05:40.215 With stage three stomach cancer like you, 00:05:40.298 --> 00:05:41.967 the 5-year survival rate after surgery is only 30 to 40 percent-- 00:05:42.050 --> 00:05:45.303 Shall we go in? 00:05:45.387 --> 00:05:46.555 Yes. 00:05:46.638 --> 00:05:48.890 Myeong-seok. Hang in there, okay? 00:05:48.974 --> 00:05:51.309 -I'll be here. -I'll see you later. 00:05:51.393 --> 00:05:54.354 Please! Come back alive! 00:05:54.437 --> 00:05:55.522 Attorney Woo. 00:05:56.356 --> 00:05:57.315 Be quiet. 00:05:58.149 --> 00:06:01.403 Please! Come back alive! 00:06:01.486 --> 00:06:03.321 -You got this. -Be quiet. 00:06:05.448 --> 00:06:06.366 Please. 00:06:22.132 --> 00:06:24.384 Namu Gwanseeumbosal. 00:06:38.356 --> 00:06:39.441 Hello? 00:06:39.524 --> 00:06:41.568 Where are you? Come to the conference room. 00:06:41.651 --> 00:06:44.029 We have a meeting with our newly assigned clients. 00:06:44.112 --> 00:06:46.114 I'm not at work right now. 00:06:46.197 --> 00:06:48.658 Then hurry up and get here as fast as you can. 00:06:49.659 --> 00:06:51.202 Right, okay. 00:06:56.625 --> 00:07:00.295 It's a bit awkward to say this myself, 00:07:01.087 --> 00:07:04.758 but certain people are cut out for certain jobs, right? 00:07:04.841 --> 00:07:08.303 Hanbada has a lot of good attorneys. 00:07:08.845 --> 00:07:12.641 But for these corporate cases, especially in tech, I… 00:07:16.978 --> 00:07:19.689 There's another attorney on this case. She must be here. 00:07:20.273 --> 00:07:21.650 Come in. 00:07:25.236 --> 00:07:26.321 As I was saying… 00:07:33.078 --> 00:07:35.413 Come in already. Why are you just standing there? 00:07:35.497 --> 00:07:36.831 Our clients are here. 00:07:36.915 --> 00:07:37.791 Right. 00:07:37.874 --> 00:07:40.669 The shock of moving from one space to another 00:07:40.752 --> 00:07:42.629 is very overwhelming for me. 00:07:42.712 --> 00:07:45.715 If I count to three and take a deep breath before going in, 00:07:45.799 --> 00:07:47.550 it lessens the shock a bit. 00:07:50.971 --> 00:07:52.806 That happens to me sometimes too. 00:07:52.889 --> 00:07:56.101 It's uncomfortable when the space I'm in suddenly changes. 00:07:56.893 --> 00:07:59.104 She's quite brave. 00:07:59.980 --> 00:08:02.357 I don't want other people to think I'm weird, 00:08:02.440 --> 00:08:06.945 so I pretend that I'm not uncomfortable even when I am. 00:08:07.028 --> 00:08:10.156 Is something like that funny to you right now? 00:08:10.240 --> 00:08:11.658 Does it make you laugh? 00:08:11.741 --> 00:08:14.244 Nothing's changed since we were in school. 00:08:14.327 --> 00:08:16.413 I'm always the one who takes things seriously. 00:08:17.038 --> 00:08:19.332 Did you two go to the same university? 00:08:19.416 --> 00:08:21.793 No, I didn't go to university. 00:08:21.876 --> 00:08:24.546 We went to high school together. And I graduated from Hana University. 00:08:24.629 --> 00:08:25.880 Hana University? 00:08:29.217 --> 00:08:31.052 I mean, we're alumni. 00:08:33.430 --> 00:08:36.099 I was a freshman at Hana University in 2000. 00:08:37.017 --> 00:08:38.476 I was a freshman in '97. 00:08:38.560 --> 00:08:40.895 I was a freshman in '13. 00:08:40.979 --> 00:08:44.357 In '13? Gosh, you're a baby. 00:08:44.441 --> 00:08:45.692 Baby? 00:08:46.943 --> 00:08:48.403 When I was in school, 00:08:48.486 --> 00:08:51.406 you came as a special lecturer, 00:08:51.489 --> 00:08:52.741 and it was very inspiring. 00:08:52.824 --> 00:08:54.951 I couldn't believe an alumnus from our school 00:08:55.035 --> 00:08:57.495 created the online shopping mall that the whole country uses. 00:08:57.579 --> 00:08:59.748 -Gosh, you flatter me. -You're really amazing. 00:09:00.457 --> 00:09:01.583 Well… 00:09:01.666 --> 00:09:03.585 It's not the whole country. 00:09:04.544 --> 00:09:08.965 Based on a recent survey, the number of Raon users is 40,954,173, 00:09:09.049 --> 00:09:12.761 but the total population of Korea is 51,628,117. 00:09:15.889 --> 00:09:16.931 Same difference. 00:09:17.015 --> 00:09:19.559 It means more than 80 percent of the entire population uses Raon. 00:09:20.518 --> 00:09:21.770 It really is amazing. 00:09:22.353 --> 00:09:23.229 Amazing? 00:09:23.897 --> 00:09:25.148 We're about to go under. 00:09:29.360 --> 00:09:30.987 Shall we get back to business? 00:09:31.071 --> 00:09:31.905 -Right. -Yes. 00:09:31.988 --> 00:09:35.950 So the employee in charge of the database received an email from a hacker? 00:09:36.034 --> 00:09:41.623 The hacker hacked into the inbox of our employee in charge of the DB 00:09:41.706 --> 00:09:44.918 and was aware of everything he and his younger brother had discussed. 00:09:45.001 --> 00:09:48.880 He even sent the email using the younger brother's exact tone. 00:09:48.963 --> 00:09:51.758 If the attachment containing the malware 00:09:51.841 --> 00:09:53.885 was an executable installation file, 00:09:53.968 --> 00:09:56.679 our DB manager would have been more careful. 00:09:56.763 --> 00:09:59.724 But since it was a document file, he didn't think much of it. 00:09:59.808 --> 00:10:03.770 I didn't know malware could be spread with Word files. 00:10:03.853 --> 00:10:04.938 Yes, it's possible. 00:10:05.021 --> 00:10:06.856 And since it was malware 00:10:06.940 --> 00:10:09.275 that was specially made to attack a specific target, 00:10:09.359 --> 00:10:11.778 it wasn't detected by the anti-malware software. 00:10:11.861 --> 00:10:13.446 Was the hacker caught? 00:10:13.530 --> 00:10:14.447 No, the police think 00:10:14.531 --> 00:10:16.825 it was done by North Korea's Reconnaissance General Bureau. 00:10:16.908 --> 00:10:18.243 But we're not sure yet. 00:10:18.326 --> 00:10:20.161 North Korea's RGB? 00:10:21.454 --> 00:10:22.664 Just a moment. 00:10:24.165 --> 00:10:27.210 Will you take a quick look at this? Here. 00:10:28.002 --> 00:10:30.213 Notice anything odd? 00:10:32.507 --> 00:10:34.884 -"Prograhm"? -Yes. 00:10:34.968 --> 00:10:37.637 Apparently, North Koreans spell "program" as "prograhm." 00:10:37.720 --> 00:10:41.141 This probably isn't the only reason they suspect North Korea, 00:10:41.224 --> 00:10:42.767 but they're investigating. 00:10:42.851 --> 00:10:45.061 If North Korea really is responsible, 00:10:45.812 --> 00:10:48.064 it's going to be difficult to catch the hacker. 00:10:48.148 --> 00:10:50.275 Since political issues will be involved as well. 00:10:50.358 --> 00:10:53.695 No, the even bigger problem is the Korea Communications Commission. 00:10:53.778 --> 00:10:57.115 They imposed a 300 billion won penalty surcharge on us. 00:10:57.198 --> 00:11:00.034 And that's why we came to you. 00:11:00.118 --> 00:11:03.872 If you think about it, we're victims of a North Korean cyberattack. 00:11:03.955 --> 00:11:08.084 Fining us 300 billion won just because we couldn't safeguard some personal data? 00:11:08.168 --> 00:11:10.044 That's just ridiculous, isn't it? 00:11:10.628 --> 00:11:14.257 When the hacker broke into our DB manager's computer, 00:11:14.340 --> 00:11:19.053 the terminal connecting to the DB server was up on the screen and still logged in. 00:11:19.137 --> 00:11:22.765 So from the hacker's perspective, he didn't have to go through 00:11:22.849 --> 00:11:25.685 the trouble of finding out the manager's ID and password 00:11:25.768 --> 00:11:27.979 to connect to the server. 00:11:28.062 --> 00:11:30.857 And this is what the KCC is taking issue with. 00:11:31.649 --> 00:11:35.570 That we didn't set an idle timeout on our DB server properly. 00:11:35.653 --> 00:11:38.281 By "idle timeout," 00:11:38.364 --> 00:11:41.701 you mean a "limitation on the maximum connection time," right? 00:11:41.784 --> 00:11:42.660 Yes. 00:11:42.744 --> 00:11:44.412 After a certain amount of time, 00:11:44.495 --> 00:11:46.706 the connection would be blocked automatically. 00:11:46.789 --> 00:11:49.876 You're not connected to the server any longer than what's necessary. 00:11:49.959 --> 00:11:53.671 And Raon's DB server didn't have this setting in place? 00:11:53.755 --> 00:11:55.048 No. 00:11:55.548 --> 00:11:56.925 We didn't set it up. 00:12:00.595 --> 00:12:01.888 From what I see, 00:12:03.723 --> 00:12:06.643 I think the KCC accidentally added a few too many zeros. 00:12:06.726 --> 00:12:07.769 -What? -What? 00:12:07.852 --> 00:12:11.564 A few years back, Aha.com also had a personal data breach. 00:12:11.648 --> 00:12:15.568 Do you know how much Aha paid for their penalty surcharge? 00:12:16.361 --> 00:12:17.487 No, we don't. 00:12:17.570 --> 00:12:19.906 There was an estimated leak of two million accounts, 00:12:19.989 --> 00:12:21.532 and they paid 70 million won. 00:12:21.616 --> 00:12:22.742 What? 00:12:22.825 --> 00:12:26.663 Yes. Meanwhile, JP Communications had an even bigger breach. 00:12:26.746 --> 00:12:29.082 Almost ten million accounts. 00:12:29.749 --> 00:12:33.211 But their penalty surcharge was a mere 100 million won. 00:12:33.294 --> 00:12:35.838 Then why would they ask us to pay 300 billion won? 00:12:35.922 --> 00:12:38.341 Is it because our personal data breach is the biggest? 00:12:39.634 --> 00:12:42.178 Well, the data of more than 40 million people was leaked. 00:12:42.261 --> 00:12:44.889 Forty million is nearly the entire… 00:12:47.141 --> 00:12:50.687 I mean, it's 80 percent of the population, right? 00:12:50.770 --> 00:12:51.771 But… 00:12:52.271 --> 00:12:54.983 it's not like we lost 40 million people's assets. 00:12:55.858 --> 00:12:58.027 It's just personal data, right? 00:12:59.320 --> 00:13:01.739 When most Korean people make accounts online, 00:13:01.823 --> 00:13:04.450 aren't they aware that their personal data 00:13:05.076 --> 00:13:06.703 could be leaked? 00:13:06.786 --> 00:13:09.038 Then why are they being like this to us? 00:13:09.122 --> 00:13:13.126 The KCC couldn't have made a mistake by adding too many zeros, right? 00:13:13.209 --> 00:13:15.712 Of course not. 00:13:16.546 --> 00:13:17.797 Well… 00:13:17.880 --> 00:13:21.342 I know some people at the KCC. 00:13:21.426 --> 00:13:26.389 I'll see if I can get the full picture as to why the KCC did this 00:13:26.472 --> 00:13:28.349 and how this is proceeding over there. 00:13:31.561 --> 00:13:32.520 By the way, 00:13:33.312 --> 00:13:36.566 no corporation has ever lost a trial against the KCC so far. 00:13:36.649 --> 00:13:40.319 The KCC is a government organization, so they can't hire an expensive law firm. 00:13:40.403 --> 00:13:43.781 So they always lose to corporations that work with major law firms. 00:13:44.615 --> 00:13:46.242 It'll be the same this time too. 00:13:46.325 --> 00:13:47.785 Don't worry. 00:13:48.703 --> 00:13:49.537 My fellow alumni. 00:14:08.389 --> 00:14:10.308 What? I can't sit here? 00:14:10.391 --> 00:14:13.686 There are plenty of other seats. 00:14:15.063 --> 00:14:16.147 Okay. 00:14:17.523 --> 00:14:19.692 Or you can just sit. 00:14:21.319 --> 00:14:22.945 We've eaten together before. 00:14:23.029 --> 00:14:25.656 Gosh, you keep changing your mind. 00:14:36.250 --> 00:14:37.377 Right. 00:14:37.460 --> 00:14:39.128 He and Young-woo broke up. 00:14:39.796 --> 00:14:42.340 I didn't realize that Jun-ho would be eating by himself. 00:14:42.423 --> 00:14:44.675 Should we go join him at his table? 00:14:50.139 --> 00:14:51.849 I don't think that will be necessary. 00:14:52.600 --> 00:14:55.561 Jun-ho. You're eating by yourself today? 00:14:55.645 --> 00:14:56.729 Can I sit here? 00:14:57.980 --> 00:14:58.940 Sure. 00:15:00.149 --> 00:15:02.568 -Jun-ho, you like sausages too? -Right. 00:15:02.652 --> 00:15:05.279 Jun-ho is Mr. Popularity of Hanbada. 00:15:05.363 --> 00:15:06.447 He sure is. 00:15:07.240 --> 00:15:10.034 Who were you worried about again? 00:15:12.161 --> 00:15:14.956 -That color looks so good on you. -I know, right? 00:15:17.250 --> 00:15:18.543 Have some of this too. 00:15:29.512 --> 00:15:31.472 A MERE 100 MILLION WON PENALTY SURCHARGE FOR 7 BILLION PERSONAL DATA LEAKS 00:15:35.393 --> 00:15:36.436 Come in. 00:15:41.190 --> 00:15:43.401 Gosh, I knew it. 00:15:43.484 --> 00:15:46.571 Why are you eating alone cooped up in your office? 00:15:46.654 --> 00:15:47.655 Right. 00:15:47.738 --> 00:15:48.948 I have work to do. 00:15:49.031 --> 00:15:52.869 That's all the more reason to go outside for lunch. 00:15:52.952 --> 00:15:57.123 You should also eat lunch and have coffee with other guys. 00:15:57.707 --> 00:15:59.250 The weather is so nice today. 00:16:04.881 --> 00:16:07.133 What happened with Jun-ho? 00:16:09.093 --> 00:16:10.261 What do you mean? 00:16:10.344 --> 00:16:13.681 I heard you called things off. Why did you do that? 00:16:16.309 --> 00:16:18.227 Well… 00:16:18.311 --> 00:16:20.521 You didn't even give him a proper explanation? 00:16:21.689 --> 00:16:22.565 No. 00:16:23.441 --> 00:16:24.567 Are you serious? 00:16:24.650 --> 00:16:26.611 That's so rude. 00:16:26.694 --> 00:16:29.822 You called things off and you still haven't told him why? 00:16:33.826 --> 00:16:37.497 I don't think it's appropriate to discuss personal matters during work hours. 00:16:38.080 --> 00:16:39.248 It's lunchtime right now. 00:16:39.332 --> 00:16:42.668 Then should we talk about whales? Lunchtime is when I usually talk-- 00:16:42.752 --> 00:16:44.670 No, I don't want to. 00:16:44.754 --> 00:16:45.880 Just answer my question. 00:17:05.233 --> 00:17:06.943 What are you doing? 00:17:11.280 --> 00:17:13.157 Lunchtime is now over. 00:17:13.241 --> 00:17:16.077 It's work hours again. No more talking about personal matters. 00:17:16.953 --> 00:17:18.871 Hey, Young-woo! 00:17:19.539 --> 00:17:20.706 Where are you going? 00:17:21.374 --> 00:17:22.291 Hey… 00:17:27.755 --> 00:17:28.965 Come in. 00:17:39.934 --> 00:17:41.561 What brings you here? 00:17:47.567 --> 00:17:49.235 Well… 00:17:50.444 --> 00:17:52.071 Attorney Jang. 00:17:52.154 --> 00:17:54.699 It's not a mistake that the KCC imposed Raon 00:17:54.782 --> 00:17:56.826 with a 300 billion won penalty surcharge. 00:17:58.452 --> 00:17:59.287 Excuse me? 00:17:59.370 --> 00:18:02.957 The KCC didn't accidentally add a few too many zeros. 00:18:05.668 --> 00:18:07.211 Then what is it? 00:18:07.295 --> 00:18:12.008 Did you find the answer as to why the KCC did that? 00:18:23.060 --> 00:18:24.895 A MERE 100 MILLION WON PENALTY SURCHARGE FOR 7 BILLION PERSONAL DATA LEAKS 00:18:24.979 --> 00:18:28.190 "Over the past decade, there have been seven billion personal data leaks, 00:18:28.274 --> 00:18:29.859 but only light punishment has been imposed." 00:18:29.942 --> 00:18:30.818 "The strengthening of punishment 00:18:30.901 --> 00:18:33.529 such as introducing a class action system and expanding punitive damages is needed." 00:18:35.072 --> 00:18:37.241 There are a lot of similar articles. 00:18:37.325 --> 00:18:39.118 Public opinion on personal data leakage 00:18:39.201 --> 00:18:42.788 is leaning toward the necessity of strengthening punishment for companies. 00:18:42.872 --> 00:18:43.831 So what? 00:18:44.498 --> 00:18:46.876 The KCC read a few newspaper articles 00:18:47.668 --> 00:18:50.004 and raised the penalty surcharge 00:18:50.087 --> 00:18:52.798 from 100 million to 300 billion won out of nowhere? 00:18:52.882 --> 00:18:53.924 The Act on the Information and Communications Network 00:18:54.008 --> 00:18:55.217 is revised frequently. 00:18:55.301 --> 00:18:58.596 Back when the KCC imposed penalties of 70 million won and 100 million won 00:18:58.679 --> 00:19:01.891 on Aha.com and JP Communications respectively, 00:19:01.974 --> 00:19:05.519 the law had set the maximum penalty surcharge as 100 million won. 00:19:05.603 --> 00:19:07.146 However, under the current law, 00:19:07.229 --> 00:19:10.024 a penalty surcharge of up to three percent of sales 00:19:10.107 --> 00:19:11.942 related to the violation can be imposed. 00:19:12.026 --> 00:19:14.945 Which is why it became possible to fine 300 billion won. 00:19:25.456 --> 00:19:27.958 She's so arrogant. 00:19:29.251 --> 00:19:31.170 Sorry? I didn't quite catch that. 00:19:43.766 --> 00:19:46.143 This is your first time working with me, right? 00:19:46.227 --> 00:19:47.436 Yes. 00:19:47.520 --> 00:19:50.439 From now on, there's only one rule you have to follow. 00:19:51.941 --> 00:19:53.109 Don't say anything you haven't been asked 00:19:53.192 --> 00:19:54.652 and don't do anything you haven't been asked to do. 00:19:55.361 --> 00:19:56.445 Understood? 00:19:58.406 --> 00:19:59.699 Aren't those two rules? 00:20:01.325 --> 00:20:02.159 What's that? 00:20:02.243 --> 00:20:03.786 "Don't say anything you haven't been asked," one. 00:20:03.869 --> 00:20:05.454 "Don't do anything you haven't been asked to do," one. 00:20:05.538 --> 00:20:06.455 That's two in total. 00:20:06.539 --> 00:20:09.250 Whether it's one or two, do you understand? 00:20:11.001 --> 00:20:12.211 Yes, I understand. 00:20:20.219 --> 00:20:25.391 I brought some side dishes for your mother, Attorney Jung. 00:20:26.058 --> 00:20:28.394 I run a pub 00:20:28.477 --> 00:20:31.522 so it seems like all these side dishes should go with drinks. 00:20:32.398 --> 00:20:34.066 Then she can have a drink with them. 00:20:34.150 --> 00:20:36.110 It's hard to look after someone while sober. 00:20:36.193 --> 00:20:37.737 She quit drinking. 00:20:37.820 --> 00:20:38.779 I see. 00:20:38.863 --> 00:20:41.741 Thank you so much for also thinking of my mother. 00:20:41.824 --> 00:20:43.284 Gosh. No need to thank me. 00:20:43.367 --> 00:20:45.119 I'm just glad your surgery went well. 00:20:45.661 --> 00:20:47.496 I'll put the food in the fridge. 00:20:53.461 --> 00:20:54.962 What's wrong, Attorney Woo? 00:20:55.045 --> 00:20:56.338 Is something bothering you? 00:20:57.214 --> 00:20:59.925 -Yes, something is bothering me. -What is it? 00:21:01.635 --> 00:21:05.181 I can't tell you the details because of attorney-client privilege. 00:21:05.264 --> 00:21:08.934 Then be vague about it and don't get into the details. 00:21:09.018 --> 00:21:10.227 Well… 00:21:12.897 --> 00:21:15.608 What do I do if a senior attorney on a case with me 00:21:15.691 --> 00:21:18.194 will not listen to what I have to say? 00:21:18.277 --> 00:21:20.988 Who's the senior attorney on the case with you? 00:21:21.071 --> 00:21:23.032 Attorney Jang. 00:21:23.115 --> 00:21:24.366 Damn it. 00:21:27.328 --> 00:21:30.664 Well, for your sake, 00:21:31.248 --> 00:21:34.960 lowering yourself and not doing anything that might set him off could be a way… 00:21:35.044 --> 00:21:36.003 Where are you going? 00:21:36.086 --> 00:21:37.338 Gosh. 00:21:37.421 --> 00:21:40.883 Young-woo, he didn't mean that literally! 00:21:44.929 --> 00:21:45.846 But… 00:21:46.347 --> 00:21:48.891 you could never do that, right? 00:21:48.974 --> 00:21:51.060 You don't even get what "lower yourself" means. 00:21:52.561 --> 00:21:53.771 Then what do I do? 00:21:56.565 --> 00:21:57.942 Attorney Woo, 00:21:58.651 --> 00:21:59.860 you have colleagues. 00:22:00.820 --> 00:22:01.946 Talk to them. 00:22:02.822 --> 00:22:04.615 If you can't get through to a senior attorney, 00:22:04.698 --> 00:22:06.951 have even more discussions with your colleagues. 00:22:27.763 --> 00:22:30.015 Its name reflects the fact that it's a cyberattack 00:22:30.099 --> 00:22:33.143 that targets the weak spot of a specific individual or organization, 00:22:33.227 --> 00:22:38.148 much like throwing a spear. 00:22:39.108 --> 00:22:42.987 The attack on Raon's DB manager, Mr. Choi Jin-pyo, 00:22:43.070 --> 00:22:45.781 was also spear phishing. 00:22:45.864 --> 00:22:49.952 The hacker used spear phishing 00:22:50.035 --> 00:22:52.663 to get malware onto Mr. Choi's computer 00:22:52.746 --> 00:22:54.540 and then proceeded with an APT attack. 00:22:54.623 --> 00:22:57.501 In other words, the Advanced Persistent-- 00:22:57.585 --> 00:22:58.877 Plaintiff's counselor. 00:23:00.004 --> 00:23:02.214 I appreciate the generous explanation, 00:23:02.298 --> 00:23:06.885 but the plaintiff, defendant, and judges here 00:23:06.969 --> 00:23:09.054 all know what an APT attack is, 00:23:09.847 --> 00:23:11.807 so can we move on? 00:23:12.391 --> 00:23:13.559 Well… 00:23:14.351 --> 00:23:18.188 You know what an Advanced Persistent Threat is? 00:23:18.272 --> 00:23:23.444 It means to attack the target in a continuous, sophisticated manner. 00:23:24.445 --> 00:23:25.362 Yes. 00:23:25.446 --> 00:23:28.324 If this were a jury trial, 00:23:28.407 --> 00:23:30.993 you would have to explain all the details. 00:23:31.076 --> 00:23:32.620 But right now, it's just us, 00:23:32.703 --> 00:23:36.707 and most of the people in the audience seem to be reporters. 00:23:36.790 --> 00:23:39.126 So why don't you just get to your argument? 00:23:39.793 --> 00:23:40.794 Sure. 00:24:01.148 --> 00:24:02.358 Just a moment. 00:24:04.860 --> 00:24:05.986 The tablet. 00:24:07.571 --> 00:24:09.114 Jeez, I'm not a mind reader. 00:24:09.657 --> 00:24:14.036 As such, to impose such a huge penalty surcharge 00:24:14.119 --> 00:24:16.121 of 300 billion won on Raon, 00:24:16.747 --> 00:24:20.876 who is also a victim of this hacking, 00:24:20.959 --> 00:24:25.589 is both a deviation and abuse of discretionary power by the KCC. 00:24:26.298 --> 00:24:28.550 It's neither a deviation nor an abuse of discretionary power. 00:24:28.634 --> 00:24:30.427 According to the Act on the Information and Communications Network, 00:24:30.511 --> 00:24:33.472 the defendant can impose on the plaintiff 00:24:33.555 --> 00:24:38.227 a penalty surcharge of up to three percent of sales related to the violation. 00:24:38.811 --> 00:24:42.314 Raon's sales last year were 30.3 trillion won. 00:24:43.190 --> 00:24:46.944 The defendant could have imposed a penalty surcharge of 900 billion won, 00:24:47.027 --> 00:24:49.405 but took into account the plaintiff's circumstances 00:24:49.488 --> 00:24:51.323 and imposed only 300 billion won, 00:24:51.990 --> 00:24:53.951 which is much less than the maximum amount. 00:24:55.786 --> 00:24:59.415 When Aha.com and JP Communications leaked personal data, 00:24:59.498 --> 00:25:02.167 the defendant imposed penalties of 70 million won 00:25:02.251 --> 00:25:04.795 and 100 million won, respectively. 00:25:04.878 --> 00:25:08.841 However, to impose 300 billion won for the same issue 00:25:08.924 --> 00:25:11.802 just because the law was revised 00:25:12.803 --> 00:25:15.931 is far too unfair. 00:25:16.014 --> 00:25:20.602 Forty million personal data records were leaked due to Raon's carelessness. 00:25:21.270 --> 00:25:23.439 They leaked the personal data of the entire country-- 00:25:23.522 --> 00:25:25.607 It's not the entire country. 00:25:26.108 --> 00:25:29.403 Korea's population is 50 million. 00:25:29.486 --> 00:25:33.907 It would be more accurate to say 80 percent of the entire country. 00:25:36.034 --> 00:25:38.370 Yes, Your Honor. I stand corrected. 00:25:38.996 --> 00:25:43.000 They leaked the personal data of 80 percent of the entire country. 00:25:43.751 --> 00:25:46.044 How much would be fair then? 00:25:47.087 --> 00:25:49.965 -That… -The leaked data from this Raon incident 00:25:50.048 --> 00:25:52.342 isn't just basic personal data. 00:25:53.177 --> 00:25:56.805 Credit and financial transaction data of 40 million people 00:25:56.889 --> 00:25:58.724 have all been exposed. 00:25:58.807 --> 00:25:59.850 But they're saying 00:25:59.933 --> 00:26:03.937 that the penalty surcharge, which is only one percent of their sales, is too much? 00:26:04.438 --> 00:26:08.358 This kind of attitude shows Raon's low level of awareness 00:26:08.442 --> 00:26:11.487 of their users' personal data. 00:26:18.410 --> 00:26:19.912 That is all. 00:26:31.673 --> 00:26:35.886 What's important in this situation is causation. 00:26:35.969 --> 00:26:36.804 You know the difference 00:26:36.887 --> 00:26:39.014 between an administrative fine and a penalty surcharge, right? 00:26:39.097 --> 00:26:40.974 No, not really. 00:26:41.850 --> 00:26:47.105 Not having set up the idle timeout itself falls under an administrative fine. 00:26:47.940 --> 00:26:49.733 It's less than 30 million won at most. 00:26:49.817 --> 00:26:53.111 But if not having this idle timeout in place 00:26:53.195 --> 00:26:56.281 is what caused this personal data breach, 00:26:57.574 --> 00:27:00.285 then it falls under a penalty surcharge. 00:27:00.994 --> 00:27:04.540 And the amount would also increase to three percent of related sales. 00:27:05.207 --> 00:27:06.041 All right. 00:27:06.124 --> 00:27:07.459 So… 00:27:08.252 --> 00:27:13.841 if an idle timeout was set on Raon's servers, 00:27:14.591 --> 00:27:17.386 could it have prevented the personal data breach? 00:27:18.720 --> 00:27:22.015 That's like asking, "If the front door was locked, 00:27:22.099 --> 00:27:26.144 would a thief still have been able to steal from inside the house?" 00:27:27.521 --> 00:27:29.982 It depends on the capability of the hacker, 00:27:30.065 --> 00:27:33.443 but we don't know who hacked us because they haven't been caught yet. 00:27:33.527 --> 00:27:36.238 But you're an expert. 00:27:36.321 --> 00:27:38.198 I'm asking you to take a guess. 00:27:40.617 --> 00:27:44.746 This is something that will decide whether it's a 30 million won administrative fine 00:27:44.830 --> 00:27:48.083 or a 300 billion won penalty surcharge. 00:27:49.543 --> 00:27:51.211 Hey, Jin-pyo. 00:27:51.295 --> 00:27:53.755 There was a keylogger in the malware installed on your computer, right? 00:27:53.839 --> 00:27:54.840 What? 00:27:55.591 --> 00:27:56.717 Yes, there was. 00:27:56.800 --> 00:27:57.801 A keylogger? 00:27:57.885 --> 00:28:02.806 If a keylogger is installed, they can see what is being typed. 00:28:02.890 --> 00:28:06.101 If Jin-pyo typed his ID and password to connect to the server, 00:28:06.184 --> 00:28:07.644 they could see that too. 00:28:07.728 --> 00:28:10.480 It would just take a bit longer for them to get the information. 00:28:10.564 --> 00:28:16.695 So even if the idle timeout was set, it couldn't have prevented the hacking? 00:28:16.778 --> 00:28:18.989 There's no causation between the two? 00:28:19.072 --> 00:28:20.073 That's right. 00:28:24.453 --> 00:28:25.621 Excuse me. 00:28:26.246 --> 00:28:27.539 I just got a phone call. 00:28:28.081 --> 00:28:31.835 Our users are filing a class-action lawsuit against us. 00:28:33.128 --> 00:28:34.504 A class-action lawsuit? 00:28:34.588 --> 00:28:38.216 To claim damages for the personal data breach. 00:28:38.300 --> 00:28:40.677 Which law firm is representing them? 00:28:43.597 --> 00:28:47.684 What law firm has nothing better to do than take on this tiresome case? 00:28:47.768 --> 00:28:48.977 It's… 00:28:49.853 --> 00:28:50.938 Taesan Law Firm. 00:28:53.815 --> 00:28:55.192 Taesan? 00:28:55.275 --> 00:28:59.321 Apparently, they're recruiting litigants through a website. 00:29:00.697 --> 00:29:02.950 I found the website you just mentioned. 00:29:03.033 --> 00:29:04.368 That was quick. 00:29:04.451 --> 00:29:05.869 It's been less than a month since the website launched 00:29:05.953 --> 00:29:07.371 but there are already a million people. 00:29:08.914 --> 00:29:11.708 It seems like they're planning to claim 100,000 won for each victim. 00:29:12.334 --> 00:29:14.795 Attorney Jang, what do we do? 00:29:14.878 --> 00:29:17.256 The penalty surcharge isn't important anymore. 00:29:17.339 --> 00:29:18.840 If they already have a million people in less than a month, 00:29:18.924 --> 00:29:21.218 it's only a matter of time before they have 40 million. 00:29:21.301 --> 00:29:23.595 And if 40 million people each claim 100,000 won, 00:29:23.679 --> 00:29:24.972 it's four trillion won in total. 00:29:25.555 --> 00:29:27.808 That would be the end of us. 00:29:30.018 --> 00:29:31.687 Raon will go bankrupt. 00:29:39.319 --> 00:29:42.197 Sir, you need to be even calmer in a situation like this. 00:29:44.116 --> 00:29:46.994 This is how it is for personal data breach cases. 00:29:47.619 --> 00:29:49.621 In addition to the liability under public law 00:29:49.705 --> 00:29:51.415 of having to pay a fine or surcharge, 00:29:51.498 --> 00:29:53.500 you'll also be expected to bear liability under the "jurisdiction" 00:29:53.583 --> 00:29:55.210 through civil lawsuits. 00:29:56.253 --> 00:29:57.087 Now-- 00:29:57.170 --> 00:29:59.298 Please be mindful of your pronunciation. 00:30:09.057 --> 00:30:09.933 What? 00:30:10.017 --> 00:30:14.354 The way you pronounced it refers to "jurisdiction." 00:30:14.438 --> 00:30:17.816 The last syllable must be stressed in the Korean word for "private law." 00:30:17.899 --> 00:30:19.818 Although the two are spelled the same, 00:30:19.901 --> 00:30:24.281 they mean completely different things based on their pronunciation. 00:30:25.240 --> 00:30:26.575 Attorney Woo. 00:30:27.409 --> 00:30:29.953 Is that something you should be saying to me right now? 00:30:30.787 --> 00:30:32.831 Are you teaching me how to pronounce words? 00:30:35.667 --> 00:30:37.377 -Attorney Jang. -Yes. 00:30:37.461 --> 00:30:38.754 May I have a word with you? 00:30:38.837 --> 00:30:40.339 -Let's go outside. -Yes. 00:30:51.183 --> 00:30:52.601 I looked into it 00:30:52.684 --> 00:30:55.312 and he had been quite active with Hana University's alumni association. 00:30:56.563 --> 00:30:57.606 Who? 00:30:58.398 --> 00:30:59.608 Our presiding judge. 00:31:00.192 --> 00:31:02.402 Right. Hana University? Yes. 00:31:03.195 --> 00:31:04.780 Can we use that to our advantage? 00:31:05.405 --> 00:31:06.365 Excuse me? 00:31:06.448 --> 00:31:09.618 Within the business industry, we treat each other to dinners. 00:31:09.701 --> 00:31:12.537 If things aren't too different in the judicial world, 00:31:12.621 --> 00:31:15.082 I was wondering if we could benefit from it. 00:31:15.165 --> 00:31:16.249 Right. 00:31:18.168 --> 00:31:19.795 Yes, that's right. 00:31:22.589 --> 00:31:25.926 "Raon, who failed to protect the personal information of 40 million users, 00:31:26.009 --> 00:31:27.469 filed a lawsuit against the penalty surcharge, 00:31:27.552 --> 00:31:29.805 which accounts for only one percent of its sales." 00:31:29.888 --> 00:31:31.640 "This fact in itself shows 00:31:31.723 --> 00:31:35.936 Raon's ridiculous level of awareness of their users' personal information." 00:31:37.020 --> 00:31:38.355 My gosh. 00:31:38.438 --> 00:31:40.774 Do you know how many articles like this are up right now? 00:31:40.857 --> 00:31:43.652 It's as if we're doing the trial to set our client up for criticism. 00:31:44.444 --> 00:31:45.278 I'm sorry. 00:31:45.362 --> 00:31:47.197 The comments are even worse. 00:31:47.781 --> 00:31:51.243 "They make 30 trillion a year, but they're whining about 300 billion?" 00:31:51.326 --> 00:31:53.662 "They leaked the personal data of the entire country 00:31:53.745 --> 00:31:56.039 but are acting like victims for being hacked." 00:31:56.123 --> 00:31:59.292 How did you set up your defense for public opinion to be this bad? 00:31:59.376 --> 00:32:02.796 The penalty surcharge that was below 100 million won for a similar case 00:32:02.879 --> 00:32:05.424 has skyrocketed to 300 billion won this time. 00:32:06.007 --> 00:32:09.678 Which is why we pointed out the KCC's deviation and abuse of discretionary power 00:32:09.761 --> 00:32:12.055 and raised the issue of fairness. 00:32:15.809 --> 00:32:17.352 We'll find another way. 00:32:18.645 --> 00:32:19.938 What other way? 00:32:20.021 --> 00:32:21.565 We're thinking about claiming 00:32:22.149 --> 00:32:23.650 that there is no direct causation 00:32:23.733 --> 00:32:26.653 between the KCC's grounds for their disposition and the hacking. 00:32:26.736 --> 00:32:29.197 You know that the second round, which is the class-action lawsuit 00:32:29.281 --> 00:32:31.241 that Taesan is preparing, is more important, right? 00:32:32.117 --> 00:32:33.160 Yes, I'm aware. 00:32:33.243 --> 00:32:34.911 We need to win this lawsuit 00:32:34.995 --> 00:32:37.330 to have the upper hand in the class-action lawsuit. 00:32:38.331 --> 00:32:41.877 It's already bad enough to see Taesan representing 40 million citizens. 00:32:41.960 --> 00:32:44.212 But imagine us losing that fight. 00:32:47.674 --> 00:32:50.218 Let's not make that our reality, okay? 00:32:52.220 --> 00:32:53.388 Yes, ma'am. 00:32:53.472 --> 00:32:55.891 I won't let that happen. 00:32:55.974 --> 00:32:57.476 We'll win this. 00:32:58.059 --> 00:32:58.935 Whatever it takes. 00:33:04.524 --> 00:33:07.319 What's so important about the pronunciation of a word? 00:33:07.402 --> 00:33:08.820 What's so important about that? 00:33:08.904 --> 00:33:09.905 What? 00:33:10.614 --> 00:33:13.325 Attorney Choi, you know how to get fired up. 00:33:14.701 --> 00:33:17.078 Who cares as long as you can understand? 00:33:17.162 --> 00:33:18.914 Why would you nitpick about that? 00:33:19.498 --> 00:33:22.584 Things are different from when we worked with Attorney Jung. 00:33:23.376 --> 00:33:24.461 They are? 00:33:25.086 --> 00:33:26.713 Of course, they are. 00:33:27.255 --> 00:33:29.382 Attorney Jung is… 00:33:30.217 --> 00:33:31.134 Well… 00:33:32.052 --> 00:33:33.345 He's generous with you. 00:33:33.428 --> 00:33:36.056 He just accepts or moves past whatever weird thing you say. 00:33:37.766 --> 00:33:39.142 "Don't say anything you haven't been asked, 00:33:39.226 --> 00:33:40.644 and don't do anything you haven't been asked to do." 00:33:40.727 --> 00:33:42.354 Yes, that's right. 00:33:42.437 --> 00:33:43.939 Just stick to that. 00:33:47.859 --> 00:33:48.818 ATTORNEY JANG SEUNG-JUN 00:33:49.945 --> 00:33:50.820 Yes, Attorney Jang. 00:33:51.571 --> 00:33:52.405 Yes, all right. 00:33:53.073 --> 00:33:54.074 Okay. 00:33:57.160 --> 00:33:59.579 -Where are you going? -What? 00:34:00.163 --> 00:34:01.373 He asked to see me. 00:34:01.456 --> 00:34:02.874 Just you? 00:34:02.958 --> 00:34:04.876 -Yes. -Why? 00:34:04.960 --> 00:34:07.087 I don't know. I'll find out when I get there. 00:34:18.431 --> 00:34:20.600 Are you sure this will be enough? 00:34:20.684 --> 00:34:22.936 Should I have made a reservation at a hostess bar? 00:34:23.979 --> 00:34:27.023 We should start off lightly. 00:34:27.691 --> 00:34:29.276 There are some people 00:34:29.359 --> 00:34:32.028 who are uncomfortable with things like that. 00:34:32.112 --> 00:34:33.029 Okay. 00:34:33.697 --> 00:34:34.531 Then, 00:34:35.323 --> 00:34:38.201 should I not give this to him today? 00:34:42.664 --> 00:34:44.958 Goodness. Well… 00:34:46.001 --> 00:34:49.212 Why don't we see how things go? 00:34:49.296 --> 00:34:50.380 Right. 00:34:50.964 --> 00:34:51.923 It's this way. 00:35:05.395 --> 00:35:07.397 What do you think you're doing? 00:35:07.480 --> 00:35:10.525 Sir, as I told you-- 00:35:10.609 --> 00:35:13.486 You said there was a Hana University alumnus in a tough spot. 00:35:13.570 --> 00:35:17.449 Didn't you tell me I would just be giving some light legal advice? 00:35:17.949 --> 00:35:21.578 What kind of person do you think I am? 00:35:22.245 --> 00:35:26.499 Sir. I am a Hana University alumnus who's in a tough spot. 00:35:27.167 --> 00:35:28.460 Please hear me out… 00:35:30.128 --> 00:35:31.880 even if it's just for five minutes. 00:35:36.301 --> 00:35:39.721 This is undeniably an improper solicitation attempt. 00:35:41.181 --> 00:35:43.725 Be grateful that I won't cause an issue with this, 00:35:43.808 --> 00:35:45.935 and don't ever do this again. 00:35:48.980 --> 00:35:49.898 Sir. 00:35:50.982 --> 00:35:51.900 Sir! 00:35:51.983 --> 00:35:53.193 Your Honor! 00:35:53.276 --> 00:35:54.110 Gosh. 00:35:54.944 --> 00:35:55.820 Your Honor! 00:36:02.369 --> 00:36:03.536 Attorney Jang. 00:36:04.162 --> 00:36:06.039 What do I do now? 00:36:08.249 --> 00:36:10.293 What do I do? 00:36:24.557 --> 00:36:25.600 Plaintiff. 00:36:26.726 --> 00:36:28.853 Do you have anything else to claim? 00:36:40.824 --> 00:36:41.866 This time… 00:36:46.621 --> 00:36:48.123 you go ahead, Attorney Choi. 00:36:49.624 --> 00:36:51.334 Right, okay. 00:37:02.429 --> 00:37:04.973 We admit that the plaintiff did not set the idle timeout. 00:37:05.056 --> 00:37:09.018 In other words, a limit on the maximum connection time. 00:37:09.811 --> 00:37:12.605 But this is merely a violation of protocol, 00:37:12.689 --> 00:37:15.233 and thus, subject to an administrative fine of less than 30 million won, 00:37:15.316 --> 00:37:18.153 not a penalty surcharge of 300 billion won. 00:37:19.779 --> 00:37:23.491 Because there is no causation between not setting up the idle timeout 00:37:23.575 --> 00:37:25.160 and the hacking. 00:37:26.995 --> 00:37:28.663 There's no causation? 00:37:28.747 --> 00:37:29.831 No, Your Honor. 00:37:30.749 --> 00:37:34.461 There was a keylogger within the malware that the hacker installed 00:37:34.544 --> 00:37:35.920 on Mr. Choi's computer. 00:37:36.546 --> 00:37:40.633 The hacker would have been able to use this keylogger to track everything 00:37:40.717 --> 00:37:42.886 that was being typed on Mr. Choi's computer. 00:37:42.969 --> 00:37:45.972 Therefore, it would have only been a matter of time for the hacker 00:37:46.055 --> 00:37:47.932 to find out the ID and password to connect to the server. 00:37:48.016 --> 00:37:48.892 This means that 00:37:48.975 --> 00:37:52.979 even if the plaintiff had set a limit on the maximum connection time, 00:37:53.062 --> 00:37:56.441 they wouldn't have been able to prevent the personal data breach. 00:37:56.524 --> 00:38:00.528 What does the defendant think about the plaintiff's claim? 00:38:01.488 --> 00:38:03.740 The causation between a limit on the maximum connection time 00:38:03.823 --> 00:38:07.327 and the personal data breach is irrelevant. 00:38:09.078 --> 00:38:10.705 Whether there is causation or not, 00:38:10.789 --> 00:38:13.875 Raon is still subject to a penalty surcharge. 00:38:14.459 --> 00:38:16.878 -Excuse me? -Irrelevant? 00:38:18.421 --> 00:38:19.547 Why is that? 00:38:19.631 --> 00:38:21.758 Because the day the hacker broke into Raon's servers 00:38:21.841 --> 00:38:25.970 and leaked users' personal data was January 19, 2022, 00:38:26.930 --> 00:38:28.223 which was when the Act on the Information and Communications Network 00:38:28.306 --> 00:38:29.766 was partially revised. 00:38:31.351 --> 00:38:33.269 Act on Promotion of Information and Communications Network Utilization 00:38:33.353 --> 00:38:35.188 and Information Protection. 00:38:35.271 --> 00:38:38.107 Article 64-3, Paragraph 1, Item 6. 00:38:39.108 --> 00:38:41.236 Before it was revised, it was the following. 00:38:41.319 --> 00:38:43.404 "In the event in which measures to protect personal data were not taken, 00:38:43.488 --> 00:38:44.572 and therefore, the user's personal information 00:38:44.656 --> 00:38:47.534 is lost, stolen, leaked, forged, altered, or damaged." 00:38:48.243 --> 00:38:49.327 Yes, that's right. 00:38:49.994 --> 00:38:52.497 Then do you also know how it was revised? 00:38:52.580 --> 00:38:53.873 "In the event in which the user's personal data 00:38:53.957 --> 00:38:56.584 is lost, stolen, leaked, forged, altered, or damaged 00:38:56.668 --> 00:38:58.795 and no measures to protect personal data were taken." 00:39:03.091 --> 00:39:04.843 What's the difference? 00:39:05.510 --> 00:39:08.096 Isn't it just the order of the phrasing that has changed? 00:39:08.179 --> 00:39:09.264 No. 00:39:09.889 --> 00:39:10.890 Prior to the revision, 00:39:10.974 --> 00:39:14.102 if the failure to take protective measures toward personal data 00:39:14.185 --> 00:39:16.813 is what caused the breach of personal data, 00:39:16.896 --> 00:39:19.107 then a penalty surcharge would have been imposed. 00:39:19.190 --> 00:39:23.528 Thus, it was clear that the inaction had to be the cause of the breach. 00:39:23.611 --> 00:39:26.447 However, the revised law states that 00:39:26.531 --> 00:39:28.908 within a personal data breach, 00:39:29.659 --> 00:39:33.162 in any event in which protective measures toward personal data were not taken, 00:39:33.246 --> 00:39:35.039 a penalty surcharge would be imposed. 00:39:35.832 --> 00:39:39.794 Thus, if the breach and inaction are both acknowledged, 00:39:39.878 --> 00:39:42.589 the causation between the two is irrelevant. 00:39:52.599 --> 00:39:54.976 The defendant's counselor is right. 00:39:55.935 --> 00:40:00.732 The court will also be more careful in the interpretation of the legal text. 00:40:06.487 --> 00:40:07.322 Your Honor. 00:40:12.035 --> 00:40:15.079 Millions of users are deleting their Raon accounts every day. 00:40:15.705 --> 00:40:17.916 And the website that's preparing the class-action lawsuit 00:40:18.666 --> 00:40:20.668 already has more than ten million members. 00:40:20.752 --> 00:40:23.630 We're losing users while the compensation for damages is increasing. 00:40:25.048 --> 00:40:27.467 A penalty surcharge of 300 billion won? 00:40:28.092 --> 00:40:31.304 Was it that wrong for us to not have set up an idle timeout? 00:40:31.387 --> 00:40:32.263 Do we… 00:40:35.516 --> 00:40:36.559 Do we… 00:40:37.560 --> 00:40:39.520 really have to pay this big of a price? 00:40:40.104 --> 00:40:42.065 Why don't you calm down? 00:40:42.148 --> 00:40:45.360 No other company has done its best to satisfy users the way Raon has. 00:40:46.361 --> 00:40:49.405 How are we supposed to stop a hacker who is determined to break in? 00:40:50.448 --> 00:40:52.492 To be disgraced as a company that leaked the personal data 00:40:52.575 --> 00:40:54.911 of the entire country and to fall apart like this… 00:40:56.788 --> 00:40:58.206 is unfair. 00:40:59.040 --> 00:40:59.958 It… 00:41:01.334 --> 00:41:02.752 It really is… 00:41:04.045 --> 00:41:05.088 unfair! 00:41:12.720 --> 00:41:13.596 In-cheol. 00:41:18.518 --> 00:41:19.978 Hey, what did you just swallow? 00:41:20.061 --> 00:41:21.896 Spit it out, man. Hey, In-cheol. 00:41:21.980 --> 00:41:23.690 What's wrong, In-cheol? 00:41:31.698 --> 00:41:32.740 In-cheol! 00:41:34.409 --> 00:41:35.535 Help! 00:41:36.536 --> 00:41:37.370 In-cheol. 00:41:37.954 --> 00:41:38.788 In-cheol. 00:41:41.332 --> 00:41:42.792 Help, please! 00:41:42.875 --> 00:41:44.419 Go do something. Hurry. 00:41:46.796 --> 00:41:47.672 -In-cheol. -Sir. 00:41:47.755 --> 00:41:49.298 Spit it out, man. 00:41:49.382 --> 00:41:51.467 Someone, please help. 00:41:51.551 --> 00:41:52.760 Call an ambulance! 00:41:52.844 --> 00:41:53.678 Hey, In-cheol. 00:41:53.761 --> 00:41:55.013 Is he okay? 00:41:55.096 --> 00:41:57.098 Please help! 00:41:58.057 --> 00:42:00.768 In-cheol… 00:42:22.540 --> 00:42:24.917 We've done everything that was needed for now. 00:42:25.001 --> 00:42:27.795 We'll keep monitoring his condition. 00:42:27.879 --> 00:42:30.757 Okay. Can I stay here for a little while? 00:42:31.257 --> 00:42:33.468 His parents aren't here yet. 00:42:34.969 --> 00:42:37.513 And I can't just leave him alone like this. 00:42:38.097 --> 00:42:40.975 The other nurses and I will be here with him. 00:42:41.642 --> 00:42:45.063 Visiting hours aren't over yet, so of course, you can stay. 00:43:00.995 --> 00:43:03.206 How is Mr. Bae In-cheol doing? 00:43:03.873 --> 00:43:06.501 You are his attorneys, right? 00:43:07.251 --> 00:43:09.754 We gave him an antidote. 00:43:09.837 --> 00:43:12.882 But he swallowed quite a lot of cyanide. 00:43:12.965 --> 00:43:15.510 Regarding recovery, we'll have to keep observing him. 00:43:16.219 --> 00:43:18.805 I'll explain further once his family gets here. 00:43:18.888 --> 00:43:20.014 Thank you. 00:43:22.975 --> 00:43:25.394 Jun-ho, you said there were a lot of reporters outside, right? 00:43:25.478 --> 00:43:26.479 Yes. 00:43:27.063 --> 00:43:30.858 Then you should get the car out to the front. 00:43:30.942 --> 00:43:33.820 So we can get in right away without any reporters stopping us. 00:43:33.903 --> 00:43:34.904 Yes, all right. 00:43:38.282 --> 00:43:39.617 We should go too. 00:43:39.700 --> 00:43:40.618 Okay. 00:43:50.378 --> 00:43:52.964 Are those reporters out there all waiting for us? 00:43:53.965 --> 00:43:57.677 They're probably waiting for an update on how the CEO of Raon is. 00:43:57.760 --> 00:44:00.138 What are we supposed to do in this sort of situation? 00:44:00.805 --> 00:44:01.973 What do you think? 00:44:02.056 --> 00:44:03.975 Just keep your mouth shut and don't say a word. 00:44:04.892 --> 00:44:05.768 All right. 00:44:06.602 --> 00:44:07.562 Let's go. 00:44:07.645 --> 00:44:09.147 What? Okay. 00:44:21.325 --> 00:44:22.952 Are you the attorneys for Raon? 00:44:23.035 --> 00:44:24.162 How is Mr. Bae doing? 00:44:24.245 --> 00:44:25.955 When will the trial continue? 00:44:26.038 --> 00:44:27.999 Is it true Mr. Bae ingested poison? 00:44:28.082 --> 00:44:30.251 How did he bring poison into the courtroom? 00:44:30.334 --> 00:44:33.045 What exactly was the poison that Mr. Bae In-cheol ingested? 00:44:33.129 --> 00:44:35.006 -Give us a comment. -Is he awake? 00:44:35.089 --> 00:44:36.507 Get in! 00:44:36.591 --> 00:44:38.718 Excuse me, coming through. 00:44:38.801 --> 00:44:41.596 -Excuse me. -Coming through. 00:44:41.679 --> 00:44:42.930 -Excuse me. -Excuse me. 00:44:43.014 --> 00:44:44.849 -Give us a comment. -Attorney Jang? 00:44:44.932 --> 00:44:48.394 -What the… -Over here! Hurry! 00:44:49.770 --> 00:44:52.481 -Hey, wait. What is he doing? -What? 00:44:52.565 --> 00:44:54.066 -Wait. -Let's go. 00:44:54.150 --> 00:44:55.568 What about the other attorneys? 00:44:55.651 --> 00:44:58.529 It's too late for them. Drive! 00:45:00.573 --> 00:45:02.366 -What about us? -We're still here! 00:45:02.450 --> 00:45:03.826 Attorney Jang! 00:45:03.910 --> 00:45:04.785 Jun-ho! 00:45:04.869 --> 00:45:05.870 What about us? 00:45:09.206 --> 00:45:10.416 That's so petty of you. 00:45:10.499 --> 00:45:12.335 -Let's go. -This is betrayal. 00:45:12.418 --> 00:45:13.836 Coming through, excuse me. 00:45:13.920 --> 00:45:14.879 Please! 00:45:14.962 --> 00:45:16.839 Excuse me. Let us through. 00:45:32.730 --> 00:45:35.566 The food is ready. 00:45:39.654 --> 00:45:42.531 But why are we the only customers here? 00:45:42.615 --> 00:45:44.909 So that the three of you can talk comfortably. 00:45:44.992 --> 00:45:48.663 We're just being considerate of our regulars. 00:45:49.956 --> 00:45:51.749 We usually don't have any customers except for her. 00:45:51.832 --> 00:45:53.292 But that's strange. 00:45:54.543 --> 00:45:56.796 Gosh, that's hot. All of your food is so good. 00:45:56.879 --> 00:45:58.589 Especially this fish cake soup. 00:45:58.673 --> 00:46:00.174 -My goodness, Hairy Boss. -Yes. 00:46:00.257 --> 00:46:02.301 He likes the fish cake soup. Make some noise! 00:46:02.969 --> 00:46:04.095 Then it's on the house. 00:46:04.637 --> 00:46:06.555 Free food that is more expensive than the actual menu. 00:46:06.639 --> 00:46:07.682 I'll go make more. 00:46:08.641 --> 00:46:09.642 He's excited. 00:46:10.226 --> 00:46:11.185 Hey, so… 00:46:18.776 --> 00:46:23.447 Anyway, what did Attorney Jang say after singling you out? 00:46:24.156 --> 00:46:25.324 Oh, that? 00:46:26.826 --> 00:46:28.619 It was nothing. 00:46:29.412 --> 00:46:30.246 Really? 00:46:30.746 --> 00:46:33.708 I thought it was Hana University alumni getting together to scheme. 00:46:33.791 --> 00:46:37.044 Jeez, Attorney Choi. You're so prejudiced. 00:46:37.128 --> 00:46:39.839 So it's okay for SNU alumni to put their heads together, 00:46:39.922 --> 00:46:41.924 but when Hana University alumni do it, it's scheming? 00:46:42.008 --> 00:46:44.010 Put heads together? When did I do that? 00:46:44.093 --> 00:46:44.927 You just-- 00:46:45.011 --> 00:46:47.388 Causation is a principle of law. 00:46:48.514 --> 00:46:49.932 Are you talking about the case? 00:46:50.516 --> 00:46:52.935 "Criminal Law, Article 17, Causation." 00:46:53.019 --> 00:46:56.564 "Any act which is not connected with the danger which is an element of a crime 00:46:56.647 --> 00:46:58.858 shall not be punishable for the results." 00:46:58.941 --> 00:47:01.777 That doesn't pertain only to criminal law, but also to civil law. 00:47:01.861 --> 00:47:04.363 Then the administrative punishment should also be like that. 00:47:04.447 --> 00:47:06.240 To punish Raon so severely with a penalty surcharge 00:47:06.323 --> 00:47:09.493 when there is no causation between their action and the personal data breach 00:47:09.577 --> 00:47:11.370 doesn't correspond to the principles of the law. 00:47:11.454 --> 00:47:14.832 But no matter how much we claim that, if the opposing attorney says, 00:47:14.915 --> 00:47:16.417 "This trial isn't to debate 00:47:16.500 --> 00:47:18.836 the fairness of the Act on the Information and Communications Network," 00:47:18.919 --> 00:47:20.755 we can't say much else. 00:47:20.838 --> 00:47:23.007 We're not going to request an adjudication on the constitutionality of statutes. 00:47:23.716 --> 00:47:24.759 You're right. 00:47:24.842 --> 00:47:27.136 Why did the hacker have to choose that day? 00:47:27.219 --> 00:47:29.889 If it were a day earlier, it would have ended with an administrative fine. 00:47:32.516 --> 00:47:34.018 "A day earlier"? 00:47:48.282 --> 00:47:49.241 Article 64-3, Paragraph 1, Item 6 00:47:49.325 --> 00:47:51.619 of the Act on the Information and Communications Network 00:47:51.702 --> 00:47:53.746 was revised on January 19, 2022. 00:47:53.829 --> 00:47:57.249 The day the hacker got into Raon's server and stole users' personal data 00:47:57.333 --> 00:47:59.126 was also January 19, 2022. 00:47:59.210 --> 00:48:01.170 Yes, so? What is it? 00:48:01.253 --> 00:48:04.173 What day did the hacker send the email to Mr. Choi? 00:48:05.883 --> 00:48:09.720 January 18, 2022, at 11:14 p.m. 00:48:09.804 --> 00:48:13.182 Mr. Choi checked his email and downloaded the attached file 00:48:13.265 --> 00:48:16.477 on January 18, 2022, at 11:48 p.m. 00:48:16.560 --> 00:48:18.729 Wait, so then this… 00:48:19.313 --> 00:48:20.397 The hacking started 00:48:20.481 --> 00:48:24.026 a day before the Act on the Information and Communications Network was revised! 00:48:28.656 --> 00:48:33.244 Do you think this is some sort of game? 00:48:33.327 --> 00:48:36.455 The judge doesn't really like us to begin with, 00:48:36.539 --> 00:48:39.333 and you want me to lead with that nonsense? 00:48:39.959 --> 00:48:41.961 It's not nonsense. 00:48:42.044 --> 00:48:44.797 According to Article 14, Paragraph 1 of the General Act on Public Administration, 00:48:44.880 --> 00:48:46.507 one may ask for a disposition 00:48:46.590 --> 00:48:48.676 based on the law at the time of the violation. 00:48:51.137 --> 00:48:55.683 I also know Article 14, Paragraph 1 of the General Act on Public Administration, 00:48:56.267 --> 00:48:58.227 and that applies only to facts 00:48:58.310 --> 00:49:02.523 completed or terminated before the enforcement of the new law. 00:49:03.524 --> 00:49:04.900 For Raon, 00:49:04.984 --> 00:49:08.696 the hacking might have taken place before the new law was enforced, 00:49:09.196 --> 00:49:13.617 but didn't the personal data leak occur after? 00:49:14.201 --> 00:49:15.077 Didn't it? 00:49:15.161 --> 00:49:17.788 There's still room for argument. 00:49:17.872 --> 00:49:20.958 According to Article 14, Paragraph 3 of the General Act on Public Administration, 00:49:21.041 --> 00:49:23.544 even in the event in which the law before the revision needs to be applied, 00:49:23.627 --> 00:49:26.255 if the new law makes the sanctions lenient, 00:49:26.338 --> 00:49:28.215 the new law is required to be applied. 00:49:28.299 --> 00:49:31.385 For Raon, it is much more advantageous for the plaintiff 00:49:31.468 --> 00:49:33.220 if the law before the revision is applied, 00:49:33.304 --> 00:49:35.806 so there is room for adjustment according to the judge-- 00:49:35.890 --> 00:49:37.308 Stop it already! 00:49:44.315 --> 00:49:45.524 Attorney Woo. 00:49:46.233 --> 00:49:49.111 Do you know the law that well? 00:49:50.029 --> 00:49:52.907 Who do you think you are to try to teach me? 00:49:53.949 --> 00:49:56.035 If you're so great, you can do it by yourself! 00:50:04.210 --> 00:50:06.795 As of today, Attorney Woo, you are off this case. 00:50:13.677 --> 00:50:15.971 Why are you just standing there? Get out right now! 00:50:21.477 --> 00:50:23.187 Attorney Jang. 00:50:23.270 --> 00:50:24.438 What do you have to say? 00:50:24.521 --> 00:50:26.732 Yes, I'm Attorney Jang. So what? 00:50:27.399 --> 00:50:28.567 It's nothing. 00:50:29.151 --> 00:50:30.361 We'll be on our way too. 00:50:30.945 --> 00:50:31.946 But-- 00:50:41.163 --> 00:50:42.206 What's wrong with you? 00:50:42.289 --> 00:50:44.124 If you want to suck up to him, do it by yourself. 00:50:44.208 --> 00:50:46.585 Why are you stopping me from saying something? 00:50:46.669 --> 00:50:49.171 Not all of the senior attorneys we'll be working with 00:50:49.255 --> 00:50:50.965 will be like Attorney Jung. 00:50:51.465 --> 00:50:53.133 We have to learn how to act accordingly. 00:50:53.217 --> 00:50:54.969 You can learn, Attorney Kwon. 00:50:55.052 --> 00:50:56.971 Young-woo was kicked off the case for no reason. 00:50:57.054 --> 00:50:59.014 Can you still not see that we're different 00:50:59.682 --> 00:51:00.641 from Attorney Woo? 00:51:01.350 --> 00:51:02.476 What? 00:51:03.018 --> 00:51:04.061 Attorney Woo… 00:51:05.521 --> 00:51:06.522 is a genius. 00:51:08.482 --> 00:51:11.318 She can do whatever she wants and be kicked out like that, 00:51:11.402 --> 00:51:14.071 and people will think of her as a stubborn genius and understand her. 00:51:14.154 --> 00:51:15.864 But we're different. 00:51:15.948 --> 00:51:17.658 If we act like Attorney Woo, 00:51:17.741 --> 00:51:19.702 we'll be treated as juniors who can't please their seniors 00:51:19.785 --> 00:51:22.079 and who are difficult to work with. 00:51:27.334 --> 00:51:28.752 You're right. 00:51:30.337 --> 00:51:32.756 You're so right that it's getting on my nerves. 00:51:35.175 --> 00:51:38.762 But can't you just be a fool for once? 00:51:42.850 --> 00:51:43.934 "Fool"? 00:51:44.518 --> 00:51:46.020 For your colleague. 00:51:46.103 --> 00:51:47.771 For something you believe is right. 00:51:47.855 --> 00:51:49.690 Can't you put down your tactics and politics for a bit 00:51:49.773 --> 00:51:51.567 and just be brave like a fool? 00:51:51.650 --> 00:51:52.526 Why… 00:51:53.152 --> 00:51:55.029 Why should I have to do that? 00:51:55.112 --> 00:51:56.363 Because… 00:52:00.409 --> 00:52:02.244 I like guys who are like that. 00:52:52.378 --> 00:52:53.462 Attorney Woo. 00:52:55.714 --> 00:52:56.673 Yes? 00:52:59.426 --> 00:53:00.969 Why can't we be together? 00:53:03.389 --> 00:53:05.391 Why on earth do we have to break up? 00:53:07.393 --> 00:53:09.144 I've been thinking about it. 00:53:11.688 --> 00:53:13.482 But I just can't figure out why. 00:53:21.323 --> 00:53:22.408 I'm… 00:53:24.910 --> 00:53:28.789 not sure if I'm someone 00:53:28.872 --> 00:53:30.374 who can make you happy. 00:53:31.750 --> 00:53:35.087 I think I'm just someone you have to take care of. 00:53:39.967 --> 00:53:41.218 Did you hear… 00:53:44.888 --> 00:53:47.099 what my sister 00:53:48.434 --> 00:53:49.685 said to me? 00:53:52.980 --> 00:53:54.440 Is that why? 00:53:58.068 --> 00:53:59.611 Attorney Woo, 00:54:01.029 --> 00:54:03.282 I'm happy just being with you. 00:54:04.074 --> 00:54:07.453 For me to be happy, I have to be with you! 00:54:09.621 --> 00:54:11.623 But haven't you ever felt lonely 00:54:12.458 --> 00:54:14.418 when you were with me? 00:54:20.883 --> 00:54:24.178 All of my thoughts tend to center around me, 00:54:25.304 --> 00:54:28.098 so I make people close to me lonely. 00:54:29.808 --> 00:54:33.687 I don't know when or why I do that. 00:54:34.897 --> 00:54:37.649 And I don't know what I can do to stop it. 00:54:39.151 --> 00:54:40.235 I… 00:54:42.529 --> 00:54:44.406 like you. 00:54:47.451 --> 00:54:48.869 But… 00:54:50.496 --> 00:54:52.789 I'm afraid… 00:54:54.791 --> 00:54:56.001 that I'll make you lonely. 00:55:35.290 --> 00:55:36.625 What are you doing? 00:55:37.209 --> 00:55:39.044 I want to say bye to Young-woo before we leave. 00:55:39.127 --> 00:55:40.045 Say bye? 00:55:40.963 --> 00:55:43.090 Like "Bye, we're off to the trial without you"? 00:55:43.173 --> 00:55:46.385 Just get going. Why do you care if I say bye or not? 00:55:47.135 --> 00:55:49.179 Hurry up or you'll be late. 00:55:54.726 --> 00:55:55.644 Come in. 00:55:58.146 --> 00:55:59.022 Young-woo. 00:56:00.524 --> 00:56:03.110 I'll see you later. The Raon trial is today, remember? 00:56:05.362 --> 00:56:06.196 Right. 00:56:07.114 --> 00:56:09.032 Should I get you something on my way back? 00:56:09.116 --> 00:56:11.827 What about Choi Su-yeon gimbap today, instead of Woo Young-woo gimbap? 00:56:12.452 --> 00:56:14.204 There's no such thing as Choi Su-yeon gimbap. 00:56:16.415 --> 00:56:17.416 No, there isn't. 00:56:18.166 --> 00:56:19.042 I'm going now. 00:56:20.002 --> 00:56:21.044 Okay. 00:57:30.781 --> 00:57:32.366 Also, the fact that 00:57:33.241 --> 00:57:37.037 the victims are preparing for a large-scale compensation lawsuit 00:57:37.579 --> 00:57:41.625 is an overwhelming mental burden for the plaintiff. 00:57:42.167 --> 00:57:43.293 Of course, 00:57:43.377 --> 00:57:46.046 with a personal data breach, liability under public law 00:57:46.129 --> 00:57:48.423 and liability under the "jurisdiction" must both be-- 00:57:48.507 --> 00:57:50.968 Please be mindful of your pronunciation. 00:57:53.720 --> 00:57:54.680 Excuse me? 00:57:54.763 --> 00:57:56.932 You must stress the last syllable 00:57:57.015 --> 00:57:59.309 when pronouncing the Korean word for "private law." 00:57:59.393 --> 00:58:03.021 They mean completely different things based on their pronunciation. 00:58:03.814 --> 00:58:04.982 Yes. 00:58:05.065 --> 00:58:06.400 Continue. 00:58:07.317 --> 00:58:08.527 Right. 00:58:09.695 --> 00:58:10.904 How did I pronounce… 00:58:13.240 --> 00:58:14.074 Never mind. 00:58:14.157 --> 00:58:15.409 I apologize. 00:58:15.492 --> 00:58:17.327 I will correct myself. 00:58:37.097 --> 00:58:38.056 I'm sorry. 00:58:40.267 --> 00:58:41.184 Your Honor, 00:58:41.268 --> 00:58:42.519 Article 64-3, Paragraph 1, Item 6 00:58:42.602 --> 00:58:44.980 of the Act on the Information and Communications Network 00:58:45.063 --> 00:58:48.442 was revised and enforced on January 19, 2022. 00:58:48.525 --> 00:58:52.195 The hacker also got into Raon's server and stole personal data that same day. 00:58:52.279 --> 00:58:55.365 But the day the hacker sent the email with malware 00:58:55.449 --> 00:58:57.826 to the DB manager, Mr. Choi Jin-pyo, 00:58:57.909 --> 00:59:01.038 was a day earlier, January 18, 2022. 00:59:02.164 --> 00:59:03.165 And? 00:59:03.665 --> 00:59:06.168 What's your point? 00:59:06.251 --> 00:59:07.836 I'm saying that the hacking began one day 00:59:07.919 --> 00:59:10.964 before the Act on the Information and Communications Network was revised. 00:59:16.803 --> 00:59:20.390 According to Article 14 of the General Act on Public Administration, 00:59:20.474 --> 00:59:24.102 which states new laws do not apply to facts that were completed 00:59:24.186 --> 00:59:26.438 or terminated before the enforcement of the new law, 00:59:26.521 --> 00:59:27.731 the plaintiff is subject 00:59:27.814 --> 00:59:29.858 to an administrative fine, not a penalty surcharge, 00:59:29.941 --> 00:59:32.611 in accordance with the Act before its revision. 00:59:33.570 --> 00:59:35.238 Attorney Choi, what are you doing? 00:59:35.322 --> 00:59:37.491 Can't you see I'm in the middle of my closing argument? 00:59:37.574 --> 00:59:40.243 Stop it. Do you think Attorney Woo would like this? 00:59:40.327 --> 00:59:41.828 This isn't about Young-woo. 00:59:41.912 --> 00:59:43.288 I'm doing what I feel is right. 00:59:43.371 --> 00:59:48.710 Your Honor, the hacking may have begun on January 18th, 00:59:48.794 --> 00:59:52.089 but the leak of personal data happened on January 19th. 00:59:52.172 --> 00:59:55.425 After the revised Act on the Information and Communications Network was enforced. 00:59:55.509 --> 00:59:57.761 With what standard does the defendant's counselor determine 00:59:57.844 --> 01:00:00.555 to be the line between hacking and the leak of personal data? 01:00:00.639 --> 01:00:04.392 Doesn't a theft begin the moment a thief breaks into a house? 01:00:04.476 --> 01:00:05.894 Choi Su-yeon. 01:00:05.977 --> 01:00:08.605 One more word and you're off the case. Am I clear? 01:00:09.648 --> 01:00:13.443 Your Honor, Article 14 of the General Act on Public Administration, 01:00:13.527 --> 01:00:15.695 which the plaintiff's counselor mentioned as grounds for refutation, 01:00:16.488 --> 01:00:19.574 only applies to facts that were completed or terminated 01:00:19.658 --> 01:00:22.869 before the enforcement of the new law. 01:00:22.953 --> 01:00:24.955 Please make the judgment based on 01:00:25.580 --> 01:00:29.584 when the leak of personal data ended, not when the hacking began. 01:00:29.668 --> 01:00:30.502 Your… 01:00:31.169 --> 01:00:32.212 Let go! 01:00:32.295 --> 01:00:35.549 According to Article 14, Paragraph 3 of the General Act on Public Administration, 01:00:35.632 --> 01:00:37.467 even in the event in which the law before its revision needs to be applied, 01:00:37.551 --> 01:00:40.053 if the new law makes the sanctions lenient, 01:00:40.137 --> 01:00:42.139 then application of the new law is required. 01:00:43.306 --> 01:00:44.516 In this case, 01:00:44.599 --> 01:00:46.268 it is advantageous for the plaintiff 01:00:46.351 --> 01:00:47.894 if the law before the revision is applied. 01:00:48.520 --> 01:00:51.523 "When in doubt, rule for the accused," 01:00:51.606 --> 01:00:54.484 should not be a principle that only applies to criminal law. 01:00:55.318 --> 01:00:56.945 I plead for your broad generosity 01:00:57.028 --> 01:00:59.614 in understanding the plaintiff's circumstances. 01:01:11.251 --> 01:01:13.128 That is an interesting point. 01:01:13.795 --> 01:01:16.631 I'll make a decision after careful deliberation. 01:01:21.469 --> 01:01:22.470 Thank you. 01:01:23.013 --> 01:01:24.097 That is all. 01:01:46.995 --> 01:01:48.622 WOO YOUNG-WOO GIMBAP 01:01:48.705 --> 01:01:51.958 There are a few resorts across the country that can be used 01:01:52.042 --> 01:01:53.752 with the Hanbada employee membership. 01:01:53.835 --> 01:01:55.795 Pick whichever one you want, 01:01:56.755 --> 01:01:59.341 and take a couple of months off with Young-woo. 01:01:59.966 --> 01:02:01.551 Think of it as a paid vacation. 01:02:04.429 --> 01:02:06.306 Is this really necessary? 01:02:06.890 --> 01:02:08.934 I can stop it for now, 01:02:10.227 --> 01:02:12.312 but once the article is out, 01:02:12.395 --> 01:02:14.439 reporters will be all over Attorney Woo too. 01:02:16.441 --> 01:02:19.027 Just lay low until things die down. 01:02:19.110 --> 01:02:21.238 She can return to Hanbada afterward. 01:02:24.032 --> 01:02:25.033 Return? 01:02:26.993 --> 01:02:28.662 Return to Hanbada after the whole world finds out 01:02:28.745 --> 01:02:31.706 that she's Tae Su-mi's daughter who was born out of wedlock? 01:02:33.375 --> 01:02:37.504 Will she be able to have a proper career with that label on her? 01:02:39.881 --> 01:02:41.049 Look. 01:02:42.634 --> 01:02:44.719 You said you'd allow it once. 01:02:46.471 --> 01:02:49.599 You said you'd allow me to use Attorney Woo to get Tae Su-mi 01:02:50.267 --> 01:02:51.893 in return for giving her a job at Hanbada. 01:02:51.977 --> 01:02:53.561 Why are you going back on your word? 01:02:57.107 --> 01:02:58.191 Seon-young. 01:02:59.567 --> 01:03:00.860 Is there no other way? 01:03:02.654 --> 01:03:06.199 Is there really no other way besides revealing it to the press? 01:03:09.577 --> 01:03:11.413 I've put much thought into it too. 01:03:13.581 --> 01:03:15.250 As of right now, 01:03:16.960 --> 01:03:19.212 this is the best I can do 01:03:20.213 --> 01:03:21.548 for you and Attorney Woo. 01:03:46.948 --> 01:03:50.493 Raon, the online shopping mall that had a personal data breach of 40 million 01:03:50.577 --> 01:03:52.078 due to their inability to stop the hack, 01:03:52.162 --> 01:03:54.456 has won the lawsuit for the cancellation of the 300 billion won penalty surcharge 01:03:54.539 --> 01:03:58.626 imposed by the KCC. 01:03:58.710 --> 01:04:02.339 The Seoul Administrative Court cited Raon's negligence of access control, 01:04:02.422 --> 01:04:07.427 including the absence of a limit on maximum connection time, 01:04:07.510 --> 01:04:09.054 but recognized that it was not 01:04:09.137 --> 01:04:10.889 the direct cause of the personal data breach 01:04:10.972 --> 01:04:12.849 and ruled in favor of the plaintiff. 01:04:12.932 --> 01:04:16.394 Meanwhile, Raon's co-CEO, Bae In-cheol, 01:04:16.478 --> 01:04:18.938 who collapsed after ingesting poison during the trial, 01:04:19.022 --> 01:04:21.149 is receiving treatment 01:04:21.232 --> 01:04:24.235 but has been confirmed as still being unconscious. 01:04:25.236 --> 01:04:27.280 Mr. Bae had complained of the unfairness by stating 01:04:27.364 --> 01:04:30.825 "No other company has done its best to satisfy users the way Raon has," 01:04:30.909 --> 01:04:34.662 and "How are we supposed to stop a hacker who is determined to break in?" 01:04:34.746 --> 01:04:37.707 after which he ingested the poison he had prepared in advance-- 01:04:48.426 --> 01:04:51.930 The person you are trying to reach is unavailable. 01:04:52.013 --> 01:04:54.432 Please leave a message after the tone. 01:04:55.558 --> 01:04:58.395 Hey, I just saw the news. 01:04:59.771 --> 01:05:01.314 Is In-cheol still unconscious? 01:05:01.815 --> 01:05:03.274 You told me he was fine. 01:05:03.900 --> 01:05:05.735 You said he was awake now. 01:05:06.236 --> 01:05:08.446 Please answer the phone. 01:05:08.947 --> 01:05:11.449 Don't make me have to hack you to get your location too. 01:05:12.700 --> 01:05:13.827 Answer your… 01:05:19.040 --> 01:05:20.041 What is it? 01:05:20.834 --> 01:05:21.918 What do you mean? 01:05:22.585 --> 01:05:24.421 I'm home early. 01:05:24.504 --> 01:05:26.423 Let's have dinner together. 01:05:51.281 --> 01:05:53.408 Why did you come to see me? 01:05:53.491 --> 01:05:55.577 Because I don't think you'll do what my mom tells you to. 01:05:55.660 --> 01:05:56.536 Me? 01:05:56.619 --> 01:06:00.081 I'm just curious about what you decide to do, Attorney Woo. 01:06:00.165 --> 01:06:05.044 I'll meet with Attorney Tae and ask her to allow Sang-hyeon to testify in court. 01:06:05.128 --> 01:06:08.339 How are you going to convince Tae Su-mi? 01:06:08.423 --> 01:06:11.217 Will she even meet with you when her confirmation hearing is so close? 01:06:11.301 --> 01:06:13.761 You weren't a good mother to me, 01:06:13.845 --> 01:06:15.680 but at the very least, 01:06:15.763 --> 01:06:18.099 please be a good mother to Sang-hyeon.