WEBVTT 00:01:04.773 --> 00:01:07.609 -What's your name? -Gye Hyang-sim. 00:01:08.318 --> 00:01:09.570 It's "Gye," not "Gae." 00:01:09.653 --> 00:01:10.737 GUREUM ORPHANAGE 00:01:10.821 --> 00:01:11.905 Your daughter's name? 00:01:13.031 --> 00:01:14.491 Gye Ha-yun. 00:01:15.867 --> 00:01:17.911 Isn't her name so stylish? 00:01:18.620 --> 00:01:22.082 I chose Ha-yun because they said it's a popular name in Korea. 00:01:22.165 --> 00:01:23.458 Her surname is odd, 00:01:24.084 --> 00:01:27.379 so at least her name doesn't stand out and she can blend in. 00:01:28.630 --> 00:01:31.758 Isn't she heavy? Should we lay her down on the couch over there? 00:01:31.842 --> 00:01:32.926 No. 00:01:33.010 --> 00:01:34.428 It's fine. 00:01:34.511 --> 00:01:35.762 I'm going to hold her. 00:01:36.930 --> 00:01:40.309 She's so sound asleep even though it's the middle of the afternoon. 00:01:40.392 --> 00:01:41.893 I gave her medicine. 00:01:43.020 --> 00:01:45.188 Medicine? To your daughter? 00:01:45.981 --> 00:01:47.607 If Ha-yun is awake, 00:01:48.191 --> 00:01:50.110 she'll try not to be separated from me. 00:01:50.193 --> 00:01:51.361 I see. 00:01:53.405 --> 00:01:54.990 What's your address? 00:01:57.367 --> 00:02:00.412 I'm not abandoning Ha-yun. 00:02:01.163 --> 00:02:02.873 You can't put her up for adoption. 00:02:02.956 --> 00:02:05.417 I'll be back for her. 00:02:05.500 --> 00:02:06.627 All right. 00:02:07.878 --> 00:02:11.673 -But first, we need an address-- -Are you taking my words lightly? 00:02:12.966 --> 00:02:14.760 I'm not abandoning Ha-yun. 00:02:15.552 --> 00:02:17.179 I'm leaving her here temporarily 00:02:17.262 --> 00:02:18.597 because I might have to go to the correctional labor camp. 00:02:19.973 --> 00:02:21.099 Correctional labor camp? 00:02:21.183 --> 00:02:22.517 I mean prison. 00:02:23.393 --> 00:02:24.394 Prison. 00:02:27.105 --> 00:02:29.816 Are you by any chance a North Korean defector? 00:02:31.360 --> 00:02:34.946 Don't discriminate Ha-yun because she's a North Korean defector's daughter 00:02:35.030 --> 00:02:37.449 or be mean to her because she's the daughter of a criminal. 00:02:37.532 --> 00:02:40.994 I will be back for her no matter what. 00:02:43.080 --> 00:02:44.081 All right. 00:02:52.464 --> 00:02:54.633 Mom! 00:02:55.217 --> 00:02:57.052 -Mom! -You can't go alone. 00:02:57.135 --> 00:02:58.762 -Mom! -You can't go. 00:02:58.845 --> 00:03:00.013 Mom! 00:03:00.097 --> 00:03:02.099 -Ha-yun. -Mom! 00:03:02.182 --> 00:03:03.517 -Mom! -Mommy… 00:03:04.726 --> 00:03:06.228 will be back soon. 00:03:08.063 --> 00:03:10.941 Mom, don't leave! 00:03:11.024 --> 00:03:13.360 Mom! 00:03:13.443 --> 00:03:16.363 Mom! 00:03:16.446 --> 00:03:19.616 Mom! 00:03:19.699 --> 00:03:23.203 Mom! 00:03:23.286 --> 00:03:27.124 Mom! 00:03:27.207 --> 00:03:30.210 Mom! 00:03:30.293 --> 00:03:32.796 Mom! 00:03:33.338 --> 00:03:35.632 Mom! 00:03:36.341 --> 00:03:37.592 Mom! 00:03:38.802 --> 00:03:44.349 CASE 6 IF I WERE A WHALE… 00:03:51.648 --> 00:03:52.607 Right. 00:03:55.444 --> 00:03:58.155 -Yes? -Attorney Jung, you called me? 00:03:58.238 --> 00:04:02.868 Yes. Attorney Choi has a public interest case. 00:04:02.951 --> 00:04:04.786 A North Korean defector charged with injury resulting from robbery. 00:04:04.870 --> 00:04:06.830 "A North Korean defector charged with injury resulting from robbery." 00:04:06.913 --> 00:04:11.251 The way I see it, there's not a lot you can do for the case. 00:04:11.334 --> 00:04:16.131 But how should I put this? I think Attorney Choi is overly passionate. 00:04:16.798 --> 00:04:19.676 It seems she's overly empathizing with the defendant. 00:04:19.760 --> 00:04:22.345 So I was thinking you could take on the case with her 00:04:22.429 --> 00:04:23.930 and stop her, like "whoa, whoa." 00:04:24.014 --> 00:04:26.600 Like "whoa, whoa"? 00:04:26.683 --> 00:04:31.605 Yes, so cool down Attorney Choi so that she doesn't treat this case emotionally. 00:04:32.230 --> 00:04:33.523 Like this. 00:04:33.607 --> 00:04:35.108 Whoa, whoa. 00:04:35.192 --> 00:04:37.360 -Whoa, whoa. -Yes, like that. 00:04:37.444 --> 00:04:39.362 -Whoa, whoa. -Whoa, whoa. 00:04:39.446 --> 00:04:41.072 Make her relax. Whoa… 00:04:41.907 --> 00:04:43.658 All right, get going. 00:04:45.327 --> 00:04:46.787 -Whoa… -Cool her down. 00:04:47.329 --> 00:04:48.246 Whoa, whoa. 00:04:48.330 --> 00:04:50.207 Whoa, whoa. 00:04:51.500 --> 00:04:52.959 Whoa, whoa. 00:04:54.711 --> 00:04:55.837 Come in. 00:05:07.808 --> 00:05:08.767 Well… 00:05:09.559 --> 00:05:12.103 Did you not come to work or did you not go home? 00:05:12.979 --> 00:05:15.315 "Go home"? What does that mean? 00:05:15.398 --> 00:05:17.609 Is it like having a life after work? 00:05:17.692 --> 00:05:20.695 The thing that only exists in fantasies and not in real life? 00:05:20.779 --> 00:05:22.155 Well… 00:05:23.114 --> 00:05:24.157 Well… 00:05:24.866 --> 00:05:27.118 What about you? Don't you have a lot of work? 00:05:27.202 --> 00:05:28.370 Work? 00:05:28.453 --> 00:05:29.746 I do have a lot. 00:05:29.830 --> 00:05:33.124 My wrists hurt because I typed for more than ten hours yesterday. 00:05:33.208 --> 00:05:35.377 I already have Asperger's syndrome. 00:05:35.460 --> 00:05:38.755 But at this rate, I'll probably get carpal tunnel syndrome too. 00:05:38.839 --> 00:05:41.967 I started growing white nose hair from not getting sleep. 00:05:47.806 --> 00:05:50.350 I'm on the public interest case you were assigned. 00:05:50.433 --> 00:05:52.978 The North Korean defector charged with injury resulting from robbery. 00:05:53.061 --> 00:05:55.021 What? Hyang-sim's case? 00:05:55.981 --> 00:05:57.065 Hyang-sim? 00:05:57.732 --> 00:05:59.985 The defendant's name is Gye Hyang-sim. 00:06:00.068 --> 00:06:02.362 I've met her once, and she's really cool. 00:06:02.445 --> 00:06:03.738 She's like a tough older sister. 00:06:03.822 --> 00:06:07.951 Attorney Jung thinks you're overly passionate about the case. 00:06:08.577 --> 00:06:10.870 That you're overly empathizing with the defendant. 00:06:10.954 --> 00:06:12.872 -Really? -Yes. 00:06:12.956 --> 00:06:15.208 He told me to "whoa, whoa" you. 00:06:16.209 --> 00:06:17.168 Whoa, whoa. 00:06:18.336 --> 00:06:19.838 Whoa, whoa. 00:06:20.797 --> 00:06:21.923 Whoa, whoa. 00:06:22.007 --> 00:06:24.467 Young-woo. Have you ever been to a detention center? 00:06:25.468 --> 00:06:27.887 No. I haven't been to one yet. 00:06:27.971 --> 00:06:31.266 Hurry and request visitation. Let's go meet Hyang-sim. 00:06:55.915 --> 00:06:57.042 My goodness. 00:06:57.751 --> 00:06:58.960 Attorney Choi. 00:06:59.044 --> 00:07:00.587 How have you been? 00:07:01.588 --> 00:07:03.506 This is Attorney Woo. 00:07:03.590 --> 00:07:05.467 She'll be working on the case with me. 00:07:06.051 --> 00:07:08.928 Hello, I am Woo Young-woo from Hanbada Law Firm. 00:07:09.512 --> 00:07:11.181 Whether it's read straight or flipped, it's still Woo Young-woo. 00:07:11.264 --> 00:07:13.433 Kayak, deed, rotator, noon, racecar, Woo Young-woo. 00:07:13.516 --> 00:07:14.434 Right. 00:07:14.935 --> 00:07:15.936 Woo Hyang-woo? 00:07:16.519 --> 00:07:17.687 What? 00:07:17.771 --> 00:07:19.522 -No. -Why don't we 00:07:19.606 --> 00:07:21.524 sit down first? 00:07:22.233 --> 00:07:23.193 Okay. 00:07:29.783 --> 00:07:32.827 How are you doing in here? I bet it's tough. 00:07:32.911 --> 00:07:34.454 Staying in here? 00:07:34.537 --> 00:07:36.790 They feed me and put a roof over my head. 00:07:37.374 --> 00:07:38.625 This is like a hotel. 00:07:39.793 --> 00:07:42.754 I just miss my daughter, Ha-yun. 00:07:43.672 --> 00:07:45.882 That just breaks my heart a bit, that's all. 00:07:47.050 --> 00:07:49.219 Ms. Gye, I heard you're a North Korean defector, 00:07:49.302 --> 00:07:51.012 but why don't you use the dialect? 00:07:54.724 --> 00:07:56.059 Comrade Woo Hyang-woo. 00:07:56.768 --> 00:07:59.729 Why would you say that to me? It's been a while since I defected. 00:08:01.231 --> 00:08:05.694 Gosh! Detention centers in South Joseon look like hotels! 00:08:05.777 --> 00:08:07.737 Do I have to speak like this to be a North Korean defector? 00:08:08.446 --> 00:08:10.448 Right, I'm sorry. 00:08:11.116 --> 00:08:12.742 Should we talk about the case? 00:08:12.826 --> 00:08:16.037 Let's start from the beginning since this is Attorney Woo's first time. 00:08:17.998 --> 00:08:20.959 Did you and the victim, Lee Sun-yeong, know each other before the incident? 00:08:21.042 --> 00:08:24.212 No. Lee Sun-yeong is not a North Korean defector 00:08:24.295 --> 00:08:26.297 nor was there a reason for us to cross paths. 00:08:26.381 --> 00:08:28.883 The day I went to get the money was my first time meeting her. 00:08:28.967 --> 00:08:30.844 I only got to know her because Mom told me about her. 00:08:31.678 --> 00:08:33.013 Mom? 00:08:33.763 --> 00:08:35.932 Are you referring to the North Korean defector broker, Choi Yeong-hui? 00:08:36.016 --> 00:08:39.019 She's not my real mother but my foster mother. 00:08:39.561 --> 00:08:41.396 We all just call her Mom. 00:08:43.481 --> 00:08:46.151 If only Mom had paid back the money she borrowed from me. 00:08:46.818 --> 00:08:48.236 I'll summarize. 00:08:49.237 --> 00:08:51.114 Five years ago, 00:08:51.197 --> 00:08:54.701 you asked "Mom," the North Korean defector broker, Choi Yeong-hui, 00:08:54.784 --> 00:08:57.412 for the ten million won she borrowed from you. 00:08:57.495 --> 00:09:02.125 Then, rather than paying you back directly, 00:09:02.208 --> 00:09:05.587 Choi Yeong-hui told you that Lee Sun-yeong had money to give her 00:09:05.670 --> 00:09:07.630 and you could get it from her instead. 00:09:07.714 --> 00:09:09.132 Yes. 00:09:09.215 --> 00:09:13.970 The ten million won debt she owed Mom was transferred over to me and Jeong-hui. 00:09:14.054 --> 00:09:15.013 Jeong-hui? 00:09:15.764 --> 00:09:17.640 Ms. Kim Jeong-hui, your accomplice? 00:09:18.349 --> 00:09:19.476 Comrade Woo Hyang-woo. 00:09:20.602 --> 00:09:23.021 Does your head hurt because there are too many people involved? 00:09:23.646 --> 00:09:24.606 No. 00:09:25.148 --> 00:09:27.442 You were friends with Ms. Kim Jeong-hui, correct? 00:09:27.525 --> 00:09:30.361 Well, we aren't really friends. 00:09:31.196 --> 00:09:33.865 We came to know each other through Mom. 00:09:33.948 --> 00:09:35.617 So I just call her my friend. 00:09:36.659 --> 00:09:39.454 She's also a North Korean defector and is the same age as me. 00:09:39.537 --> 00:09:43.374 You were going to split the money with her once Lee Sun-yeong gave it to you? 00:09:43.458 --> 00:09:46.544 Yes! The problem was, would Lee Sun-yeong 00:09:46.628 --> 00:09:50.298 just hand us the money she didn't even give to Mom? 00:09:50.381 --> 00:09:52.759 If we wanted to stop her from lying about not having the money, 00:09:52.842 --> 00:09:55.678 we couldn't look like people she could take advantage of. 00:10:11.111 --> 00:10:14.739 Goodness, she doesn't even lock her door. 00:10:14.823 --> 00:10:16.032 Is she not afraid? 00:10:16.116 --> 00:10:18.076 She's very brave. 00:10:18.159 --> 00:10:20.995 Jeong-hui, be on your toes. 00:10:21.079 --> 00:10:23.039 She won't give us the money easily. 00:10:23.665 --> 00:10:27.168 You can tell how fierce she is since she didn't even pay Mom back, right? 00:10:27.252 --> 00:10:30.046 Speak for yourself. You're way too soft. 00:10:30.130 --> 00:10:33.174 There's no one else as fierce as me on the Korean Peninsula. 00:10:33.258 --> 00:10:34.259 Let's go. 00:10:37.887 --> 00:10:38.930 Grab one. 00:10:44.060 --> 00:10:45.436 Lee Sun-yeong! 00:10:47.021 --> 00:10:48.189 Come out right now! 00:10:48.273 --> 00:10:49.315 Come out! 00:10:49.399 --> 00:10:50.358 Where are you? 00:10:53.611 --> 00:10:54.612 You. 00:10:56.156 --> 00:10:57.365 Hand over Mom's money! 00:10:58.158 --> 00:11:00.869 -What money? -"What money?" 00:11:05.832 --> 00:11:08.918 You pocketed Mom's ten million won and you're not paying it back. 00:11:09.002 --> 00:11:09.919 You. 00:11:11.296 --> 00:11:13.173 Where did you hide the money? 00:11:13.798 --> 00:11:15.383 Is it in that room? 00:11:15.466 --> 00:11:16.509 No. 00:11:18.428 --> 00:11:21.264 Please, let it go this one time. I'm in a difficult situation. 00:11:24.183 --> 00:11:26.060 Hey, you thieving *! 00:11:26.144 --> 00:11:27.812 You think we're doing this because our situation is any better? 00:11:27.896 --> 00:11:29.522 Right, step aside! 00:11:29.606 --> 00:11:31.733 No, you can't! 00:11:31.816 --> 00:11:33.067 Let go! 00:11:34.193 --> 00:11:36.905 No. You can't. 00:11:37.405 --> 00:11:38.448 What are you doing? 00:11:40.533 --> 00:11:42.952 Hey, let go! 00:11:43.786 --> 00:11:44.954 Let go of me! 00:11:46.080 --> 00:11:47.999 -Darn it. -Hey! 00:11:48.082 --> 00:11:53.588 Lee Sun-yeong, just hand over the money! 00:11:53.671 --> 00:11:57.800 Gosh, it's so loud. I've had enough of this. 00:11:58.468 --> 00:11:59.844 Hello? Is this the police? 00:11:59.928 --> 00:12:02.889 -I don't have the money! -This is 52 Dongbaek-gil. 00:12:02.972 --> 00:12:05.683 The people upstairs are being loud again! 00:12:05.767 --> 00:12:08.186 I can't sleep. Please hurry. 00:12:09.020 --> 00:12:09.979 Gosh. 00:12:10.688 --> 00:12:11.606 Let go! 00:12:11.689 --> 00:12:15.568 The police came because the landlord who lived below the victim reported it. 00:12:15.652 --> 00:12:19.280 Then you and Ms. Kim Jeong-hui were arrested on-site, right? 00:12:20.073 --> 00:12:23.117 To be honest, we didn't beat her up that much. 00:12:23.910 --> 00:12:27.330 But the police saw shattered glass, 00:12:27.413 --> 00:12:29.916 a stick rolling around, and a stone brick, 00:12:30.667 --> 00:12:32.418 so it must've seemed pretty severe. 00:12:32.502 --> 00:12:36.339 At the time, you applied for a jury trial with Ms. Kim Jeong-hui. 00:12:36.422 --> 00:12:37.882 Ms. Kim Jeong-hui appeared in court 00:12:37.966 --> 00:12:39.634 and received a four-year sentence for injury resulting from robbery, 00:12:39.717 --> 00:12:41.761 but you fled before the trial. 00:12:41.844 --> 00:12:43.012 Why did you do that? 00:12:43.805 --> 00:12:44.806 Four years… 00:12:48.726 --> 00:12:50.812 Then Jeong-hui must be out already. 00:12:50.895 --> 00:12:52.772 Yes, probably. 00:12:53.398 --> 00:12:54.941 Why did you run away? 00:12:56.901 --> 00:12:58.528 Jeong-hui doesn't have any kids. 00:12:59.404 --> 00:13:00.905 But I have a daughter. 00:13:06.285 --> 00:13:08.496 Ha-yun was only three years old at the time. 00:13:08.997 --> 00:13:12.333 If I got sent to the correctional labor camp, she would've been abandoned. 00:13:14.168 --> 00:13:15.670 I'm a North Korean defector, 00:13:16.838 --> 00:13:18.131 so we have no one. 00:13:20.091 --> 00:13:21.968 Mom's not my real mom. 00:13:22.969 --> 00:13:25.096 And my friend isn't my real friend. 00:13:26.889 --> 00:13:31.894 Ha-yun's dad passed away from a car accident soon after she was born. 00:13:32.729 --> 00:13:36.315 Without me, there wouldn't have been anyone to take care of my daughter. 00:13:38.860 --> 00:13:40.236 What about now? 00:13:40.319 --> 00:13:41.988 Where's Ha-yun now? 00:13:42.071 --> 00:13:43.364 I left her at the orphanage. 00:13:44.115 --> 00:13:45.867 Then I went to the police station. 00:13:45.950 --> 00:13:49.537 Couldn't you have left her at an orphanage five years ago? 00:13:49.620 --> 00:13:53.041 If I left her then, Ha-yun would've forgotten about me 00:13:53.124 --> 00:13:54.375 because she was too young. 00:13:55.918 --> 00:13:59.505 She's eight now, so when I go back to get her, 00:14:00.423 --> 00:14:01.758 she'll remember her mom. 00:14:02.383 --> 00:14:05.303 Did you run away so that you could raise her until she reached an age 00:14:05.386 --> 00:14:06.596 where she could remember her mother? 00:14:07.263 --> 00:14:08.306 Yes. 00:14:09.182 --> 00:14:12.393 And now, Ha-yun has to attend school, 00:14:13.436 --> 00:14:15.563 so she can't keep living as the daughter of a fugitive. 00:14:15.646 --> 00:14:18.858 It's only right that I hurry and go to prison and return. 00:14:20.401 --> 00:14:21.694 Like a mother whale. 00:14:22.487 --> 00:14:23.446 What? 00:14:24.906 --> 00:14:27.784 The maternal instincts of a whale are famous for their devotion. 00:14:27.867 --> 00:14:28.993 They have to be. 00:14:29.077 --> 00:14:32.830 Because there aren't that many safe places in the ocean to raise babies. 00:14:35.541 --> 00:14:38.086 How did you get by after you ran away? 00:14:38.169 --> 00:14:40.838 In those five years, you wouldn't have received national subsidies 00:14:40.922 --> 00:14:42.215 and it would've been difficult to get a job. 00:14:42.298 --> 00:14:43.758 I cleaned at a motel, 00:14:44.842 --> 00:14:47.553 got a spare room, and lived there with Ha-yun. 00:14:48.304 --> 00:14:49.555 I feel bad 00:14:50.181 --> 00:14:51.557 when I think about that. 00:14:52.475 --> 00:14:55.269 Other kids go to kindergarten 00:14:56.270 --> 00:14:57.730 and daycare centers. 00:14:59.148 --> 00:15:01.317 But Ha-yun was stuck in a motel room all day 00:15:02.110 --> 00:15:04.278 because I was her mom. 00:15:13.579 --> 00:15:16.457 I'm sure she was happy because she was with her mom. 00:15:17.333 --> 00:15:18.251 You think so? 00:15:19.836 --> 00:15:21.421 Would she really think that? 00:15:22.922 --> 00:15:24.966 Yes, she would have. 00:15:30.430 --> 00:15:32.306 I was wondering 00:15:32.807 --> 00:15:34.809 if I get a four-year sentence like Jeong-hui, 00:15:36.060 --> 00:15:39.188 could you come visit at least once? 00:15:40.189 --> 00:15:41.399 I know you must be busy, 00:15:42.024 --> 00:15:44.068 but just once with Ha-yun. 00:15:47.864 --> 00:15:51.659 Don't be so weak-minded! There will be no four-year sentence. 00:15:56.414 --> 00:15:59.375 Ms. Gye Hyang-sim must get probation! 00:16:00.543 --> 00:16:03.796 We will do everything in our power to get the defendant probation. 00:16:06.632 --> 00:16:07.884 That was passionate. 00:16:08.926 --> 00:16:12.180 Does the defendant have some kind of irresistible charm? 00:16:12.263 --> 00:16:15.475 Because it seems that everyone she encounters becomes so heated. 00:16:15.558 --> 00:16:17.768 What happened to the "whoa, whoa" mission? 00:16:20.438 --> 00:16:21.564 For an attorney, 00:16:21.647 --> 00:16:24.942 defending this charge is as difficult as defending murder. 00:16:25.026 --> 00:16:26.652 Any guess as to why? 00:16:26.736 --> 00:16:29.197 -Because the statutory penalty is high? -Correct. 00:16:29.280 --> 00:16:31.365 What is the statutory penalty for injury resulting from robbery? 00:16:31.449 --> 00:16:33.534 A life sentence or at least seven years of imprisonment. 00:16:33.618 --> 00:16:35.495 To repeat, at least seven years. 00:16:35.578 --> 00:16:39.040 What's the maximum amount that can be reduced at the discretion of the judge? 00:16:39.123 --> 00:16:40.416 Mitigation of punishments in extenuating circumstances 00:16:40.500 --> 00:16:41.709 cannot exceed the range of statutory mitigation, 00:16:41.792 --> 00:16:44.462 and with a fixed sentence, it is limited to half of the term of imprisonment, 00:16:44.545 --> 00:16:46.088 so at least 3 years and 6 months. 00:16:46.172 --> 00:16:49.759 However, to get probation, the sentence has to be less than three years. 00:16:49.842 --> 00:16:52.970 So if you don't find reasons for not only mitigation in extenuating circumstances 00:16:53.054 --> 00:16:55.890 but also statutory mitigation to get it reduced even more, 00:16:55.973 --> 00:16:57.808 you won't be able to get probation. 00:16:57.892 --> 00:17:00.978 That's why they say injury resulting from robbery always ends up with prison time. 00:17:01.062 --> 00:17:03.272 And on top of that, the defendant ran away. 00:17:03.898 --> 00:17:06.067 If anything, that could lead to additional punishment. 00:17:09.237 --> 00:17:10.279 All right. 00:17:10.363 --> 00:17:12.657 This case is quite odd. 00:17:12.740 --> 00:17:15.826 We haven't even started, but the answers are already there. 00:17:15.910 --> 00:17:17.995 It's as if the defendant already had her trial. 00:17:18.621 --> 00:17:20.164 Because there was an accomplice? 00:17:20.248 --> 00:17:21.249 Yes. 00:17:21.332 --> 00:17:24.961 Ms. Gye Hyang-sim and Ms. Kim Jeong-hui's issues are almost identical. 00:17:25.545 --> 00:17:27.713 By being tried first, Ms. Kim Jeong-hui already 00:17:27.797 --> 00:17:29.257 claimed everything that could be claimed 00:17:29.340 --> 00:17:31.217 and everything that could be dismissed has already been dismissed. 00:17:31.300 --> 00:17:32.802 And the answer… 00:17:33.928 --> 00:17:35.137 was a four-year sentence. 00:17:35.221 --> 00:17:38.808 Ms. Gye Hyang-sim testified that she only held onto the victim's clothes 00:17:38.891 --> 00:17:40.268 and hit her a couple of times. 00:17:40.351 --> 00:17:44.313 What if we claim that this can't be legally seen as bodily harm? 00:17:50.069 --> 00:17:52.989 Here. The victim was hurt badly. What are you talking about? 00:17:53.072 --> 00:17:55.032 But sir, 00:17:55.116 --> 00:17:58.119 seeing this now, her injuries are too severe. 00:17:59.453 --> 00:18:01.455 The defendant has a small frame. 00:18:01.539 --> 00:18:03.916 Of course, her accomplice might be a bit bigger, 00:18:04.000 --> 00:18:07.003 but even so, two women hit her with their bare hands. 00:18:07.086 --> 00:18:09.922 And they were arrested by the police not long after they arrived there. 00:18:10.006 --> 00:18:14.343 They wouldn't have had much time to cause injuries that severe. 00:18:15.595 --> 00:18:18.848 All right. I guess it's necessary to look into what really happened. 00:18:18.931 --> 00:18:23.352 Yes. And we plan on meeting with the attorney who defended Ms. Kim Jeong-hui. 00:18:23.436 --> 00:18:26.772 There could be something from the earlier trial that they had missed. 00:18:26.856 --> 00:18:29.233 Okay, it's not a bad idea, 00:18:30.067 --> 00:18:33.321 but time is the most important resource to an attorney. 00:18:34.196 --> 00:18:37.241 Balance it well so you don't spend too much time on this one case. 00:18:37.325 --> 00:18:39.201 -I will. -Yes, I understand. 00:18:42.204 --> 00:18:43.289 Get her to cool down. 00:18:43.914 --> 00:18:44.749 I will. 00:18:50.463 --> 00:18:51.589 Hey, Min-woo. 00:18:53.090 --> 00:18:54.550 I'm going to tell you a story. 00:18:54.634 --> 00:18:56.927 There's this person. 00:18:57.720 --> 00:18:58.971 There's a person. 00:18:59.055 --> 00:19:03.017 And I think I'm making 00:19:03.684 --> 00:19:07.229 that person think 00:19:08.147 --> 00:19:10.399 that I don't like the person. 00:19:10.483 --> 00:19:12.193 When you actually do like the person? 00:19:13.444 --> 00:19:14.362 Yes. 00:19:14.445 --> 00:19:17.365 What's the matter? Just tell the person how you feel. 00:19:18.658 --> 00:19:19.659 But… 00:19:21.077 --> 00:19:22.912 it's not that simple. 00:19:22.995 --> 00:19:23.954 Why? 00:19:25.456 --> 00:19:26.666 Is it an office romance? 00:19:30.127 --> 00:19:33.172 What is there to worry about when you're the most popular guy at Hanbada? 00:19:34.965 --> 00:19:37.968 Hey, Jun-ho. Just give them each a number first. 00:19:38.052 --> 00:19:40.638 Number one, two, and three. 00:19:40.721 --> 00:19:44.100 -And date all of them in order. -You're talking nonsense. 00:19:44.183 --> 00:19:45.393 Forget it. 00:19:45.476 --> 00:19:47.395 I'm not talking to you. Hand me the bottle. 00:19:49.772 --> 00:19:51.524 -Is the person an attorney? -Hey. 00:19:51.607 --> 00:19:54.026 Does that matter? 00:19:54.860 --> 00:19:57.655 It's just someone 00:19:58.322 --> 00:20:02.284 who I see often. 00:20:02.368 --> 00:20:04.578 Goodness! She's in litigation? 00:20:05.621 --> 00:20:07.957 Jeez, let me see. 00:20:08.040 --> 00:20:10.543 It can't be Woo Young-woo. 00:20:11.419 --> 00:20:13.045 Gosh! I told you to forget it. 00:20:14.255 --> 00:20:15.381 You. 00:20:15.464 --> 00:20:16.716 You know what? 00:20:17.258 --> 00:20:19.260 You're an idiot. 00:20:19.343 --> 00:20:21.554 You're an idiot who's only focused on who it is. 00:20:21.637 --> 00:20:23.139 Forget it. Just go to sleep. 00:20:23.222 --> 00:20:25.766 I'm just trying to help you. 00:20:25.850 --> 00:20:28.519 But I can only help if I know who it is. 00:20:30.062 --> 00:20:32.273 Hey, tell me. 00:20:33.899 --> 00:20:34.775 Jun-ho. 00:20:35.359 --> 00:20:37.069 I actually know everything though. 00:20:38.279 --> 00:20:40.990 I can see what's going on. 00:20:42.950 --> 00:20:44.034 Choi… 00:20:49.039 --> 00:20:52.877 You heard what the judge said, right? You have to come here again in two weeks. 00:20:52.960 --> 00:20:53.836 -Yes. -Okay. 00:20:53.919 --> 00:20:56.881 Give me some change, will you? I don't have money to get home. 00:20:57.548 --> 00:20:58.591 Here we go again. 00:20:58.674 --> 00:21:01.260 Why do you need money to get home when you don't even have a home? 00:21:01.343 --> 00:21:02.470 Go on. 00:21:07.349 --> 00:21:08.559 Attorney Kwon Ju-ho? 00:21:09.685 --> 00:21:11.437 I'm Choi Su-yeon. I contacted you. 00:21:11.520 --> 00:21:13.022 This is Attorney Woo Young-woo. 00:21:13.105 --> 00:21:14.023 Hanbada? 00:21:14.106 --> 00:21:17.109 Yes, I contacted you because of a case you were on five years ago. 00:21:17.193 --> 00:21:19.653 The one for Ms. Gye Hyang-sim and Ms. Kim Jeong-hui. 00:21:19.737 --> 00:21:22.823 I have another trial. Should we talk on my way there? 00:21:22.907 --> 00:21:23.824 Yes. 00:21:25.659 --> 00:21:27.661 Did Ms. Gye Hyang-sim resurface? 00:21:28.454 --> 00:21:30.498 At the time, she fled without going on trial. 00:21:30.581 --> 00:21:31.665 Yes, that's right. 00:21:32.374 --> 00:21:35.002 But I'm not sure if I'd be of any help. 00:21:35.085 --> 00:21:38.005 It's a case from five years ago, so I don't really remember much. 00:21:38.088 --> 00:21:42.426 Besides, public defenders take on so many cases 00:21:42.510 --> 00:21:45.638 that it's like we work on cases just to get them out of the way. 00:21:46.347 --> 00:21:48.599 Doesn't that make you wish you had done something? 00:21:48.682 --> 00:21:51.185 Perhaps something you wanted to look into 00:21:51.268 --> 00:21:52.895 or things that you had no choice but to pass over. 00:21:53.521 --> 00:21:54.647 I'm not sure. 00:21:54.730 --> 00:21:56.524 Ms. Gye Hyang-sim's frame is on the smaller side. 00:21:56.607 --> 00:21:58.025 How was Ms. Kim Jeong-hui? 00:21:59.109 --> 00:22:00.194 Her size? 00:22:01.028 --> 00:22:03.113 From what I recall, they were both small. 00:22:04.740 --> 00:22:07.743 These are pictures taken of the victim at the time of the incident. 00:22:07.827 --> 00:22:08.994 Do you remember? 00:22:09.078 --> 00:22:10.871 Aren't these injuries too severe 00:22:10.955 --> 00:22:14.458 to be the outcome of two small women in such a short period? 00:22:14.542 --> 00:22:16.377 You're right. 00:22:17.253 --> 00:22:18.337 But, you do know 00:22:18.420 --> 00:22:21.882 that the most powerful and hardest to flip in a criminal trial is… 00:22:21.966 --> 00:22:23.092 Is? 00:22:23.175 --> 00:22:24.468 A doctor's diagnosis. 00:22:25.094 --> 00:22:26.720 But if you think about it, 00:22:26.804 --> 00:22:29.014 most of the diagnoses used in criminal trials 00:22:29.098 --> 00:22:31.976 are clinical speculation written based on what the patient says. 00:22:32.685 --> 00:22:36.188 So not many of them have objective test results to back them up. 00:22:36.855 --> 00:22:40.276 Which is why it's natural for there to be questionable and ambiguous parts, 00:22:40.859 --> 00:22:43.529 but it's usually difficult to refute. 00:22:45.698 --> 00:22:46.740 Right. 00:22:47.533 --> 00:22:51.453 Now that I think of it, I think the doctor was a bit biased. 00:22:52.037 --> 00:22:52.997 The doctor? 00:22:53.080 --> 00:22:55.666 The doctor who wrote the diagnosis for the victim. 00:22:56.250 --> 00:22:58.961 A while after the trial, I was reading the newspaper 00:22:59.044 --> 00:23:01.088 and coincidentally saw a piece that he wrote. 00:23:01.755 --> 00:23:05.175 It was about North Korean defectors. How should I put this? 00:23:05.259 --> 00:23:07.845 The content seemed to be biased against North Korean defectors. 00:23:07.928 --> 00:23:10.389 Do you remember the title of the piece? 00:23:10.472 --> 00:23:12.349 Just a moment, let me look it up. 00:23:16.687 --> 00:23:17.896 Here it is. 00:23:18.480 --> 00:23:22.735 "A Korean woman who was assaulted by North Korean defectors came to see me." 00:23:22.818 --> 00:23:24.194 He's talking about this case. 00:23:24.278 --> 00:23:27.072 I felt a bit bitter after reading this. 00:23:27.156 --> 00:23:30.075 In a case where all the defendants were North Korean defectors, 00:23:30.159 --> 00:23:34.622 I thought, "Why did it have to be a person like him who wrote the diagnosis?" 00:23:40.586 --> 00:23:41.837 Lee Sun-yeong's house is… 00:23:46.175 --> 00:23:48.594 Lee Sun-yeong's house is on the second floor, right? 00:23:48.677 --> 00:23:50.137 Yes, should we go up? 00:23:50.220 --> 00:23:51.096 Yes. 00:23:52.097 --> 00:23:52.931 Damn it. 00:23:53.932 --> 00:23:55.559 This damn household. 00:23:56.226 --> 00:23:58.729 Where are you going? 00:23:58.812 --> 00:23:59.813 Let go. 00:24:02.066 --> 00:24:03.484 Let go! 00:24:03.567 --> 00:24:04.777 Young-woo, are you okay? 00:24:06.195 --> 00:24:07.946 You can't take that money! 00:24:08.030 --> 00:24:08.947 Damn it, you brat. 00:24:17.748 --> 00:24:19.583 Don't be so dramatic. 00:24:28.342 --> 00:24:29.677 We have to call the police. 00:24:29.760 --> 00:24:31.720 -I can't deal with this anymore. -Hold on. 00:24:31.804 --> 00:24:33.347 I think someone's already making a call. 00:24:33.430 --> 00:24:36.058 Is this the police? This is 52 Dongbaek-gil. 00:24:36.558 --> 00:24:39.269 I'm about to go mad because of how loud they are upstairs! 00:24:39.353 --> 00:24:40.896 Hurry and send someone over. 00:24:41.897 --> 00:24:44.149 It happens far too often. 00:24:44.233 --> 00:24:45.317 Hurry! 00:24:49.113 --> 00:24:50.739 Ms. Lee Sun-yeong. 00:24:50.823 --> 00:24:52.574 Ms. Lee Sun-yeong. 00:24:52.658 --> 00:24:55.285 We're attorneys representing Ms. Gye Hyang-sim. 00:24:55.869 --> 00:24:57.663 We would like to talk to you. 00:24:59.123 --> 00:25:00.332 If I die early, 00:25:00.416 --> 00:25:02.292 -Ms. Lee Sun-yeong. -it's because of the man upstairs. 00:25:02.376 --> 00:25:04.753 Breaking, smashing and throwing things every day. 00:25:04.837 --> 00:25:07.965 I might die soon because my heart keeps trembling. 00:25:08.549 --> 00:25:12.052 I wanted to kick them out in whatever way I could, 00:25:12.136 --> 00:25:14.763 but I pity the wife who gets beaten up. 00:25:14.847 --> 00:25:19.643 And before I knew it, it's been five tiresome years! 00:25:19.727 --> 00:25:22.646 So did you call the police every time they were like that? 00:25:22.730 --> 00:25:23.772 I did. 00:25:23.856 --> 00:25:27.609 Do you think that wife-beating punk listens to me when I try to stop him? 00:25:27.693 --> 00:25:30.779 But he calms down when the police get here. 00:25:30.863 --> 00:25:32.614 Even if it's only for a little while. 00:25:32.698 --> 00:25:36.452 Then you must've called the police on them five years ago too. 00:25:36.535 --> 00:25:37.494 Of course! 00:25:37.578 --> 00:25:41.165 So when I call and just give them my address now, 00:25:41.248 --> 00:25:42.916 the precinct sends the police to me 00:25:43.000 --> 00:25:45.878 as if they're delivering jjajangmyeon. 00:25:49.256 --> 00:25:51.467 Where's Lee Sun-yeong? Did you meet her? 00:25:51.550 --> 00:25:53.677 No, there's no answer. 00:25:53.761 --> 00:25:55.888 Gosh, do you think she'd want to show her face 00:25:55.971 --> 00:25:58.182 when she gets beaten up by her husband like that? 00:25:58.265 --> 00:26:00.058 I'm sick of this. 00:26:01.643 --> 00:26:04.730 I think the landlord called the police whenever there was a ruckus. 00:26:04.813 --> 00:26:08.650 Then wouldn't there be records of her reports before the incident too? 00:26:08.734 --> 00:26:11.695 You're right. We should secure the report records. 00:26:22.998 --> 00:26:24.374 -Are you… -Young-woo. 00:26:35.135 --> 00:26:37.137 Please text me after you send it. 00:26:37.221 --> 00:26:38.096 All right. 00:26:39.014 --> 00:26:40.140 My goodness. 00:26:40.641 --> 00:26:42.059 What do you think about Jun-ho? 00:26:42.768 --> 00:26:45.938 -What? -How do you feel about Jun-ho as a man? 00:26:47.272 --> 00:26:49.399 You must have a lot of free time these days. 00:26:50.234 --> 00:26:53.612 I really think the person Jun-ho likes is you, Attorney Choi. 00:26:54.488 --> 00:26:55.364 What? 00:26:55.447 --> 00:26:56.532 Works at Hanbada, 00:26:56.615 --> 00:26:59.618 an attorney on the litigation team, and someone who he sees often. 00:26:59.701 --> 00:27:00.786 That's Choi Su-yeon. 00:27:02.287 --> 00:27:03.205 Why? 00:27:03.705 --> 00:27:06.625 You don't like Jun-ho because he's not an attorney? 00:27:12.089 --> 00:27:15.300 Did Jun-ho say something about me? 00:27:15.384 --> 00:27:16.593 To you? 00:27:16.677 --> 00:27:17.928 I mean, 00:27:20.430 --> 00:27:23.725 we live together so we talk about a lot of things together. 00:27:24.351 --> 00:27:25.269 Are you curious? 00:27:26.186 --> 00:27:27.396 No. 00:27:35.279 --> 00:27:38.699 Therefore, we would like to summon the victim, Lee Sun-yeong, as a witness. 00:27:39.575 --> 00:27:40.576 Your Honor, 00:27:41.410 --> 00:27:43.537 the victim already completed cross-examination 00:27:43.620 --> 00:27:44.997 at the trial five years ago. 00:27:45.581 --> 00:27:50.586 Summoning the victim once again as a witness is unnecessary and unfair. 00:27:50.669 --> 00:27:53.922 The defendant ran away and then came back as she pleased, 00:27:54.006 --> 00:27:56.550 what right does she have to make the victim come and go? 00:27:56.633 --> 00:27:57.801 This is secondary-- 00:27:57.885 --> 00:28:00.846 It is the people's basic right to get a fair trial. 00:28:00.929 --> 00:28:03.849 Is the defendant who fled and came back not a citizen of Korea? 00:28:03.932 --> 00:28:05.517 -The victim-- -Just a moment. 00:28:06.685 --> 00:28:10.355 What is your family origin? 00:28:11.857 --> 00:28:15.277 -Excuse me? -Your family origin. Your surname. 00:28:15.360 --> 00:28:17.738 Right. It is the Woo family of Danyang. 00:28:17.821 --> 00:28:20.657 Danyang is in Chungcheongbuk-do, right? 00:28:21.742 --> 00:28:25.662 But why are you in such a rush that you're cutting off other people's words? 00:28:25.746 --> 00:28:27.789 That's very unlike someone from Chungcheong-do. 00:28:28.999 --> 00:28:32.210 -Excuse me? -Cutting people off doesn't look good. 00:28:32.294 --> 00:28:33.295 Don't do it. 00:28:33.378 --> 00:28:35.797 In this courtroom where I am the presiding judge, 00:28:36.465 --> 00:28:38.216 cutting people off is prohibited. 00:28:39.176 --> 00:28:40.802 Right. Okay. 00:28:40.886 --> 00:28:43.096 Your Honor, with all due respect, 00:28:43.180 --> 00:28:46.141 isn't your family origin the Ryu family of Pungsan? 00:28:46.808 --> 00:28:48.810 How did you know? 00:28:49.478 --> 00:28:51.563 The Ryu family of Pungsan is one with a long and rich history, 00:28:51.647 --> 00:28:54.900 located in Andong Hahoe Folk Village, right? 00:28:55.567 --> 00:28:58.904 You just give off that kind of impression. 00:28:59.696 --> 00:29:00.614 Is that so? 00:29:00.697 --> 00:29:02.407 My family origin is the Kim family of Andong, 00:29:02.491 --> 00:29:06.036 and since Pungsan is a part of the city of Andong, broadly speaking, 00:29:06.119 --> 00:29:09.539 we are from the same hometown. 00:29:10.290 --> 00:29:12.417 Yes, that's true. 00:29:12.501 --> 00:29:13.669 Yes. 00:29:13.752 --> 00:29:14.878 Nice to meet you. 00:29:14.962 --> 00:29:16.004 Yes, nice to meet you. 00:29:17.089 --> 00:29:20.801 Your Honor, about summoning the victim, Lee Sun-yeong, as a witness-- 00:29:20.884 --> 00:29:22.886 What is your family origin, Attorney? 00:29:22.970 --> 00:29:24.513 Your Honor. 00:29:24.596 --> 00:29:27.391 You just cut another person off while she was speaking. 00:29:27.474 --> 00:29:28.350 I beg your pardon? 00:29:29.434 --> 00:29:31.520 In this courtroom where you are the presiding judge, 00:29:31.603 --> 00:29:33.146 cutting people off is prohibited. 00:29:33.230 --> 00:29:34.481 It is against the rules. 00:29:47.619 --> 00:29:49.997 From now until the trial is over, 00:29:50.080 --> 00:29:53.000 attorneys must raise their hands if they have something to say. 00:29:53.709 --> 00:29:56.128 You cannot speak without my permission. 00:29:59.631 --> 00:30:00.799 What is it? 00:30:01.675 --> 00:30:03.802 Your Honor, my family origin 00:30:04.678 --> 00:30:06.179 is the Choi family of Wonju. 00:30:08.265 --> 00:30:11.476 Judge Choi Bo-yeon, whose office is on the same floor as yours, 00:30:11.560 --> 00:30:13.228 also originates from the Choi family of Wonju. 00:30:14.229 --> 00:30:15.230 He… 00:30:16.440 --> 00:30:17.941 is my father. 00:30:19.151 --> 00:30:20.152 What? 00:30:21.111 --> 00:30:23.155 You're Chief Judge Choi's daughter? 00:30:23.780 --> 00:30:25.782 -Yes. -Gosh. 00:30:25.866 --> 00:30:29.828 Chief Judge Choi is a dear junior colleague of mine. 00:30:30.787 --> 00:30:33.081 We even have dinner together from time to time. 00:30:33.165 --> 00:30:35.834 I heard in passing that his son is a doctor. 00:30:35.917 --> 00:30:37.711 I see his daughter is an attorney. 00:30:39.796 --> 00:30:43.175 It seems like he raised his children well. 00:30:43.258 --> 00:30:44.426 I envy him. 00:30:44.509 --> 00:30:45.385 Thank you. 00:30:45.469 --> 00:30:47.804 I will send your regards to him. 00:30:47.888 --> 00:30:49.848 Yes, all right. 00:30:52.017 --> 00:30:53.769 My goodness. 00:30:53.852 --> 00:30:55.520 What were we discussing? 00:30:55.604 --> 00:30:58.023 We were discussing the summoning of the victim as a witness. 00:30:58.106 --> 00:31:00.609 Right. Let's do that. 00:31:00.692 --> 00:31:01.818 Excuse me? 00:31:03.570 --> 00:31:06.698 We're going through with the trial so we might as well do it properly. 00:31:06.782 --> 00:31:08.658 Is there something wrong? 00:31:08.742 --> 00:31:09.910 Well… 00:31:10.827 --> 00:31:13.288 No, sir. 00:31:23.924 --> 00:31:26.093 So, I was right. It is her. 00:31:26.927 --> 00:31:28.762 Don't they look good together? 00:31:30.806 --> 00:31:32.599 They're such a good-looking match. 00:31:34.601 --> 00:31:37.521 Don't you think Jun-ho likes Attorney Choi? 00:31:37.604 --> 00:31:40.023 Right, I guess you don't drink much coffee. 00:31:40.107 --> 00:31:41.441 Actually, rather than coffee… 00:31:41.525 --> 00:31:43.443 You don't know much about that, right? 00:31:48.198 --> 00:31:49.950 I wonder where my other half is? 00:32:01.086 --> 00:32:03.880 The next witness is the victim, Lee Sun-yeong. 00:32:04.506 --> 00:32:06.091 Witness, come out to the front. 00:32:26.319 --> 00:32:28.864 ATTORNEYS, DEFENDANT 00:32:28.947 --> 00:32:30.490 JURY 00:32:30.574 --> 00:32:32.242 PROSECUTOR 00:32:38.123 --> 00:32:39.207 "I pledge this." 00:32:40.542 --> 00:32:45.422 "I solemnly swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth 00:32:46.131 --> 00:32:48.300 and agree to receive punishment 00:32:48.383 --> 00:32:51.136 in accordance with perjury should there be any falsehood." 00:32:52.596 --> 00:32:54.890 Counselor, you may begin questioning the witness. 00:32:56.349 --> 00:32:57.434 Hold on. 00:32:57.517 --> 00:32:59.144 Attorney Choi, you go ahead. 00:32:59.936 --> 00:33:01.271 What? 00:33:01.354 --> 00:33:05.275 The jury is sympathetic to the victim, so I don't think we should be too stiff. 00:33:05.358 --> 00:33:07.486 Attorney Choi, you go out there and be gentle. 00:33:07.569 --> 00:33:08.820 All right. 00:33:28.757 --> 00:33:31.051 Hello, Ms. Sun-yeong. 00:33:31.927 --> 00:33:32.802 Hi. 00:33:32.886 --> 00:33:36.389 I know it must be hard for you to have to recall what happened five years ago, 00:33:36.473 --> 00:33:38.808 but thank you for being here today as a witness. 00:33:40.936 --> 00:33:43.146 You have a lot of bruises and wounds. 00:33:43.813 --> 00:33:45.190 How did you get hurt? 00:33:45.273 --> 00:33:46.566 Objection. 00:33:46.650 --> 00:33:48.360 This is irrelevant to the case. 00:33:48.443 --> 00:33:50.111 How long are you going to exchange niceties? 00:33:50.195 --> 00:33:53.490 Your Honor, please allow me to question her a bit more. 00:33:53.573 --> 00:33:54.783 It's related to the case. 00:33:55.534 --> 00:33:58.828 Since she says it's relevant, we'll keep listening for now. 00:33:58.912 --> 00:33:59.788 Overruled. 00:34:05.043 --> 00:34:07.587 Could you tell us how you got injured? 00:34:07.671 --> 00:34:08.880 Well… 00:34:08.964 --> 00:34:10.799 Yes, well… 00:34:10.882 --> 00:34:11.967 Did your… 00:34:12.926 --> 00:34:14.469 husband hit you? 00:34:14.553 --> 00:34:15.679 Objection! 00:34:15.762 --> 00:34:17.180 This is irrelevant to the case! 00:34:17.264 --> 00:34:20.141 There are police records that say the police were called 00:34:20.225 --> 00:34:22.310 two days before the incident on November 6th, 2017 00:34:22.394 --> 00:34:24.104 as Lee Sun-yeong was assaulted by her husband. 00:34:24.187 --> 00:34:28.525 Differentiating whether her injuries were caused because of the defendant's assault 00:34:28.608 --> 00:34:31.861 or caused by her husband is important. 00:34:31.945 --> 00:34:33.947 Please let us check the factual relationship. 00:34:34.030 --> 00:34:36.575 I see what you're saying, Counselor. 00:34:37.284 --> 00:34:41.413 So stick to questions about what happened at the time of the incident. 00:34:41.496 --> 00:34:45.166 No more questions about current injuries. 00:34:45.250 --> 00:34:46.167 Yes, sir. 00:34:47.752 --> 00:34:49.170 I'll ask you again. 00:34:49.879 --> 00:34:53.383 Witness, do you recall the police being called to your house 00:34:53.883 --> 00:34:56.720 on November 6th, 2017? 00:34:57.304 --> 00:34:59.639 If you're talking about 2017… 00:35:00.682 --> 00:35:02.559 that's already five years ago. 00:35:04.978 --> 00:35:06.521 I do not recall. 00:35:07.188 --> 00:35:10.442 That day, your husband hit you, 00:35:10.525 --> 00:35:13.028 so the landlord, who lives below you, called the police. 00:35:13.653 --> 00:35:17.449 Here are the police records. Do you not recall? 00:35:19.743 --> 00:35:21.578 I do not recall. 00:35:22.245 --> 00:35:23.955 Pure lies! 00:35:25.081 --> 00:35:27.709 Have you gotten dumb from being beaten up by your husband? 00:35:27.792 --> 00:35:29.544 What are you doing? Stop talking! 00:35:30.962 --> 00:35:32.964 Defendant, what did you say? 00:35:33.048 --> 00:35:36.176 She wasn't beaten by us that much. 00:35:36.259 --> 00:35:40.013 Even if we wanted to, we didn't have the time because the police arrived. 00:35:41.556 --> 00:35:45.018 But look at that wretched thing with her ulterior motive. 00:35:45.769 --> 00:35:48.938 She's trying to put all the beatings she usually gets from her husband 00:35:49.022 --> 00:35:51.483 and frame it all on me! 00:35:53.068 --> 00:35:54.986 It's all a lie! 00:35:55.070 --> 00:35:56.529 Your Honor. 00:35:56.613 --> 00:35:59.699 The defendant is insulting the victim, making a mockery of the court, 00:35:59.783 --> 00:36:01.701 and is showing absolutely no remorse for her wrongdoings! 00:36:02.994 --> 00:36:04.287 Yes. 00:36:04.371 --> 00:36:05.955 I see that. 00:36:06.498 --> 00:36:07.832 You're absolutely right. 00:36:09.042 --> 00:36:10.085 Your Honor-- 00:36:12.504 --> 00:36:14.255 You have to raise your hand first. 00:36:14.339 --> 00:36:15.423 What? 00:36:15.507 --> 00:36:18.009 In this trial, attorneys have to raise their hand first 00:36:18.093 --> 00:36:19.511 if they have something to say. 00:36:19.594 --> 00:36:22.389 We can't speak before the judge gives us permission to speak. 00:36:22.972 --> 00:36:24.015 Why? 00:36:24.974 --> 00:36:28.853 I think it's because his family origin is the Ryu family of Pungsan. 00:36:35.694 --> 00:36:36.820 What is it? 00:36:36.903 --> 00:36:38.071 Right. 00:36:38.154 --> 00:36:39.781 Your Honor, we apologize. 00:36:39.864 --> 00:36:42.867 The defendant is not used to trials, so she lost her control 00:36:42.951 --> 00:36:44.494 and said things she didn't mean. 00:36:45.161 --> 00:36:48.581 Could we have a recess so the defendant can settle down? 00:36:48.665 --> 00:36:51.292 Prosecution, do you have anything to ask the witness? 00:36:51.376 --> 00:36:52.377 Well… 00:36:53.420 --> 00:36:54.504 No. 00:36:54.587 --> 00:36:55.714 I don't. 00:36:57.257 --> 00:36:59.426 Witness, you may go home. 00:37:01.261 --> 00:37:03.388 I will not allow the victim and the defendant 00:37:03.471 --> 00:37:05.640 to meet in this courtroom again. 00:37:07.058 --> 00:37:08.518 We'll have a ten-minute recess. 00:37:09.185 --> 00:37:10.562 All rise. 00:37:11.813 --> 00:37:12.981 Defendant. 00:37:14.149 --> 00:37:15.942 Get a hold of yourself! 00:37:30.123 --> 00:37:32.250 You can't get in our way. 00:37:32.333 --> 00:37:33.543 Get in your way? 00:37:34.043 --> 00:37:35.211 You were beating around the bush, 00:37:35.295 --> 00:37:36.671 so I pointed it out. 00:37:36.755 --> 00:37:38.840 You pointed it out and look at what happened. 00:37:38.923 --> 00:37:41.259 There is an order and formality in a trial. 00:37:41.342 --> 00:37:42.552 This isn't some marketplace fight. 00:37:43.553 --> 00:37:46.848 Please help us go through with our strategy. 00:37:46.931 --> 00:37:48.224 Some marketplace fight? 00:37:49.184 --> 00:37:52.979 If an attorney does it, it's strategy, but if I do it, it's a marketplace fight? 00:37:53.062 --> 00:37:54.898 What do you think I am? 00:37:55.565 --> 00:37:58.151 -Attorney Jung didn't mean it like that. -Didn't mean it like what? 00:37:58.234 --> 00:38:01.029 Are you siding with him because you're an attorney too? 00:38:01.696 --> 00:38:05.784 I did it because I was too frustrated to just sit still and watch! 00:38:05.867 --> 00:38:07.702 Whoa, whoa. 00:38:08.828 --> 00:38:10.288 Whoa, whoa. 00:38:10.371 --> 00:38:13.500 This trial isn't for you to release your frustration. 00:38:13.583 --> 00:38:15.460 It's to get a reduction on your sentence. 00:38:15.543 --> 00:38:17.420 Think of your daughter who is waiting for you at the orphanage. 00:38:17.504 --> 00:38:19.923 If you want to see Ha-yun as quickly as possible, 00:38:20.006 --> 00:38:21.674 you have to listen to us. 00:38:22.383 --> 00:38:24.219 Whoa, whoa. 00:38:24.302 --> 00:38:25.470 Whoa, whoa. 00:38:25.553 --> 00:38:26.596 Whoa, whoa. 00:38:26.679 --> 00:38:28.848 Whoa, whoa. Good job. 00:38:28.932 --> 00:38:30.099 Stop. 00:38:31.100 --> 00:38:32.435 The doctor is next, right? 00:38:32.519 --> 00:38:33.394 Yes. 00:38:33.478 --> 00:38:35.939 We're lucky if he accepts without reservation 00:38:36.022 --> 00:38:37.982 that the injuries could've come from the husband. 00:38:38.066 --> 00:38:40.610 But if he says otherwise, we'll have to go in strong too. 00:38:41.361 --> 00:38:44.864 Emphasize that the witness is biased against North Korean defectors 00:38:44.948 --> 00:38:46.324 to discredit him. 00:38:47.992 --> 00:38:48.868 This time… 00:38:52.664 --> 00:38:53.748 Attorney Woo, you go. 00:38:53.832 --> 00:38:54.916 Because… 00:38:55.834 --> 00:38:56.876 I'm stiff? 00:38:56.960 --> 00:38:58.878 Yes. Show us what you got. 00:39:00.922 --> 00:39:02.006 Okay. 00:39:02.090 --> 00:39:03.007 WITNESS 00:39:06.052 --> 00:39:07.804 This is the diagnosis of the injuries 00:39:07.887 --> 00:39:11.683 you wrote five years ago after seeing the victim yourself. 00:39:11.766 --> 00:39:14.018 Could you read the underlined part? 00:39:14.811 --> 00:39:15.770 Yes. 00:39:16.437 --> 00:39:18.022 "Fourteen days of treatment needed 00:39:18.106 --> 00:39:21.609 for sprains and strain of the cervical spine from the date of diagnosis." 00:39:21.693 --> 00:39:25.655 "Lacerations and bruises all over the body due to indiscriminate assault." 00:39:25.738 --> 00:39:30.201 "Damage to the hair roots and scalp caused by excessive pulling of the hair." 00:39:30.285 --> 00:39:34.789 What do you think the cause of these symptoms is? 00:39:34.873 --> 00:39:36.082 Right. 00:39:37.458 --> 00:39:42.380 The assault by the defendant sitting over there and her accomplice. 00:39:43.298 --> 00:39:44.382 That is all. 00:39:45.216 --> 00:39:47.302 Counselor, you may begin cross-examination. 00:39:53.224 --> 00:39:56.644 On November 6th, 2017, two days before the incident, 00:39:56.728 --> 00:40:01.149 the police were called because Ms. Lee was assaulted by her husband. 00:40:01.232 --> 00:40:04.319 When you issued your diagnosis, were you aware of this fact? 00:40:04.903 --> 00:40:06.112 No, I wasn't. 00:40:06.195 --> 00:40:10.491 So now that you do, do you think the injuries of Ms. Lee Sun-yeong 00:40:10.575 --> 00:40:14.871 could've been caused by her husband's assault, not the defendant? 00:40:16.414 --> 00:40:17.457 No. 00:40:18.041 --> 00:40:21.628 I still think the defendant is to blame. 00:40:22.211 --> 00:40:23.254 Why is that? 00:40:23.338 --> 00:40:26.049 It's not like the name of the person responsible is written on injuries. 00:40:26.132 --> 00:40:27.967 I can tell by looking at the injuries. 00:40:28.509 --> 00:40:30.637 Because I'm a doctor. 00:40:30.720 --> 00:40:34.724 Could you explain how you know based on medical facts? 00:40:34.807 --> 00:40:39.854 I've already given a doctor's opinion as a doctor. 00:40:40.605 --> 00:40:44.734 What more do I have to do 00:40:45.777 --> 00:40:48.529 if you ask me to base it on even more medical facts? 00:40:58.790 --> 00:41:00.792 -Push him into a corner. -Okay. 00:41:02.919 --> 00:41:04.337 Early 2018. 00:41:06.547 --> 00:41:10.134 You wrote this piece for a newspaper. Could you please read the title out loud? 00:41:10.218 --> 00:41:11.386 Objection. 00:41:11.469 --> 00:41:13.137 This is irrelevant to the case. 00:41:15.974 --> 00:41:18.601 -Speak. -The first sentence of this piece is, 00:41:18.685 --> 00:41:23.022 "A Korean woman who was assaulted by North Korean defectors came to see me." 00:41:23.106 --> 00:41:27.568 The piece directly mentions the incident, which means this piece is relevant. 00:41:28.695 --> 00:41:30.279 Objection overruled. 00:41:30.363 --> 00:41:32.323 Counselor, continue. 00:41:32.907 --> 00:41:35.535 Witness, please read the title of the piece. 00:41:37.245 --> 00:41:38.246 Your Honor. 00:41:39.330 --> 00:41:41.666 Could I not talk about this? 00:41:41.749 --> 00:41:44.002 Are you refusing to testify? 00:41:44.085 --> 00:41:45.044 For what reason? 00:41:45.128 --> 00:41:48.214 I've received a lot of hatred and criticism after I wrote this. 00:41:49.215 --> 00:41:51.884 I received hate comments, phone complaints, 00:41:51.968 --> 00:41:53.761 and even threatening letters. 00:41:54.971 --> 00:41:59.892 Unfortunately, none of those fall under the reasons for refusal to testify. 00:42:00.852 --> 00:42:02.645 Read the title of the piece. 00:42:06.566 --> 00:42:09.986 "North Korean defectors are becoming a criminal group." 00:42:12.363 --> 00:42:15.324 The witness argues that "in Korean society, 00:42:15.408 --> 00:42:17.785 North Korean defectors are already a huge issue," 00:42:18.411 --> 00:42:21.539 and that "the government giving North Korean defectors funds to settle 00:42:21.622 --> 00:42:26.127 is like providing criminals with an incentive for criminal acts." 00:42:26.210 --> 00:42:27.253 Is this correct? 00:42:27.336 --> 00:42:28.337 I mean… 00:42:31.007 --> 00:42:31.883 Well, 00:42:33.176 --> 00:42:37.764 I'm not biased or anything like that. The statistics speak for themselves. 00:42:38.765 --> 00:42:41.809 Do you have any idea what the violent crime rate of North Korean defectors is? 00:42:41.893 --> 00:42:43.227 As much as ten percent. 00:42:43.311 --> 00:42:47.356 More than twice the average crime rate of South Koreans. 00:42:47.440 --> 00:42:52.070 The rate of second offenders is also more than five times as much. 00:42:52.153 --> 00:42:55.448 Do you still think that North Korean defectors aren't a criminal group? 00:42:55.531 --> 00:42:58.576 So then, is your opinion on being able to tell who caused the injury 00:42:58.659 --> 00:43:01.537 just by looking at the victim's injury 00:43:01.621 --> 00:43:04.665 unrelated to your usual thoughts about North Korean defectors? 00:43:06.125 --> 00:43:07.001 What? 00:43:07.085 --> 00:43:08.169 You're saying 00:43:08.252 --> 00:43:11.839 the defendant is more at fault than the victim's husband, correct? 00:43:11.923 --> 00:43:13.174 Because the husband is South Korean, 00:43:13.257 --> 00:43:14.926 but the defendant is a North Korean defector. 00:43:15.009 --> 00:43:16.594 Objection. Leading. 00:43:18.179 --> 00:43:19.305 Sustained. 00:43:25.853 --> 00:43:27.647 But honestly, 00:43:27.730 --> 00:43:31.317 is it right to make an abusive husband out of a normal South Korean man 00:43:31.400 --> 00:43:35.696 just to do something good for North Korean defectors? 00:43:36.322 --> 00:43:37.240 What? 00:43:37.323 --> 00:43:41.452 This trial is done with the tax paid by the citizens. 00:43:41.536 --> 00:43:45.748 So the trial should protect them, not that North Korean defector! 00:43:47.834 --> 00:43:50.002 Take it easy. The jury is on our side now. 00:43:55.508 --> 00:43:59.303 While I respect your opinion, 00:44:00.096 --> 00:44:02.723 North Korean defectors are citizens of South Korea as well. 00:44:03.391 --> 00:44:05.268 That's why we're having this trial. 00:44:06.435 --> 00:44:08.271 Yes, well… 00:44:09.188 --> 00:44:10.022 That's right. 00:44:27.290 --> 00:44:28.708 You're eating? 00:44:30.042 --> 00:44:33.004 You messed things up, yet you're eating? 00:44:35.590 --> 00:44:38.384 How can you eat, you idiot? 00:44:38.467 --> 00:44:41.721 -What's wrong with you? Are you crazy? -You're the one who's crazy. 00:44:41.804 --> 00:44:45.850 Do you have any idea how hard I worked to get the GRD as our client? 00:44:45.933 --> 00:44:47.143 The GRD? 00:44:47.226 --> 00:44:48.394 Yes, you punk! 00:44:48.477 --> 00:44:51.939 The Group of Righteous Doctors, the GRD! You blew it! 00:44:55.359 --> 00:44:57.820 You put Kwon Byeong-gil on the witness stand 00:44:57.904 --> 00:44:59.280 without knowing that he's an executive of the GRD? 00:44:59.363 --> 00:45:02.575 Do you know what I had to deal with from the Chairman just now? 00:45:02.658 --> 00:45:04.285 You don't! 00:45:04.368 --> 00:45:07.288 Kwon Byeong-gil said he didn't want to talk about the piece. 00:45:07.371 --> 00:45:12.418 But the attorneys at Hanbada insisted that he talk about it! 00:45:13.669 --> 00:45:14.629 Gosh. 00:45:15.713 --> 00:45:17.465 Gosh! 00:45:17.548 --> 00:45:20.676 Is this because of a public interest case you're doing with the rookies? 00:45:21.344 --> 00:45:22.637 Myeong-seok. 00:45:22.720 --> 00:45:25.973 How could someone with your level of experience make such a mistake? 00:45:26.724 --> 00:45:28.601 How could you cost us a client 00:45:28.684 --> 00:45:31.938 who's worth billions over some mere public interest case? 00:45:36.150 --> 00:45:38.819 Okay, I understand. You can stop now. 00:45:38.903 --> 00:45:41.072 The one peer I have 00:45:41.155 --> 00:45:44.450 that should be helping me is bringing harm to me instead! 00:45:44.533 --> 00:45:46.118 Gosh, this is so annoying! 00:45:46.619 --> 00:45:48.454 I'm the only one worried about the firm! 00:46:03.427 --> 00:46:06.847 I'm sorry for not running a background check on the witness. 00:46:07.932 --> 00:46:11.185 I'm sorry for making you lose a client that's worth billions. 00:46:12.061 --> 00:46:14.271 It's nothing for rookies to apologize for. 00:46:14.355 --> 00:46:15.272 It's my mistake. 00:46:18.442 --> 00:46:22.113 It's my fault and I'm really embarrassed right now. 00:46:22.196 --> 00:46:23.572 But let's not think of it as 00:46:23.656 --> 00:46:28.828 "some mere public interest case" or "some mere North Korean defector." 00:46:30.079 --> 00:46:32.498 Let's work hard even if it's not a case 00:46:34.000 --> 00:46:35.501 that's worth billions of won. 00:46:36.085 --> 00:46:37.211 Yes. 00:46:37.878 --> 00:46:38.796 Yes. 00:46:38.879 --> 00:46:39.839 All right. 00:46:41.132 --> 00:46:42.299 Finish your food. 00:46:42.883 --> 00:46:44.927 I'm going to go because I'm embarrassed. 00:47:00.818 --> 00:47:02.570 ESTABLISHMENT OF LAW AND ORDER 00:47:24.800 --> 00:47:26.552 -Mom! -Ha-yun. 00:47:27.136 --> 00:47:28.554 -Mom! -Ha-yun. 00:47:28.637 --> 00:47:29.764 Mom! 00:47:30.931 --> 00:47:33.059 Mom! 00:47:33.684 --> 00:47:35.227 Mommy's sorry. 00:47:35.311 --> 00:47:36.645 Mom. 00:47:36.729 --> 00:47:41.108 Mommy's sorry, Ha-yun. 00:47:56.082 --> 00:47:57.166 Ha-yun. 00:47:57.666 --> 00:47:58.918 You're doing well! 00:48:02.755 --> 00:48:03.798 You did great. 00:48:09.303 --> 00:48:10.262 Let's eat the gimbap. 00:48:10.346 --> 00:48:12.681 WHITE 480, BLUE 680 00:48:12.765 --> 00:48:14.683 EXCELLENCE AWARD, EFFORT AWARD CONCESSION AWARD 00:48:14.767 --> 00:48:16.936 FAMILY SPORTS DAY WITH DREAMS AND HOPE 00:48:19.605 --> 00:48:22.066 Here, Young-woo. Have some fruit. 00:48:24.485 --> 00:48:26.028 No. 00:48:26.112 --> 00:48:27.446 My son is too handsome. 00:48:29.323 --> 00:48:31.158 Young-woo? Here, hold it. 00:48:41.460 --> 00:48:43.587 -Dad. -Yes? 00:48:44.922 --> 00:48:48.217 Why don't I have a mom? 00:49:05.776 --> 00:49:08.821 The statutory penalty for injury resulting from robbery is too high. 00:49:08.904 --> 00:49:10.489 Murder is five years at the least. 00:49:10.573 --> 00:49:12.616 It doesn't make sense for this charge to be seven years. 00:49:13.200 --> 00:49:16.787 Why don't we file for an adjudication on the constitutionality of the law? 00:49:17.496 --> 00:49:19.790 If the Constitutional Court finds this to be unconstitutional, 00:49:19.874 --> 00:49:21.458 Hyang-sim can be acquitted. 00:49:21.542 --> 00:49:23.544 That already happened a few times before. 00:49:23.627 --> 00:49:26.255 In 2001, 2006, and 2016. 00:49:26.338 --> 00:49:28.132 And? They all didn't work? 00:49:28.799 --> 00:49:31.051 Yes, they were seen as being constitutional. 00:49:34.680 --> 00:49:38.309 A North Korean defector is technically a kind of refugee, right? 00:49:39.018 --> 00:49:42.771 Aren't there any laws that are generous to refugees, immigrants, or foreigners? 00:49:42.855 --> 00:49:43.814 No. 00:49:43.898 --> 00:49:45.983 Think carefully. Is there really nothing? 00:49:52.031 --> 00:49:54.825 There's none. And there shouldn't be anything like that. 00:49:54.909 --> 00:49:58.329 It's like giving a criminal license to refugees, immigrants, or foreigners. 00:50:00.956 --> 00:50:03.167 Then what else could there be? 00:50:03.250 --> 00:50:05.753 Young-woo, you're a genius. 00:50:05.836 --> 00:50:07.087 Think of something! 00:50:16.513 --> 00:50:19.975 It is a bit far-fetched, but there is one I can think of. 00:50:20.893 --> 00:50:21.810 What is it? 00:50:22.478 --> 00:50:23.604 It's North Korean law. 00:50:24.605 --> 00:50:25.731 North Korean law? 00:50:25.814 --> 00:50:28.734 Yes, there is robbery in North Korea as well. 00:50:28.817 --> 00:50:32.988 Article 288 of North Korean criminal law. Robbery of personal property. 00:50:33.656 --> 00:50:35.532 "Someone who has robbed personal property 00:50:35.616 --> 00:50:38.410 by means of assault or threat to a person's life or health 00:50:38.494 --> 00:50:41.288 will be sentenced to a maximum of four years in a correctional labor camp." 00:50:41.956 --> 00:50:43.832 But according to Criminal Law 00:50:43.916 --> 00:50:46.377 published by the Kim Il Sung University Publishers, 00:50:46.460 --> 00:50:49.129 North Korea's crime of robbery, in comparison to South Korea, 00:50:49.213 --> 00:50:52.007 requires a high level of intensity in the assault and threats. 00:50:52.591 --> 00:50:56.262 The assault should be intense enough to kill or seriously injure 00:50:56.345 --> 00:50:59.640 and threats should be one of assault that will result in immediate death 00:50:59.723 --> 00:51:01.183 or serious injuries 00:51:01.267 --> 00:51:04.645 unless the victim does not comply with the criminal's requests. 00:51:04.728 --> 00:51:08.232 If the assault and threats do not meet these standards, 00:51:08.315 --> 00:51:10.067 the crime of robbery cannot be established 00:51:10.150 --> 00:51:13.404 and it would merely fall under the crime of stealing personal property. 00:51:13.988 --> 00:51:16.156 A crime of stealing personal property? 00:51:16.240 --> 00:51:18.325 "Article 284 of North Korean criminal law." 00:51:18.409 --> 00:51:19.994 "A crime of stealing personal property." 00:51:20.077 --> 00:51:21.745 "Someone who has stolen personal property will be sentenced 00:51:21.829 --> 00:51:24.206 to a maximum of one year of labor discipline." 00:51:24.290 --> 00:51:27.126 Your Honor, please focus on the sentence. 00:51:27.209 --> 00:51:28.919 Robbery of personal property 00:51:29.003 --> 00:51:31.005 is a maximum of four years of correctional labor camp. 00:51:31.088 --> 00:51:33.716 In other words, a maximum of four years of imprisonment. 00:51:33.799 --> 00:51:36.010 But the sentence for stealing personal property 00:51:36.093 --> 00:51:38.971 is a maximum of one year of labor discipline. 00:51:39.054 --> 00:51:41.765 In South Korea, this would merely be a sentence of a maximum 00:51:41.849 --> 00:51:43.809 of one year of community service. 00:51:44.685 --> 00:51:47.521 That's enough lecture on North Korean law. 00:51:47.604 --> 00:51:51.108 So what are you trying to claim? 00:51:51.942 --> 00:51:53.777 The defendant is more used to North Korean law 00:51:53.861 --> 00:51:55.362 than she is to South Korean law. 00:51:55.446 --> 00:51:59.158 The defendant only tried to get back the money she was supposed to get. 00:51:59.241 --> 00:52:03.120 There was no intention to rob the money by oppressing the victim's free will. 00:52:03.203 --> 00:52:05.956 Moreover, she did not think that she would be 00:52:06.040 --> 00:52:08.042 sentenced to a life sentence 00:52:08.125 --> 00:52:10.711 or a minimum of seven years of imprisonment because of her action. 00:52:10.794 --> 00:52:12.588 Because in North Korea, 00:52:12.671 --> 00:52:16.800 the defendant's actions aren't enough to establish the crime of robbery. 00:52:18.594 --> 00:52:21.263 So the attorneys are claiming 00:52:21.347 --> 00:52:23.974 that since the defendant thought "this isn't robbery in North Korea, 00:52:24.058 --> 00:52:26.226 so I'm not committing robbery." 00:52:26.310 --> 00:52:28.270 Is that what you're saying? 00:52:28.854 --> 00:52:32.191 Your Honor, this is the most unprecedented logic that's ever been heard. 00:52:33.192 --> 00:52:35.611 It's true that it's unprecedented. 00:52:35.694 --> 00:52:38.405 But perhaps we should look into it. 00:52:39.573 --> 00:52:40.657 Defendant. 00:52:42.117 --> 00:52:45.996 Did you think your action wasn't robbery 00:52:46.497 --> 00:52:50.125 because you were more used to North Korean law? 00:52:53.545 --> 00:52:54.755 Well… 00:52:54.838 --> 00:52:55.756 Yes. 00:52:56.382 --> 00:52:57.341 Is that so? 00:52:58.050 --> 00:53:01.887 What were you going to do if the victim didn't hand you the money? 00:53:03.180 --> 00:53:06.767 Didn't you think of getting it even if you had to force her? 00:53:08.852 --> 00:53:09.895 Your Honor… 00:53:10.437 --> 00:53:11.271 Your Honor. 00:53:12.439 --> 00:53:15.025 Could you please once again notify the defendant 00:53:15.109 --> 00:53:16.735 of her right to refuse to testify? 00:53:16.819 --> 00:53:18.237 Of course. 00:53:18.320 --> 00:53:20.406 Defendant, you don't have to answer. 00:53:21.573 --> 00:53:25.411 But I would like to ask so we can have a fair trial. 00:53:26.995 --> 00:53:29.123 Defendant, could you respond? 00:53:45.597 --> 00:53:47.266 I went there 00:53:48.225 --> 00:53:49.268 to get it at all costs. 00:53:49.351 --> 00:53:52.104 That was my money. 00:53:54.606 --> 00:53:55.774 Yes. 00:53:56.650 --> 00:53:57.651 Well… 00:53:58.527 --> 00:54:02.573 What do you think of what the attorneys claimed just now? 00:54:03.365 --> 00:54:06.452 Did you really think that you should threaten the victim only enough 00:54:06.535 --> 00:54:11.832 so that robbery wouldn't be established according to North Korean law? 00:54:13.125 --> 00:54:14.209 I'm not sure. 00:54:15.294 --> 00:54:16.962 I honestly don't know 00:54:17.963 --> 00:54:20.799 all that about North Korean law. 00:54:22.926 --> 00:54:24.219 I see. 00:54:37.399 --> 00:54:38.609 That is all. 00:54:43.197 --> 00:54:46.867 All right, that concludes the defense. 00:54:46.950 --> 00:54:50.037 Juries, please start your review. 00:54:50.120 --> 00:54:52.623 I will give a verdict after that. 00:54:52.706 --> 00:54:54.374 All rise. 00:55:06.678 --> 00:55:09.097 I'm headed back to the office. Are you coming with me? 00:55:09.181 --> 00:55:11.808 I'll stay for the verdict. 00:55:11.892 --> 00:55:12.726 Me, too. 00:55:12.809 --> 00:55:13.769 Okay, then. 00:55:13.852 --> 00:55:15.938 Stay with the defendant until the end. 00:55:16.647 --> 00:55:19.358 No matter the result, you two did your best. 00:55:34.206 --> 00:55:35.624 Attorney comrades. 00:55:36.291 --> 00:55:38.710 Why the long face? 00:55:41.797 --> 00:55:43.006 She doesn't mean it literally. 00:55:44.591 --> 00:55:45.551 I'm sorry. 00:55:45.634 --> 00:55:47.886 Gosh, what are you sorry for? 00:55:49.263 --> 00:55:50.264 Then 00:55:50.973 --> 00:55:52.224 has it already been decided 00:55:52.975 --> 00:55:54.268 that I'll be sent to prison? 00:55:54.351 --> 00:55:57.563 No. Get some rest and we'll see you at the verdict. 00:56:03.235 --> 00:56:04.361 Come this way. 00:56:38.895 --> 00:56:41.440 There's a claim that we haven't tried yet. 00:56:42.441 --> 00:56:43.984 Adjudication on the constitutionality of the law. 00:56:44.067 --> 00:56:45.068 What? 00:56:45.819 --> 00:56:47.404 You said other people tried it 00:56:47.487 --> 00:56:48.864 and they were seen as being constitutional. 00:56:51.867 --> 00:56:53.076 Wait. 00:56:53.160 --> 00:56:54.244 Young-woo! 00:56:57.998 --> 00:56:59.499 Where are you going? 00:57:01.918 --> 00:57:05.213 The jurors are already reviewing. What can you do at this point? 00:57:05.297 --> 00:57:07.299 The verdict hasn't been given yet. 00:57:07.382 --> 00:57:08.925 Then we can still request the resumption of the hearing. 00:57:09.009 --> 00:57:10.135 We're going to go meet the judge. 00:57:10.218 --> 00:57:12.346 You can't enter the judge's chambers without a visitor's permit. 00:57:12.429 --> 00:57:14.014 We can ask for visitor's permits. 00:57:14.097 --> 00:57:16.266 They don't just give it to you. 00:57:16.350 --> 00:57:18.143 You need the judge's permission. 00:57:18.226 --> 00:57:20.604 Do you think he'll give you permission? 00:57:26.611 --> 00:57:30.031 Hello, we're attorneys. We would like to visit one of the judges' chambers. 00:57:30.115 --> 00:57:31.366 -Which one? -Ryu-- 00:57:31.450 --> 00:57:33.702 Chief Judge Choi Bo-yeon's chambers on the eighth floor. 00:57:33.785 --> 00:57:35.579 What's the purpose of your visit? 00:57:35.662 --> 00:57:37.330 Is he expecting you? 00:57:38.081 --> 00:57:39.624 It's a personal errand. 00:57:43.920 --> 00:57:46.047 Judge Choi Bo-yeon is my father. 00:57:46.131 --> 00:57:48.800 This is my colleague and we're here for an errand. 00:57:48.884 --> 00:57:49.926 Just a moment. 00:57:52.053 --> 00:57:53.388 This is the access desk. 00:57:53.472 --> 00:57:56.308 A woman who says she's Judge Choi's daughter is hoping to visit 00:57:56.391 --> 00:57:58.351 and I was wondering if this was prearranged. 00:57:59.269 --> 00:58:00.187 Your name? 00:58:00.270 --> 00:58:01.521 Choi Su-yeon. 00:58:01.605 --> 00:58:02.939 Attorney Choi Su-yeon. 00:58:05.650 --> 00:58:06.943 Yes. All right. 00:58:08.069 --> 00:58:11.031 Write down your name and purpose of visit here, and you can go in. 00:58:20.874 --> 00:58:23.752 SUPREME COURT OF KOREA 00:58:26.254 --> 00:58:27.714 Do you know what all that's for? 00:58:27.797 --> 00:58:29.424 To prevent people like us. 00:58:29.508 --> 00:58:32.177 To stop people from trying to plead their case to a judge outside the courtroom. 00:58:32.260 --> 00:58:34.471 We're not trying to plead our case to the judge outside the courtroom. 00:58:34.554 --> 00:58:36.723 We're just trying to request the resumption of the hearing. 00:58:36.806 --> 00:58:38.892 Would the prosecutor see it that way? 00:58:38.975 --> 00:58:41.228 I can't believe I let Wild Card Woo Young-woo talk me into this. 00:58:43.104 --> 00:58:44.356 Excuse me. 00:58:44.856 --> 00:58:47.234 We're here to see Judge Ryu Myeong-ha! 00:58:47.317 --> 00:58:48.693 Who are you? 00:58:54.658 --> 00:58:55.617 What is this? 00:58:56.368 --> 00:58:57.702 How did you get in here? 00:58:57.786 --> 00:59:00.956 Your Honor. We would like to request the resumption of the hearing. 00:59:01.623 --> 00:59:05.001 Don't you know the juries are reviewing right now? 00:59:05.085 --> 00:59:07.754 We do. But we had no choice but to come see you, 00:59:07.837 --> 00:59:09.673 even though we knew it was rude. 00:59:09.756 --> 00:59:12.259 It's too late for us to submit a request form for a resumption of the hearing. 00:59:12.342 --> 00:59:13.426 No. 00:59:14.386 --> 00:59:17.389 If you're not satisfied with something, you can appeal. 00:59:27.566 --> 00:59:29.401 What is it? 00:59:29.985 --> 00:59:32.737 The defendant ultimately never got the money from the victim. 00:59:32.821 --> 00:59:36.408 It's unconstitutional for this to be on trial for injury resulting from robbery. 00:59:36.491 --> 00:59:39.661 Please allow for the resumption of the hearing. 00:59:39.744 --> 00:59:44.040 Attempted injury resulting from robbery does not mean robbery was attempted. 00:59:44.124 --> 00:59:45.208 There must be an attempt to cause injury 00:59:45.292 --> 00:59:47.460 in order for this charge to be established. 00:59:47.544 --> 00:59:49.588 Isn't there room for a different interpretation? 00:59:49.671 --> 00:59:52.716 An attempted injury resulting from robbery charge is more favorable to the defendant 00:59:52.799 --> 00:59:54.259 than an injury resulting from robbery charge. 00:59:54.342 --> 00:59:55.969 And criminal law prohibits any reduced interpretation of a law 00:59:56.052 --> 00:59:59.097 that is favorable to the defendant without reason. 00:59:59.180 --> 01:00:02.100 Are you going to trial because you don't want to yield? 01:00:03.643 --> 01:00:06.813 Are you saying little strokes don't fell great oaks? 01:00:06.896 --> 01:00:10.358 First, you claimed the victim's injuries are not the defendant's fault. 01:00:10.442 --> 01:00:14.988 Then you bring up North Korean law to say there wasn't any intention in the robbery. 01:00:15.071 --> 01:00:16.781 Now, it's unconstitutional for the defendant to be tried 01:00:16.865 --> 01:00:19.951 for injury resulting from robbery because she didn't get the money? 01:00:20.744 --> 01:00:22.495 Are you kidding me? 01:00:25.707 --> 01:00:26.708 Darn it. 01:00:26.791 --> 01:00:28.501 CHIEF JUDGE RYU MYEONG-HA 01:00:32.756 --> 01:00:36.301 I understand you're passionate as young attorneys. 01:00:36.384 --> 01:00:37.385 However, 01:00:38.345 --> 01:00:41.348 there is a time and place to be passionate. 01:00:41.431 --> 01:00:43.850 It's not because we're young attorneys. 01:00:44.851 --> 01:00:47.979 It's because Ms. Gye Hyang-sim is a great mother. 01:00:48.855 --> 01:00:50.023 Like a mother whale. 01:00:51.566 --> 01:00:52.400 What? 01:00:52.484 --> 01:00:55.570 Ms. Gye Hyang-sim lacks common sense and does whatever she pleases. 01:00:56.196 --> 01:01:00.492 Even now, it doesn't seem like she fully understands what she did wrong. 01:01:01.076 --> 01:01:04.788 But Ms. Gye Hyang-sim chose to be a fugitive for five years 01:01:04.871 --> 01:01:06.998 to not abandon her child. 01:01:08.083 --> 01:01:10.627 Maternal instinct is not a reason for mitigation, 01:01:10.710 --> 01:01:14.673 but I beg you to think of the circumstance of a great mother 01:01:15.548 --> 01:01:18.593 who thought she had to raise her daughter before going to prison 01:01:18.677 --> 01:01:21.763 so that she would be old enough to remember her mother 01:01:23.556 --> 01:01:24.974 once she was released. 01:01:33.775 --> 01:01:37.112 This is an argument made out of court. 01:01:37.696 --> 01:01:41.199 I'm not going to hear any more of this or reflect it on the verdict. 01:01:41.282 --> 01:01:43.159 I won't allow for the resumption of the hearing either. 01:01:44.536 --> 01:01:48.206 If you both don't leave right now, I will call a bailiff. 01:01:55.922 --> 01:02:00.635 The most famous way of hunting whales is to kill the baby first. 01:02:01.302 --> 01:02:03.596 They throw a harpoon at the weak baby, 01:02:03.680 --> 01:02:06.516 and as the baby is swimming around in pain, 01:02:07.183 --> 01:02:09.728 the mother never leaves its side. 01:02:11.104 --> 01:02:13.857 She can't abandon her baby that is in pain. 01:02:14.816 --> 01:02:15.817 That's when 01:02:16.651 --> 01:02:18.486 the second harpoon is thrown 01:02:19.154 --> 01:02:21.156 at the mother that is the ultimate target. 01:02:22.532 --> 01:02:24.242 Humans. 01:02:25.034 --> 01:02:26.745 Whales are intelligent. 01:02:27.537 --> 01:02:31.124 She knows that she will also be killed if she doesn't abandon her baby. 01:02:32.542 --> 01:02:34.461 But she never does. 01:02:37.297 --> 01:02:39.674 If I were a whale, 01:02:42.051 --> 01:02:44.387 would my mom not have abandoned me? 01:03:06.910 --> 01:03:08.411 All rise. 01:03:13.291 --> 01:03:14.501 Be seated. 01:03:19.923 --> 01:03:22.717 Jury, did you finish up the review? 01:03:22.801 --> 01:03:24.677 Will you hand me the written verdict? 01:03:40.485 --> 01:03:43.363 I will announce the jury's review. 01:03:45.240 --> 01:03:46.866 On the charges. 01:03:46.950 --> 01:03:50.286 By unanimous decision of the indictment of all seven jurors, guilty. 01:03:51.162 --> 01:03:52.539 Opinion on sentencing. 01:03:53.039 --> 01:03:55.875 By unanimous decision of the indictment of all seven jurors, 01:03:55.959 --> 01:03:57.252 four years of imprisonment. 01:03:58.753 --> 01:04:00.922 Thank you, members of the jury. 01:04:01.798 --> 01:04:07.262 This court sincerely respects the jury's verdict. 01:04:08.513 --> 01:04:09.806 Now, for the verdict. 01:04:10.765 --> 01:04:11.808 Stand up. 01:04:15.144 --> 01:04:16.312 Formal adjudication. 01:04:16.938 --> 01:04:20.275 The defendant is sentenced to one year and nine months of imprisonment. 01:04:22.694 --> 01:04:26.322 However, the execution of the sentence against the defendant 01:04:26.948 --> 01:04:29.868 is suspended for three years following the date of the verdict. 01:04:31.119 --> 01:04:34.706 The court orders that the defendant be on probation 01:04:34.789 --> 01:04:37.041 and 80 hours of community service. 01:04:40.753 --> 01:04:41.588 What is he saying? 01:04:42.630 --> 01:04:43.715 Probation! 01:04:43.798 --> 01:04:44.841 What? 01:04:45.800 --> 01:04:47.510 Probation… 01:04:48.344 --> 01:04:51.055 The nature of this crime offending as the defendant colluded 01:04:51.723 --> 01:04:53.975 with an accomplice and assaulted and threatened the victim 01:04:54.058 --> 01:04:57.186 with the intention to take property by force. 01:04:57.770 --> 01:05:00.648 Considering the fear the victim must've felt during the crime 01:05:00.732 --> 01:05:04.986 and how the defendant fled after the crime without being tried, 01:05:05.695 --> 01:05:07.989 it is necessary to punish the defendant severely. 01:05:08.823 --> 01:05:12.118 However, considering that the defendant 01:05:12.201 --> 01:05:15.914 is not used to South Korean laws and regulations as a North Korean defector, 01:05:15.997 --> 01:05:18.708 a first-time offender without a criminal record, 01:05:19.250 --> 01:05:20.585 and most importantly… 01:05:25.673 --> 01:05:27.634 although it has been five years, 01:05:28.217 --> 01:05:30.678 she has confessed without forgetting her crimes, 01:05:30.762 --> 01:05:33.348 with the intent of receiving punishment. 01:05:33.431 --> 01:05:36.351 Thus, the court is taking into account these special sentencing factors. 01:05:43.149 --> 01:05:44.400 Right. 01:05:45.193 --> 01:05:46.319 Confession. 01:05:47.403 --> 01:05:48.488 Yes, she confessed. 01:05:48.571 --> 01:05:50.031 That's right. 01:05:50.698 --> 01:05:54.327 Sentencing elements that are advantageous or disadvantageous to the defendant… 01:05:54.410 --> 01:05:57.997 We were focused on something else that we forgot Hyang-sim had confessed. 01:05:58.081 --> 01:06:01.584 Confession is the most basic reason for mitigation. I can't believe we forgot. 01:06:02.293 --> 01:06:03.461 We're idiots. 01:06:03.544 --> 01:06:05.630 Perhaps the judge is the smart one. 01:06:06.547 --> 01:06:09.050 The cleverness of a veteran. 01:06:09.634 --> 01:06:11.886 "The cleverness of a veteran." 01:06:12.387 --> 01:06:15.807 Through a trial by jury, 01:06:15.890 --> 01:06:18.309 following the law regarding juries in criminal trials, 01:06:18.393 --> 01:06:20.436 the ruling is as the formal adjudication. 01:06:22.730 --> 01:06:23.940 Thank you. 01:06:25.483 --> 01:06:26.651 Thank you. 01:06:28.611 --> 01:06:29.862 Thank you. 01:06:34.075 --> 01:06:35.576 Thank you. 01:07:06.816 --> 01:07:09.152 Mom, put that down. 01:07:09.235 --> 01:07:10.820 Look at this. Isn't it so pretty? 01:07:10.903 --> 01:07:13.364 Gosh, it's too short for me. You try it on. 01:07:13.448 --> 01:07:15.324 -Mom, try it on. -It looks good on you. 01:07:15.408 --> 01:07:16.242 Just this once. 01:07:17.785 --> 01:07:19.037 No, this is too expensive. 01:07:19.120 --> 01:07:20.705 Come on, I'll get it for you. 01:07:23.166 --> 01:07:25.668 The headquarters has been marketing toward the younger generation, 01:07:25.752 --> 01:07:27.962 so we have more customers who bring their daughters with them. 01:07:28.046 --> 01:07:28.921 I see. 01:07:29.005 --> 01:07:30.339 Do you have a daughter? 01:07:31.799 --> 01:07:33.468 No, just a son. 01:07:33.551 --> 01:07:34.802 I see. 01:07:34.886 --> 01:07:38.264 Then you must be envious whenever you see a mother and daughter shopping. 01:07:39.307 --> 01:07:41.350 It's not too late for you to have a daughter. 01:08:20.322 --> 01:08:21.448 What are you doing? 01:08:21.531 --> 01:08:22.532 Let's go. 01:08:23.366 --> 01:08:24.367 Again? 01:08:39.085 --> 01:08:42.922 It's splitting the town in half and isolating each side. 01:08:43.006 --> 01:08:46.926 It's not a neighborhood that can just disappear like that. 01:08:47.010 --> 01:08:49.637 Are these all materials on Haengbok-ro? 01:08:49.721 --> 01:08:51.306 That's Attorney Tae Su-mi, right? 01:08:51.389 --> 01:08:53.224 -Why is the king here herself? -"King"? 01:08:53.308 --> 01:08:57.395 -I think Jun-ho likes you. -It's not easy for someone to like me. 01:08:57.479 --> 01:09:00.356 -Does your heart pound like crazy? -There was a time when it did. 01:09:00.440 --> 01:09:01.816 You totally like him!