WEBVTT

00:01:42.666 --> 00:01:43.291
What happen?

00:01:43.291 --> 00:01:45.707
Sir, the girl was
already dead when we arrived

00:01:45.791 --> 00:01:47.416
He wouldn't tell us a thing

00:01:47.916 --> 00:01:49.249
What's your name?

00:02:06.624 --> 00:02:08.082
Your Honour

00:02:10.916 --> 00:02:14.124
<i>What I have here
is a duplicate of Evidence DA</i>

00:02:14.499 --> 00:02:15.790
Miss Lo

00:02:16.332 --> 00:02:19.873
According to an article published on
March 29th this year

00:02:19.874 --> 00:02:21.999
On the 'Shock News' website titled

00:02:22.499 --> 00:02:24.665
'Unjust Admission Standards at Hon Yeung School

00:02:24.666 --> 00:02:28.332
Admission Tests Exempted
for Principal's Friends'

00:02:28.624 --> 00:02:32.499
As the Editor-in-Chief,
why did you choose to report this?

00:02:32.541 --> 00:02:35.457
At first, I received complaints from some parents

00:02:35.457 --> 00:02:37.915
They found out that the children of

00:02:37.916 --> 00:02:39.916
Friends or relatives of the principal

00:02:39.916 --> 00:02:42.582
Were admitted without being interviewed

00:02:42.582 --> 00:02:43.582
They thought

00:02:43.582 --> 00:02:47.707
For the children who have
worked hard for the admission tests

00:02:47.707 --> 00:02:49.082
This was really unfair

00:02:49.082 --> 00:02:50.123
Court

00:02:53.166 --> 00:02:54.291
Your Honour

00:02:54.582 --> 00:02:56.123
My client pledges not guilty

00:02:56.124 --> 00:02:59.957
My client never engaged in any hawking activities

00:03:00.291 --> 00:03:03.416
And she didn't set a price on the cardboard

00:03:03.957 --> 00:03:07.332
Therefore, no monetary transaction was involved

00:03:07.832 --> 00:03:10.707
And the $20 the Indonesian
domestic worker gave to my client

00:03:10.707 --> 00:03:13.623
Should be considered as a personal gift

00:03:13.624 --> 00:03:15.332
Not money from a transaction

00:03:15.332 --> 00:03:17.665
Did you continue with your research?

00:03:17.666 --> 00:03:21.374
I wrote to the school,
but I didn't get any response

00:03:21.374 --> 00:03:23.915
So I did my own research and investigation

00:03:23.916 --> 00:03:27.041
The crime happened in private property

00:03:27.041 --> 00:03:30.207
Which is managed by a private owners' corporation

00:03:30.249 --> 00:03:32.582
Therefore it was not public property

00:03:32.582 --> 00:03:34.332
I've noticed in the past few years

00:03:34.332 --> 00:03:35.790
The number of students who got admitted

00:03:35.791 --> 00:03:39.082
Without an interview kept increasing

00:03:39.457 --> 00:03:41.665
But the school had no formal explanation

00:03:41.666 --> 00:03:44.541
I firmly believe in the parents' accusation

00:03:44.541 --> 00:03:47.624
<i>So I decided 10 write an expose on it</i>

00:03:47.624 --> 00:03:49.249
Thank you, Miss Lo

00:03:51.624 --> 00:03:52.957
By the way

00:03:52.999 --> 00:03:56.665
Your daughter also goes to
Hon Yeung International School, right?

00:03:57.749 --> 00:03:58.457
Yes

00:03:58.457 --> 00:04:00.373
I'm innocent, Your Honour

00:04:01.207 --> 00:04:02.040
Granny

00:04:02.374 --> 00:04:03.415
Get up

00:04:03.416 --> 00:04:04.999
- Don't cry
- I'm begging you

00:04:04.999 --> 00:04:08.124
Your Honour, as a journalist

00:04:08.124 --> 00:04:11.499
She plays a monitoring role in the incident

00:04:11.791 --> 00:04:14.874
She makes sure that when choosing their students

00:04:14.874 --> 00:04:17.165
The school remains fair and consistent

00:04:17.166 --> 00:04:20.541
Her opinion is lawfully and reasonably construed

00:04:20.541 --> 00:04:25.041
As 'Qualified Privilege'
in the Defamation Ordinance

00:04:25.166 --> 00:04:27.332
[t shouldn't be considered defamation

00:04:27.791 --> 00:04:30.541
Therefore, her accusation of
defamation should be ruled false

00:04:30.541 --> 00:04:32.374
My client is an elderly lady who lives alone

00:04:32.374 --> 00:04:35.249
She has diabetes and needs long-term medication

00:04:35.457 --> 00:04:38.332
She could have applied for
Social Security Assistance

00:04:38.332 --> 00:04:39.498
But she didn't

00:04:39.499 --> 00:04:42.457
She believes she can provide for herself

00:04:44.041 --> 00:04:45.291
Your Honour

00:04:45.791 --> 00:04:48.207
Temper justice with mercy

00:04:48.207 --> 00:04:49.957
Will you consider an appeal?

00:04:49.957 --> 00:04:51.123
Granny, any thoughts?

00:04:51.124 --> 00:04:54.165
What's your plan going forward?
Do you think the ruling was fair?

00:04:54.166 --> 00:04:55.374
Granny is innocent

00:04:55.374 --> 00:04:58.207
She doesn't have to bear responsibility for this

00:04:58.207 --> 00:05:00.415
We're extremely upset with the adjudication

00:05:00.832 --> 00:05:03.707
We'll study the verdict and consider an appeal

00:05:04.707 --> 00:05:06.415
Don't mess up again

00:05:06.416 --> 00:05:08.166
Or I'll charge you full price next time

00:05:08.166 --> 00:05:09.582
I'm not a big corporation

00:05:09.582 --> 00:05:11.790
How can I afford you as my legal consultant?

00:05:12.082 --> 00:05:15.332
I'll ask for your advice whenever I'm in doubt

00:05:15.332 --> 00:05:16.665
I've got to go, bye-bye

00:05:16.666 --> 00:05:17.624
Bye

00:05:18.624 --> 00:05:20.665
Kelvin lost 12 cases in a row

00:05:20.666 --> 00:05:22.832
What an exceptional legal genius

00:05:23.166 --> 00:05:24.999
Don't say that about him

00:05:24.999 --> 00:05:27.874
I know, you won 12 cases in a row

00:05:28.291 --> 00:05:29.999
Drop me off at the post office

00:05:30.374 --> 00:05:31.374
What for?

00:05:32.249 --> 00:05:36.040
I finally collected the entire set,
I'm sending them to Elise

00:05:36.041 --> 00:05:37.291
Surprise!

00:05:40.416 --> 00:05:42.916
You're sending to my daughter these dolls

00:05:43.457 --> 00:05:45.498
What a cheap surprise

00:05:46.749 --> 00:05:49.374
What do you know about girls?

00:05:49.374 --> 00:05:50.082
This morning

00:05:50.082 --> 00:05:53.498
A female corpse was found in
an industrial building in Ngau Tau Kok

00:05:53.499 --> 00:05:56.207
25-year-old male suspect, Lee,
was arrested on site

00:05:56.207 --> 00:05:59.415
The victim is identified as
Hong Kong billionaire Kwok Sai-wing's daughter

00:05:59.416 --> 00:06:00.499
Preliminary evidence suggests

00:06:00.499 --> 00:06:03.499
Cause of death as excessive blood loss
from a fractured skull

00:06:03.499 --> 00:06:05.457
The authorities have classified this
as a rape and murder case

00:06:05.457 --> 00:06:08.998
Kwok Sai-wing refused to comment on
his daughter's murder

00:06:09.041 --> 00:06:12.207
You met her at the bar, she invited you home

00:06:12.207 --> 00:06:14.248
You got drunk after having sex with her

00:06:14.249 --> 00:06:16.874
She was dead next to you when you woke up?

00:06:17.791 --> 00:06:18.832
Yes

00:06:19.624 --> 00:06:21.415
The door was locked

00:06:21.416 --> 00:06:23.957
You were the only one in the house

00:06:23.957 --> 00:06:26.790
If it wasn't you, who the hell was it?

00:06:26.791 --> 00:06:28.082
Officer, I didn't do it

00:06:28.082 --> 00:06:30.373
I didn't kill anyone, I didn't kill her

00:06:30.666 --> 00:06:32.332
...remember now

00:06:32.541 --> 00:06:34.624
I heard some noise when I was sleeping

00:06:34.624 --> 00:06:38.415
Enough! If you knew how to solve it,
you would have already

00:06:38.416 --> 00:06:40.749
Then I smelled something acidic

00:06:42.457 --> 00:06:44.457
When I woke up again, there you all were

00:06:45.457 --> 00:06:47.457
What acidic smell?

00:06:47.457 --> 00:06:49.540
Didn't you say you were blackout drunk?

00:06:49.874 --> 00:06:51.082
You trying to give me a false statement?

00:06:51.082 --> 00:06:53.082
I didn't give a false statement,
I was really drunk!

00:06:53.374 --> 00:06:54.290
I didn't kill her!

00:06:54.291 --> 00:06:56.374
Slow down, take it easy

00:06:56.707 --> 00:06:58.540
If you don't remember clearly

00:06:58.541 --> 00:07:00.166
Then let's not record this part of the statement

00:07:00.166 --> 00:07:03.124
No! I mean it,
I remember smelling something acidic

00:07:03.124 --> 00:07:05.040
Check if this statement is all right

00:07:05.041 --> 00:07:06.874
If it's fine, sign it

00:07:07.374 --> 00:07:10.165
Meanwhile, it's important that you
assist our investigation

00:07:10.457 --> 00:07:11.582
Understand?

00:07:13.624 --> 00:07:14.832
Take a look

00:07:14.832 --> 00:07:16.582
Sign it if it's all right

00:07:20.249 --> 00:07:23.040
Officer, I'm Lee Yat-fung's grandmother

00:07:23.041 --> 00:07:25.791
Someone called today and said he got arrested

00:07:25.791 --> 00:07:27.624
I'm here to bail him out

00:07:28.082 --> 00:07:30.498
I'm Officer Chiu, I'm in charge of this case

00:07:30.499 --> 00:07:33.040
We are formally charging your grandson with murder

00:07:33.041 --> 00:07:34.582
You can't bail him out now

00:07:35.832 --> 00:07:37.790
There must be a mistake, officer

00:07:37.791 --> 00:07:40.832
My grandson is a delinquent,
but he won't kill anyone

00:07:40.832 --> 00:07:43.540
Let me see him and talk to him directly

00:07:43.541 --> 00:07:45.541
The suspect is not feeling well

00:07:45.541 --> 00:07:46.874
And we have a regulation

00:07:46.874 --> 00:07:49.624
We have the right to reject anyone
who might compromise the investigation

00:07:49.624 --> 00:07:51.249
You can't see him today

00:07:51.249 --> 00:07:54.582
You should go back and find him a good lawyer

00:08:17.416 --> 00:08:21.207
Don't do that,
paying the fine means admitting guilt

00:08:21.916 --> 00:08:24.582
You didn't steal the cardboard,
I'll be filing an appeal for you

00:08:24.582 --> 00:08:26.248
Don't worry about the retainer

00:08:26.249 --> 00:08:27.499
I'll call you later

00:08:27.874 --> 00:08:29.332
Kelvin

00:08:30.832 --> 00:08:34.248
Don't worry, I'm not your boss

00:08:34.249 --> 00:08:36.249
Just pay your rent on time

00:08:36.249 --> 00:08:38.082
But seriously, losing 12 cases in a row

00:08:38.082 --> 00:08:41.498
Is as difficult as winning 12 in a row like me

00:08:42.082 --> 00:08:43.248
Keep it up

00:08:43.249 --> 00:08:46.249
I'm not losing, it's just that I haven't won yet

00:08:47.041 --> 00:08:49.166
Don't be so petty

00:08:49.707 --> 00:08:53.165
You get paid regardless,
so you can afford your rent

00:08:53.166 --> 00:08:54.374
Barrister Lui

00:08:54.957 --> 00:08:56.915
The law might be a business to you,

00:08:56.916 --> 00:08:58.749
but it is sacred to me

00:08:58.749 --> 00:09:00.582
I won't give up until I win

00:09:00.582 --> 00:09:02.748
Very good, keep it up

00:09:06.041 --> 00:09:08.541
Attorney Cheung, wait here,
I've notified Barrister Ho

00:09:08.541 --> 00:09:09.916
Okay, thanks

00:09:11.249 --> 00:09:12.415
Attorney Cheung

00:09:12.874 --> 00:09:14.207
I've already hired you

00:09:14.207 --> 00:09:14.748
Yes

00:09:14.749 --> 00:09:17.415
Why do I need to hire another lawyer?

00:09:17.416 --> 00:09:20.374
Granny Lee, I'm a solicitor

00:09:20.374 --> 00:09:22.874
And Lee Yat-fung's case is a criminal case

00:09:22.874 --> 00:09:26.790
So we need a barrister to represent him in court

00:09:45.832 --> 00:09:47.790
I don't want him to be my grandson's lawyer

00:09:48.457 --> 00:09:49.873
It's not him

00:09:57.957 --> 00:10:00.332
Granny Lee, please come with me

00:10:01.999 --> 00:10:03.374
Barrister Ho

00:10:04.124 --> 00:10:08.624
You must help my grandson, he's innocent

00:10:11.791 --> 00:10:14.041
Did you give me a discount on the retainer?

00:10:14.041 --> 00:10:16.666
It's okay, charge me the normal price

00:10:16.666 --> 00:10:20.624
It's more important that you help my grandson

00:10:20.624 --> 00:10:22.124
I'm begging you

00:10:22.832 --> 00:10:26.540
Granny, relax, don't worry about the retainer

00:10:29.166 --> 00:10:31.416
I really want to see him

00:10:32.624 --> 00:10:34.457
Is there anything you can do to help?

00:10:34.457 --> 00:10:37.290
I promise I'll arrange a meeting
as soon as possible

00:10:38.499 --> 00:10:41.999
He really is innocent, he really is

00:10:42.207 --> 00:10:44.665
He won't do anything like this

00:11:08.832 --> 00:11:10.207
What's the plan?

00:11:12.791 --> 00:11:14.957
Department of Justice hasn't pressed charges yet

00:11:15.916 --> 00:11:17.541
According to Lee Yat-fung's statement

00:11:17.874 --> 00:11:20.374
When he was sleeping in the victim's workshop

00:11:20.374 --> 00:11:22.290
He heard some loud noises

00:11:22.832 --> 00:11:25.457
This building has only one apartment on each floor

00:11:25.457 --> 00:11:28.332
There are factory outlets on other floors

00:11:28.332 --> 00:11:31.457
Normally, nobody would be around at these hours

00:11:38.916 --> 00:11:40.499
"Manslaughter"

00:11:40.624 --> 00:11:41.957
Any problems?

00:11:43.082 --> 00:11:47.582
Doesn't the law guarantee everyone
the right to a fair trial?

00:11:48.124 --> 00:11:51.999
You want him to confess before the Department
of Justice presses charges?

00:11:52.666 --> 00:11:54.791
Besides a plea bargain,

00:11:54.791 --> 00:11:56.582
what better suggestion do you have?

00:12:04.874 --> 00:12:06.040
Kelvin

00:12:06.041 --> 00:12:08.832
We are defense attorneys, not Sherlock Holmes

00:12:08.832 --> 00:12:11.915
Kwok Ka-yee's killer is not the main focus

00:12:11.916 --> 00:12:13.207
And is not our responsibility

00:12:13.207 --> 00:12:15.207
The key to this case is

00:12:15.207 --> 00:12:17.998
How to give our clients the biggest advantage

00:12:17.999 --> 00:12:19.540
This is a simple principle

00:12:19.541 --> 00:12:21.999
You should've learned that during
your first year of law school

00:12:21.999 --> 00:12:24.374
I learned that 'everyone is equal before the law'

00:12:24.374 --> 00:12:27.165
Everyone should be considered innocent
until proven guilty

00:12:32.249 --> 00:12:33.207
Okay

00:13:06.457 --> 00:13:07.623
Indian lettuce

00:13:08.499 --> 00:13:09.457
US$10

00:13:11.999 --> 00:13:13.082
Thank you

00:13:18.582 --> 00:13:19.707
Auntie Chu

00:13:20.332 --> 00:13:22.582
You grandson is being accused of murder

00:13:22.582 --> 00:13:23.998
It's a tough case

00:13:24.499 --> 00:13:26.707
Stop talking about murder

00:13:26.707 --> 00:13:28.957
My grandson never killed anyone

00:13:35.582 --> 00:13:37.582
Barrister Ho might not be able to help you

00:13:39.791 --> 00:13:41.499
Go find Barrister Cheung

00:13:42.082 --> 00:13:44.665
He's good at handling cases like this

00:13:51.874 --> 00:13:55.332
Take this cheque, he is quite expensive

00:14:08.666 --> 00:14:10.457
We won't accept any compensation from the Kwok's

00:14:10.582 --> 00:14:11.665
That's right!

00:14:13.291 --> 00:14:15.666
Listen to me, calm down

00:14:15.874 --> 00:14:19.957
Mr. Lui, conciliation out of court
is your best option

00:14:19.957 --> 00:14:22.165
Everyone will lose if we go to court

00:14:23.499 --> 00:14:24.749
Let me tell you

00:14:24.749 --> 00:14:27.165
We won't stop suing until we're at
The Court of Final Appeal

00:14:29.749 --> 00:14:32.332
As the major landlord of
Sing Fu Shopping Mall

00:14:32.332 --> 00:14:36.540
You must bear all responsibility for this incident

00:14:36.832 --> 00:14:38.123
Objection

00:14:38.124 --> 00:14:41.124
The plaintiff has made an unreasonable accusation

00:14:44.957 --> 00:14:49.457
As the plaintiff fails to prove the
collapse of Sing Fu Shopping Mall

00:14:50.041 --> 00:14:54.541
Is directly correlated with the quality
of construction materials

00:14:55.332 --> 00:14:57.248
Provided by Kwok Properties

00:14:57.999 --> 00:14:59.915
The collapse is purely accidental

00:15:00.249 --> 00:15:02.124
And is not caused by human negligence

00:15:02.624 --> 00:15:07.124
I now pronounce that Kwok Group is not
obliged to pay compensation

00:15:08.082 --> 00:15:12.165
The plantiff must settle all court
and tribunal fees

00:15:14.582 --> 00:15:16.498
You didn't know about this?

00:15:16.499 --> 00:15:20.707
We only know that his daughter
goes to a boarding school in the UK

00:15:20.707 --> 00:15:22.957
But no one asked where her mother was

00:15:35.207 --> 00:15:36.832
'The law holds that it is better that
ten guilty persons escape

00:15:36.832 --> 00:15:38.915
Than that one innocent party suffer'

00:15:38.916 --> 00:15:40.124
- Sir William Blackstone

00:16:07.707 --> 00:16:09.540
Do you smell cigarettes?

00:16:11.957 --> 00:16:13.998
I promised someone I'd quit

00:16:18.249 --> 00:16:21.165
You used to be quite righteous

00:16:21.666 --> 00:16:25.916
You helped the underprivileged fight
against the high wall

00:16:26.499 --> 00:16:28.249
What happened?

00:16:31.707 --> 00:16:34.832
You're oversimplifying things

00:16:34.832 --> 00:16:39.332
So if everyone stands on the side of the egg

00:16:39.416 --> 00:16:42.166
The high wall will fall by itself?

00:16:57.749 --> 00:16:59.499
Leave it here

00:17:05.124 --> 00:17:08.665
The most pressing issue is to
let Auntie Chu see her grandson

00:17:09.374 --> 00:17:10.499
Piece of cake

00:17:11.666 --> 00:17:13.957
You don't have to do a thing in there

00:17:13.957 --> 00:17:17.373
I guarantee Dicky will see
Auntie Chu before his hearing

00:17:17.374 --> 00:17:18.415
Okay?

00:17:22.416 --> 00:17:23.582
Thank you

00:17:31.082 --> 00:17:32.498
Mr. Lee

00:17:32.499 --> 00:17:35.540
I'm Ho Hok-ming,
your grandmother hired me to represent you

00:17:35.541 --> 00:17:37.999
What about my grandma? Why isn't she here?

00:17:37.999 --> 00:17:39.790
I'm arranging a meeting for you

00:17:39.791 --> 00:17:41.332
Is she all right? Where is she now?

00:17:41.332 --> 00:17:44.290
Don't worry, your grandma is fine

00:17:44.291 --> 00:17:45.791
Mr. Lee Yat-fung

00:17:46.124 --> 00:17:48.374
Did you ask Barrister Ho to refer me

00:17:48.374 --> 00:17:52.540
Barrister Lui Yau-fai,
as your chief defense attorney?

00:17:59.624 --> 00:18:00.499
Yes

00:18:01.791 --> 00:18:05.957
Officer, since you forgot to turn off the CCTV

00:18:06.499 --> 00:18:08.582
You might as well be my witness

00:18:08.582 --> 00:18:10.207
Turn if off, please

00:18:17.999 --> 00:18:19.290
Mr. Lee Yat-fung

00:18:19.707 --> 00:18:22.707
From now on, I am officially your defense attorney

00:18:22.707 --> 00:18:26.040
If anyone asks you about what happened that night

00:18:26.041 --> 00:18:27.541
All you have to say is

00:18:27.541 --> 00:18:30.624
'I'm sorry, I'm unwell,

00:18:30.624 --> 00:18:32.582
I don't want to answer your questions'

00:18:32.582 --> 00:18:33.707
Okay?

00:18:34.207 --> 00:18:37.248
I'm sorry, I'm unwell,

00:18:37.249 --> 00:18:38.957
I don't want to answer your questions

00:18:38.957 --> 00:18:40.123
Good

00:18:45.332 --> 00:18:47.082
What are you doing?

00:18:47.082 --> 00:18:50.498
Our client is hurting himself,
call an ambulance

00:19:20.791 --> 00:19:23.291
I'm a man of my word

00:19:28.624 --> 00:19:29.915
Can you please explain?

00:19:33.374 --> 00:19:34.374
Officer

00:19:35.582 --> 00:19:39.707
My assistant and I are here to see
my client Mr. Lee Yat-fung

00:19:54.291 --> 00:19:55.457
Thank you

00:20:03.499 --> 00:20:04.249
Grandma

00:20:04.249 --> 00:20:05.915
Grandma, are you all right?

00:20:05.916 --> 00:20:06.916
Grandma

00:20:08.874 --> 00:20:11.540
I didn't do it, Grandma. I didn't kill anyone

00:20:11.791 --> 00:20:15.499
I just wanted to drink,
when I woke up, I saw her...

00:20:16.624 --> 00:20:20.124
I've always told you not to drink

00:20:20.124 --> 00:20:22.165
Why don't you listen?

00:20:22.166 --> 00:20:23.999
I'm sorry, Grandma

00:20:23.999 --> 00:20:28.415
I never asked you to be a genius or a billionaire

00:20:28.416 --> 00:20:30.624
I just wanted you to be a good person

00:20:30.624 --> 00:20:33.457
Is it that hard?

00:20:33.499 --> 00:20:34.957
No!

00:20:34.957 --> 00:20:37.498
Grandma, I know I messed up

00:20:37.499 --> 00:20:39.540
Your parents are not around anymore

00:20:39.541 --> 00:20:43.332
Do you want Grandma to be left alone too?

00:20:43.332 --> 00:20:44.457
No, Grandma

00:20:44.457 --> 00:20:48.290
No, Grandma, I won't do it again

00:20:48.624 --> 00:20:50.915
I'm sorry!

00:20:50.957 --> 00:20:52.457
When you're in jail

00:20:52.457 --> 00:20:55.373
Don't fight and argue with others

00:20:55.374 --> 00:20:56.457
Yes

00:20:56.457 --> 00:20:58.498
Remember to eat no matter what

00:20:58.499 --> 00:21:01.624
Don't listen to what people say against you

00:21:01.624 --> 00:21:03.957
Don't fight with others

00:21:04.124 --> 00:21:05.915
I won't

00:21:06.249 --> 00:21:08.790
Listen to this man from now on

00:21:09.082 --> 00:21:11.748
He's the only one who can save you, understand?

00:21:11.749 --> 00:21:13.290
I understand

00:21:13.957 --> 00:21:16.248
I'm sorry, Grandma

00:21:24.249 --> 00:21:27.999
Defendant Lee Yat-fung is
suspected of murdering Kwok Ka-yee

00:21:27.999 --> 00:21:30.749
A female of Chinese descent on 18 Oct, 2018

00:21:30.749 --> 00:21:33.999
Defendant, do you understand
the charges against you?

00:21:34.457 --> 00:21:35.540
Yes

00:21:36.041 --> 00:21:39.166
Defendant will be detained in
Lai Chi Kok Reception Centre

00:21:39.166 --> 00:21:41.499
While awaiting trial and further investigation

00:21:41.499 --> 00:21:44.415
Mention will be held on 20 Nov

00:21:46.166 --> 00:21:47.457
These days, young people like us

00:21:47.457 --> 00:21:49.373
Only earn a bit more than 10k each month

00:21:49.374 --> 00:21:52.874
We can't even afford a trip to Japan,
let alone owning properties

00:21:53.999 --> 00:21:56.290
How can we give up a trip to Japan?

00:21:56.291 --> 00:21:58.666
We can take budget airlines and stay in hostels

00:21:58.666 --> 00:22:02.124
Our generation should be open to changes

00:22:02.124 --> 00:22:03.665
Never lose faith

00:22:03.666 --> 00:22:04.582
Thank you

00:22:05.416 --> 00:22:07.582
Mr. Tsang

00:22:09.457 --> 00:22:11.665
Kwok sai-wing's daughter Kwok Ka-yee

00:22:11.666 --> 00:22:13.666
Was found dead in a property under your name

00:22:13.666 --> 00:22:15.082
Do you have anything you'd like to say?

00:22:15.082 --> 00:22:16.998
What's your relationship with Miss Kwok?

00:22:17.457 --> 00:22:20.457
I just read about this on the news

00:22:20.457 --> 00:22:22.248
I'm truly saddened by it

00:22:22.582 --> 00:22:24.540
The two properties under my name

00:22:24.541 --> 00:22:26.749
Have been handled by my colleagues

00:22:26.749 --> 00:22:31.249
As far as I know,
the rent is lower than average

00:22:31.332 --> 00:22:35.832
So young people can rent it
as workshops or band studios

00:22:35.832 --> 00:22:38.165
I sincerely hope that you will

00:22:38.166 --> 00:22:41.207
Give some space to the bereaved to cope
with their grief

00:22:41.207 --> 00:22:42.373
Thank you

00:22:45.957 --> 00:22:47.415
Vote for Candidate no.1

00:22:48.624 --> 00:22:50.915
Thank you for your hard work

00:22:56.291 --> 00:22:57.541
Daddy

00:23:00.957 --> 00:23:02.207
Thank you

00:23:02.207 --> 00:23:06.707
Thank you for being here for
my son's election rally

00:23:12.291 --> 00:23:16.332
When Chi-wai graduated from school

00:23:16.791 --> 00:23:20.041
He said he wanted to join CFP

00:23:20.874 --> 00:23:25.374
And serve the Hong Kong people

00:23:25.624 --> 00:23:28.374
I thought he was only joking

00:23:30.916 --> 00:23:35.416
So I said,
you must do well at the district level

00:23:40.832 --> 00:23:43.873
After 5 years of hard work

00:23:45.332 --> 00:23:47.082
I think he's more mature

00:23:47.082 --> 00:23:50.790
And definitely able
to serve the people of Hong Kong

00:23:51.332 --> 00:23:52.373
Sounds good?

00:23:52.374 --> 00:23:54.040
Yeah!

00:23:54.332 --> 00:23:56.207
Thank you for your support

00:23:57.874 --> 00:23:59.290
Yes, Mr. Tsang

00:23:59.957 --> 00:24:02.457
Smart ass, what's your problem?

00:24:04.249 --> 00:24:06.415
'Tate's Cairn Tunnel'

00:24:06.416 --> 00:24:08.541
Not 'Tate's Kairo Tunnel'

00:24:08.916 --> 00:24:10.666
It starts with a C

00:24:11.124 --> 00:24:13.915
All your English posts have bad grammar

00:24:13.916 --> 00:24:16.041
And you don't know Chinese

00:24:16.041 --> 00:24:17.999
Did you get your degree by lottery?

00:24:18.916 --> 00:24:20.541
- Rubbish
- Sorry

00:24:36.124 --> 00:24:40.249
Who's the woman who barged in to interview me?

00:24:40.999 --> 00:24:42.665
Why didn't anyone block her?

00:24:43.541 --> 00:24:45.374
If I didn't handle it by myself

00:24:45.874 --> 00:24:47.915
We would've all been screwed, right?

00:24:48.332 --> 00:24:49.540
Sorry

00:24:50.874 --> 00:24:54.290
From now on, in all of my election rallies

00:24:54.291 --> 00:24:57.374
We will only invite proper journalists

00:24:57.374 --> 00:24:59.374
Not this bitch we saw today

00:24:59.791 --> 00:25:00.874
Understand?

00:25:00.874 --> 00:25:02.082
Yes

00:25:02.499 --> 00:25:03.665
Get back to work

00:25:54.707 --> 00:25:56.165
Take care

00:25:56.249 --> 00:25:58.207
My condolences

00:26:01.832 --> 00:26:04.290
Uncle, please accept my condolences

00:26:04.874 --> 00:26:07.832
If I didn't make Angie stay in Hong Kong

00:26:07.832 --> 00:26:10.373
This wouldn't have happened

00:26:10.749 --> 00:26:12.749
Don't blame yourself

00:26:16.374 --> 00:26:18.874
Now we know the truth

00:26:19.916 --> 00:26:22.582
Angie can rest in peace

00:26:30.082 --> 00:26:31.457
Uncle, I'm leaving for now

00:26:33.999 --> 00:26:35.499
Chi-wai

00:26:36.291 --> 00:26:39.541
Do you mind staying here with me and Angie?

00:26:53.541 --> 00:26:54.749
Master

00:26:57.416 --> 00:26:59.207
I've read through the case

00:26:59.207 --> 00:27:02.915
It's attempted rape turned murder

00:27:02.916 --> 00:27:04.332
Simple case

00:27:05.499 --> 00:27:07.374
My superiors are concerned about this case

00:27:07.374 --> 00:27:09.624
I want you to be the lead prosecutor

00:27:09.624 --> 00:27:10.874
Why not?

00:27:10.874 --> 00:27:14.999
The defense has hired Lui Yau-fai and Kelvin Ho

00:27:14.999 --> 00:27:18.249
You must know that Lui Yau-fai
is every prosecutor's kryptonite

00:27:18.666 --> 00:27:22.332
But I'm confident in my students

00:27:22.707 --> 00:27:24.915
I know you will perform well

00:27:25.249 --> 00:27:26.374
I'll be okay

00:27:26.874 --> 00:27:28.915
We've got all the prima facie evidence

00:27:28.916 --> 00:27:31.541
We just need their counter-offer

00:27:42.124 --> 00:27:44.374
I'm about to retire

00:27:44.791 --> 00:27:47.249
Do well and I'll recommend you to

00:27:47.707 --> 00:27:51.832
The Secretary of Justice to be
the Recorder of the High Court

00:27:51.832 --> 00:27:54.332
You've spent all these years looking up from below

00:27:54.332 --> 00:27:56.957
It's about time you sit up there

00:27:58.291 --> 00:27:59.541
Thank you, Master

00:28:16.874 --> 00:28:18.374
Do you really recognize him?

00:28:19.124 --> 00:28:22.165
Yes

00:28:22.249 --> 00:28:24.332
The girl was drinking here that night

00:28:24.332 --> 00:28:26.415
The guy thought she was hot

00:28:26.416 --> 00:28:28.082
He came over to flirt with her

00:28:28.082 --> 00:28:30.248
But she ignored him

00:28:30.249 --> 00:28:34.499
I even heard her tell him to piss off

00:28:37.124 --> 00:28:41.207
DoJ has confirmed
to charge Lee Yat-fung with murder

00:28:42.541 --> 00:28:45.791
Tina took the vacuum bag for
lab analysis this morning

00:28:48.832 --> 00:28:52.040
Except the robot vacuum cleaner in the crime scene

00:28:52.041 --> 00:28:53.457
We found nothing else

00:28:53.916 --> 00:28:57.499
This crime scene is too pristine

00:28:57.499 --> 00:28:59.499
There are doubts in the case

00:28:59.999 --> 00:29:01.915
All the statements and evidence

00:29:01.916 --> 00:29:04.666
Have pointed towards Dicky being the murderer

00:29:04.666 --> 00:29:07.249
There's a loophole in the collection of evidence

00:29:08.457 --> 00:29:10.623
In the evidence list

00:29:10.624 --> 00:29:12.540
Let's forget about Kwok Ka-yee's computer

00:29:12.541 --> 00:29:14.374
There isn't even a cellphone

00:29:14.791 --> 00:29:18.624
How can a person live without
a cellphone nowadays?

00:29:18.624 --> 00:29:21.374
The vanished phone and computer

00:29:21.374 --> 00:29:23.999
If we present these doubts in court

00:29:23.999 --> 00:29:25.332
Even Joe can't do anything about it

00:29:25.332 --> 00:29:28.665
Give me the list of eyewitnesses
who gave statements

00:29:31.874 --> 00:29:36.374
All of them are male except the cleaning lady

00:29:37.332 --> 00:29:41.707
Then where is the girl
sitting next to Angie that day?

00:29:45.874 --> 00:29:48.499
She must know some crucial information

00:29:48.874 --> 00:29:50.499
We must find her soon

00:29:51.666 --> 00:29:52.749
I've found her

00:29:52.957 --> 00:29:54.207
She's Cat

00:29:54.832 --> 00:29:56.415
Angie's assistant

00:29:57.416 --> 00:29:59.957
Is Cat the murderer?

00:30:00.624 --> 00:30:01.415
If it wasn't her,

00:30:01.416 --> 00:30:03.624
then why hasn't she shown up since the incident?

00:30:23.457 --> 00:30:26.290
I had to catch a plane that night, so I left early

00:30:27.082 --> 00:30:28.582
Before you left,

00:30:28.582 --> 00:30:31.248
did Lee Yat-fung interact with Miss Kwok?

00:30:31.249 --> 00:30:32.415
I forgot

00:30:34.666 --> 00:30:37.666
Miss Kwok's laptop is gone,
do you know where it is?

00:30:38.207 --> 00:30:39.748
How would I know?

00:30:39.749 --> 00:30:42.915
I just got off the plane,
I haven't even gone home

00:30:43.291 --> 00:30:44.916
That laptop is very important to us

00:30:44.916 --> 00:30:46.291
Let's talk another time

00:30:47.541 --> 00:30:48.624
This was fixed a long time ago

00:30:48.624 --> 00:30:49.624
I thought you didn't want it anymore

00:30:49.624 --> 00:30:51.540
I forgot about it, thanks

00:30:56.207 --> 00:30:59.873
Someone told the press that Mr. Tsang had
an affair with Kwok Sai-wing's daughter

00:31:00.374 --> 00:31:01.999
Can you get Mr. Tsang to respond?

00:31:02.207 --> 00:31:04.498
Media partners, please calm down

00:31:04.499 --> 00:31:07.207
Mr. Tsang will not be commenting on anything today

00:31:07.207 --> 00:31:08.915
Please leave for now

00:31:10.416 --> 00:31:13.832
"No Caller ID"

00:31:15.666 --> 00:31:16.916
Hello?

00:31:16.916 --> 00:31:18.041
This is Cat

00:31:18.624 --> 00:31:21.457
You should know that I have a lot more with me

00:31:21.457 --> 00:31:25.082
Let's get it over with,
SO we can go our separate ways

00:31:25.082 --> 00:31:26.165
No problem

00:31:26.541 --> 00:31:27.582
Where should we meet?

00:31:27.582 --> 00:31:30.498
2pm tomorrow, Sheung Wan Parking Lot

00:31:31.457 --> 00:31:33.748
Come alone, don't play games

00:31:46.291 --> 00:31:47.416
Daddy

00:31:48.499 --> 00:31:52.874
She wants $5 million for the photos

00:31:55.999 --> 00:31:58.165
Be smart!

00:32:00.374 --> 00:32:01.582
Sorry, Daddy

00:32:02.207 --> 00:32:03.123
Mr. Tsang

00:32:03.624 --> 00:32:06.165
It's simple, I'll find someone to get rid of her

00:32:07.124 --> 00:32:08.999
Do you really know how to do it?

00:32:43.207 --> 00:32:44.290
Where's my money?

00:32:45.624 --> 00:32:46.665
Give it to me

00:33:08.416 --> 00:33:09.582
Get in

00:33:28.666 --> 00:33:30.749
If it was just the photos

00:33:31.207 --> 00:33:33.707
Tsang Chi-wai wouldn't have been so nervous

00:33:33.707 --> 00:33:34.998
How do I know?

00:33:36.166 --> 00:33:37.749
Maybe he's worried that if this gets out

00:33:37.749 --> 00:33:39.332
He won't get elected

00:33:39.332 --> 00:33:40.998
Speak up, maybe we can help you

00:33:40.999 --> 00:33:42.915
Perhaps things can change

00:33:43.416 --> 00:33:45.582
Miss Chan, please help us

00:33:56.457 --> 00:34:00.623
Okay, he reached out to me that night

00:34:01.374 --> 00:34:03.582
I've been looking for Angie all night

00:34:03.582 --> 00:34:04.957
Are you with her right now?

00:34:04.957 --> 00:34:07.540
I was at the workshop,
and the password was changed

00:34:07.541 --> 00:34:08.874
What do you want?

00:34:09.499 --> 00:34:12.290
I'm outside the workshop, just tell me

00:34:14.666 --> 00:34:17.166
'3690', don't let her know I told you

00:34:18.416 --> 00:34:19.832
All right, I got in

00:34:20.916 --> 00:34:22.166
That's all

00:34:23.666 --> 00:34:25.749
This recording is key to this case

00:34:26.791 --> 00:34:29.749
If you can articulate this in court

00:34:29.749 --> 00:34:31.540
Dicky will definitely be acquitted

00:34:34.749 --> 00:34:37.457
Do you want your boss' death to go unsolved?

00:34:37.957 --> 00:34:39.415
Where's your conscience?

00:34:39.957 --> 00:34:41.832
'Conscience' doesn't put food on the table

00:34:41.832 --> 00:34:45.207
If I go to court,
what will Tsang Chi-wai do to me?

00:34:45.207 --> 00:34:46.707
Do I have a choice?

00:34:46.707 --> 00:34:48.415
But Dicky is innocent

00:34:48.416 --> 00:34:51.041
If you don't help him, no one can

00:34:51.041 --> 00:34:54.582
Forget it, Kelvin, you can't force it on her

00:34:54.582 --> 00:34:58.623
<i>Add Cat to the list of defense witnesses tomorrow</i>

00:35:02.666 --> 00:35:04.207
But I really won't know

00:35:04.582 --> 00:35:07.082
What Tsang Chi-wai will think then

00:35:09.707 --> 00:35:13.707
Mr. Tsang, you reached out to me personally,
I'll get it done

00:35:13.707 --> 00:35:14.998
Don't worry

00:35:15.707 --> 00:35:17.707
Just keep an eye on them

00:35:17.707 --> 00:35:21.498
Take action when you see that girl

00:35:22.207 --> 00:35:23.582
That's it

00:35:30.957 --> 00:35:33.457
Please vote for No.1, thank you

00:35:33.457 --> 00:35:34.915
Way to go

00:35:35.957 --> 00:35:38.040
Thank you, let's take a photo

00:35:41.582 --> 00:35:45.040
Thank you, vote for No.1

00:35:46.541 --> 00:35:47.957
Hello

00:35:57.749 --> 00:35:58.290
Hello?

00:35:58.291 --> 00:35:59.582
Barrister Lui,

00:35:59.582 --> 00:36:02.623
I have some information on the Kwok Group and CFP

00:36:02.624 --> 00:36:05.249
Given to me by their former Financial Director

00:36:05.249 --> 00:36:08.665
I want to seek your legal advice
before posting it online

00:36:09.749 --> 00:36:11.124
Let's meet up

00:36:11.124 --> 00:36:14.040
Let me organize them, see you tonight at 11

00:36:42.416 --> 00:36:43.582
Have a seat

00:36:43.582 --> 00:36:44.915
Mr. Tsang

00:36:46.374 --> 00:36:50.332
I've always wanted to meet you, Barrister Lui

00:36:51.249 --> 00:36:53.624
Today is the day

00:36:55.582 --> 00:36:59.623
Would you mind cruising on
the tram with an old man?

00:36:59.624 --> 00:37:01.582
I haven't taken the tram in a while

00:37:01.582 --> 00:37:03.957
My first job was a tram driver

00:37:04.832 --> 00:37:09.332
I joined the labor union to
attain better benefits for the workers

00:37:10.624 --> 00:37:14.249
And before I knew it, I've founded CFP

00:37:15.332 --> 00:37:16.957
This year marks

00:37:18.207 --> 00:37:21.123
The 40th anniversary of CFP

00:37:22.666 --> 00:37:23.999
Congratulations

00:37:25.832 --> 00:37:28.665
We politicians are no different from you lawyers

00:37:28.666 --> 00:37:33.166
When I was young, I fought for truth and justice

00:37:33.582 --> 00:37:34.832
But what now?

00:37:34.832 --> 00:37:36.123
The conclusion is

00:37:36.582 --> 00:37:39.540
Nobody needs these things

00:37:40.249 --> 00:37:43.165
These are just slogans and gestures

00:37:43.707 --> 00:37:45.165
They don't make a living

00:37:45.541 --> 00:37:48.041
Even if you sacrifice yourself fighting for it

00:37:48.041 --> 00:37:50.916
Would anyone remember you? Or even care?

00:37:51.749 --> 00:37:53.249
Barrister Lui

00:37:54.082 --> 00:37:55.998
Talented people like you

00:37:56.666 --> 00:38:00.874
Shouldn't represent delinquents like Lee Yat-fung

00:38:00.874 --> 00:38:02.415
What a shame

00:38:02.416 --> 00:38:04.124
Consider working for us at CFP

00:38:04.124 --> 00:38:06.582
As my legal consultant

00:38:14.874 --> 00:38:16.290
Signing bonus

00:38:33.957 --> 00:38:35.248
That's right

00:38:36.082 --> 00:38:38.040
If you want someone talented

00:38:38.041 --> 00:38:40.249
You should spend more money

00:38:42.082 --> 00:38:43.748
Barrister Lui

00:38:43.749 --> 00:38:45.582
I'm adding $1 million on the table

00:38:50.291 --> 00:38:52.124
I'm sorry, Mr. Tsang

00:38:52.791 --> 00:38:56.666
I just received a cheque of $50,000 from
Lee Yat-fung's grandmother

00:38:57.582 --> 00:38:59.373
It's all that they had

00:38:59.707 --> 00:39:02.457
As a parent

00:39:02.457 --> 00:39:06.957
Even when you know your children
have made a mistake

00:39:07.624 --> 00:39:10.040
You will save him at all costs

00:39:10.041 --> 00:39:11.749
Mr. Tsang, I'm sure

00:39:13.082 --> 00:39:15.332
You know that feeling very well

00:39:16.916 --> 00:39:18.416
I'll get out of your hair, Mr. Tsang

00:39:18.874 --> 00:39:20.457
I'm leaving

00:40:21.624 --> 00:40:23.790
Daddy, Tai-tung got it done

00:40:26.207 --> 00:40:29.873
With so much happening in this world everyday

00:40:31.124 --> 00:40:34.707
People don't need to know every single one of them

00:40:39.499 --> 00:40:41.665
When did you start seeing my daughter?

00:40:44.874 --> 00:40:47.915
Uncle, I...

00:40:49.791 --> 00:40:52.207
I knew all about this

00:40:54.249 --> 00:40:58.040
Angie was a sensible girl

00:40:58.832 --> 00:41:03.332
Chi-wai knows how important
this election is to him

00:41:04.707 --> 00:41:09.207
They broke up before he
signed up for the election

00:41:10.541 --> 00:41:12.291
Right, Chi-wai?

00:41:12.291 --> 00:41:13.582
Yes, Uncle

00:41:13.957 --> 00:41:18.415
Angie and I had a fling, but we broke it off

00:41:35.124 --> 00:41:36.915
Barrister Lui, I'll fetch it for you

00:41:40.291 --> 00:41:42.541
"Fire Breaks Out at Nam Sang Wai"

00:41:42.541 --> 00:41:44.541
"Use of Vacant Government Land"

00:41:44.541 --> 00:41:45.291
Barrister Lui

00:41:45.291 --> 00:41:48.791
Tina was about to publish this draft
after consulting with you

00:41:51.624 --> 00:41:52.874
"Front page!"

00:41:59.749 --> 00:42:01.165
What is it? What can I do for you?

00:42:01.166 --> 00:42:02.832
We've found a witness

00:42:02.874 --> 00:42:04.749
We hope DoJ can protect the witness

00:42:04.749 --> 00:42:06.790
You should know that it's against regulations

00:42:06.791 --> 00:42:09.707
It'll be easy for me to know what you have

00:42:09.707 --> 00:42:11.748
Saving lives matters more than winning

00:42:18.916 --> 00:42:19.874
Fine

00:42:21.374 --> 00:42:22.457
Okay

00:42:26.374 --> 00:42:28.374
Officer Chiu, thanks for coming

00:42:34.999 --> 00:42:37.040
Security measures are not up to par

00:42:37.124 --> 00:42:39.082
I suggest transferring the witness

00:43:09.541 --> 00:43:10.624
Officer Chiu

00:43:42.916 --> 00:43:44.957
This is East Kowloon RCU Inspector Chiu Kwok-fai

00:43:45.874 --> 00:43:48.207
I was ambushed while transferring a witness

00:43:48.207 --> 00:43:49.957
Both the witness and the evidence are missing

00:43:50.457 --> 00:43:52.415
What is it?

00:43:52.416 --> 00:43:54.166
Please send backup

00:44:20.416 --> 00:44:24.499
Make yourselves at home, sorry it's a bit cramped

00:44:25.166 --> 00:44:29.082
Is Miss Cheung still at work? Should we call her?

00:44:31.874 --> 00:44:34.540
There was an accident, she's in the hospital now

00:44:34.832 --> 00:44:37.082
She's in the hospital?

00:44:38.166 --> 00:44:40.416
I'll bring her some soup later

00:44:40.416 --> 00:44:41.666
There's no need

00:44:42.041 --> 00:44:45.541
The doctor said she's fine,
she'll be discharged in 2 days

00:44:46.124 --> 00:44:49.749
You have to go to court tomorrow, rest up

00:44:51.791 --> 00:44:54.374
Right, Auntie Chu, don't worry

00:44:54.374 --> 00:44:56.749
We found a crucial witness to the case

00:44:56.749 --> 00:44:59.790
Your grandson will be home to have your soup soon

00:45:07.291 --> 00:45:09.832
I know how hard it must've been on you both

00:45:17.624 --> 00:45:19.207
Auntie Chu, have a goose leg

00:45:19.207 --> 00:45:20.373
Here

00:46:10.957 --> 00:46:15.165
"Be a good lawyer"

00:47:44.207 --> 00:47:45.540
A female corpse was found

00:47:45.541 --> 00:47:48.291
In an industrial building in October this year

00:47:48.291 --> 00:47:51.499
The identity is confirmed to be
billionaire Kwok Sai-wing's daughter

00:47:51.499 --> 00:47:53.124
And has become a very high profile case

00:47:53.124 --> 00:47:55.915
The murder trial starts today

00:47:57.166 --> 00:47:58.707
Here he is

00:47:59.207 --> 00:48:00.957
Mr. Kwok

00:48:01.332 --> 00:48:03.207
Say a few words

00:48:03.207 --> 00:48:04.582
What do you have to say?

00:48:05.332 --> 00:48:07.332
Mr. Kwok

00:48:07.332 --> 00:48:08.165
Any comments?

00:48:16.416 --> 00:48:17.707
Frankie

00:48:18.249 --> 00:48:18.915
Joe

00:48:18.916 --> 00:48:19.999
Long time no see

00:48:19.999 --> 00:48:22.374
Last time we saw each other
was right here 5-6 years ago

00:48:22.374 --> 00:48:24.332
I don't remember who won

00:48:24.332 --> 00:48:27.665
I used to count how many times I've won

00:48:28.291 --> 00:48:30.499
But recently, someone taught me

00:48:30.499 --> 00:48:33.665
That the law is sacred, not just a business

00:48:34.166 --> 00:48:38.541
If that's true,
what's the point of keeping count?

00:48:38.541 --> 00:48:39.582
Good luck

00:49:11.916 --> 00:49:12.916
Court

00:49:20.166 --> 00:49:24.041
Case No. HCCC96/2020,

00:49:24.041 --> 00:49:25.582
defendant Lee Yat-fung is suspected of

00:49:25.582 --> 00:49:27.748
Murdering Kwok Ka-yee,

00:49:27.749 --> 00:49:30.540
a female of Chinese descent on the night of 18 Oct

00:49:30.541 --> 00:49:33.457
Prosecutor, please summon your witness to testify

00:49:34.582 --> 00:49:35.665
Your Honour

00:49:35.666 --> 00:49:40.166
I'd like to summon Mr. Chan Kwok-sing,
bartender at King Pub, to testify

00:49:41.541 --> 00:49:43.749
What did you see that night?

00:49:44.416 --> 00:49:46.791
The victim drank a lot that night

00:49:46.957 --> 00:49:49.540
How did the victim react

00:49:49.541 --> 00:49:51.274
When the defendant bought her a drink?

00:49:51.332 --> 00:49:52.165
The victim ignored him

00:49:52.166 --> 00:49:54.249
And the guy just walked off

00:49:54.541 --> 00:49:55.666
Witness

00:49:56.416 --> 00:49:58.957
You said the victim turned down my client

00:49:59.416 --> 00:50:02.124
Do you remember what the victim said?

00:50:02.124 --> 00:50:04.332
The victim told the defendant to 'piss off'

00:50:04.332 --> 00:50:06.165
According to your statement

00:50:06.166 --> 00:50:10.582
My client flirted with the victim that night

00:50:10.582 --> 00:50:12.998
And the victim told my client to 'piss off'

00:50:13.832 --> 00:50:14.707
Is that right?

00:50:15.249 --> 00:50:15.957
Yes

00:50:15.957 --> 00:50:17.165
That's not possible

00:50:17.166 --> 00:50:21.666
This is a screen capture from
the CCTV that night

00:50:22.791 --> 00:50:25.999
It was completely packed

00:50:25.999 --> 00:50:28.290
I went to King Pub myself

00:50:28.291 --> 00:50:30.291
And did a simple experiment

00:50:30.291 --> 00:50:32.749
I recognize him, that night...

00:50:32.749 --> 00:50:33.915
I recognize him

00:50:33.916 --> 00:50:36.957
Music was loud, with strong bass speakers

00:50:36.957 --> 00:50:39.457
The noise level was over 90 decibels

00:50:39.457 --> 00:50:43.957
Witness, could you really hear
what the victim said?

00:50:45.999 --> 00:50:46.999
Yes

00:50:47.291 --> 00:50:51.499
Witness, you must have ridiculously good hearing

00:50:52.916 --> 00:50:57.374
Your Honour,
I'd like to summon my client Lee Yat-fung

00:51:02.374 --> 00:51:03.957
Mr. Lee Yat-fung

00:51:04.957 --> 00:51:07.707
Please tell us what happened that night

00:51:10.416 --> 00:51:11.707
That night

00:51:12.957 --> 00:51:14.765
I met Angie at the pub

00:51:14.832 --> 00:51:17.290
I had too much to drink, so I passed out

00:51:17.291 --> 00:51:20.291
And then what happened?

00:51:20.291 --> 00:51:23.582
I remember when I was sleeping

00:51:24.541 --> 00:51:26.499
I think I heard some noises

00:51:26.499 --> 00:51:29.499
But I was too drunk to wake up

00:51:29.499 --> 00:51:32.332
I was woken up by a loud shriek

00:51:32.332 --> 00:51:34.415
Then I realized it was already the next morning

00:51:34.416 --> 00:51:37.416
I woke up and saw...

00:51:38.374 --> 00:51:42.332
I saw Angie... lying next to me

00:51:43.416 --> 00:51:45.791
And the floor were covered in blood

00:51:47.541 --> 00:51:48.916
She wasn't breathing

00:51:48.916 --> 00:51:50.791
This is when I realized

00:51:51.999 --> 00:51:53.749
She was dead

00:51:57.374 --> 00:52:00.499
Your Honour, no further questions

00:52:04.499 --> 00:52:08.999
Defendant, what time did you arrive at the pub?

00:52:09.624 --> 00:52:12.707
Around 11:45pm

00:52:12.707 --> 00:52:17.207
You said you had a lovely chat with the victim

00:52:17.499 --> 00:52:19.790
Can you tell us what you two talked about?

00:52:19.791 --> 00:52:22.041
She told me

00:52:22.041 --> 00:52:26.249
About her art installation at MOMA in New York

00:52:26.249 --> 00:52:30.749
A new acquaintance who's pretty and cute

00:52:30.957 --> 00:52:34.957
Do you admit that you were
instantly attracted to her?

00:52:34.957 --> 00:52:36.082
Objection

00:52:36.082 --> 00:52:38.998
Calls for speculation

00:52:39.749 --> 00:52:43.249
Your Honour, this is not speculation

00:52:43.249 --> 00:52:47.749
This directly reflects
on the Defendant's motive to rape

00:52:49.041 --> 00:52:52.416
Overruled, Defendant must answer the question

00:52:53.499 --> 00:52:55.124
Please answer the question

00:52:55.124 --> 00:52:56.249
Yes

00:52:57.332 --> 00:52:58.373
I admit...

00:52:58.374 --> 00:53:02.874
Evidence suggests that you consumed
a lot of alcohol at her studio

00:53:03.124 --> 00:53:06.499
Can you tell us how much you drank?

00:53:06.999 --> 00:53:10.499
3 bottles of red wine and a bottle of whiskey

00:53:10.957 --> 00:53:12.123
Sorry

00:53:12.124 --> 00:53:13.374
I'm afraid I might be mishearing it

00:53:13.374 --> 00:53:16.540
The spectators and
the jury might have missed it too

00:53:16.541 --> 00:53:20.499
Can you repeat how much you drank that night?

00:53:23.791 --> 00:53:26.291
3 bottles of red wine

00:53:26.291 --> 00:53:27.374
And a bottle of whiskey

00:53:29.416 --> 00:53:32.582
I don't think my entire family can finish all that

00:53:32.582 --> 00:53:34.373
Did you get drunk?

00:53:35.041 --> 00:53:35.832
Yes

00:53:35.832 --> 00:53:37.998
That's why he raped the victim

00:53:38.000 --> 00:53:40.874
- it was consensual
- You took off the victim's clothes

00:53:45.432 --> 00:53:46.348
No, I didn't kill her!

00:53:46.349 --> 00:53:49.057
You just have to answer yes or no

00:53:49.057 --> 00:53:50.432
It was your plan all along

00:53:50.432 --> 00:53:52.098
Since the moment you met

00:53:52.099 --> 00:53:56.599
You used her interest in art to
lure her back to her studio

00:53:56.891 --> 00:53:58.932
You pretended to share her interest

00:53:58.932 --> 00:54:03.223
Just so you can rape her
when she was drunk

00:54:03.224 --> 00:54:06.974
But the victim wasn't drunk enough,
so she fought back

00:54:06.974 --> 00:54:08.432
You were worried about the consequences

00:54:08.432 --> 00:54:12.640
So you decided to rape and kill the victim

00:54:12.641 --> 00:54:15.182
- It was your plan all along
- No!

00:54:15.182 --> 00:54:16.140
Unforgivable

00:54:16.141 --> 00:54:17.891
No! I didn't do it! That's not true!

00:54:18.182 --> 00:54:20.890
Your Honour, I have no further questions

00:54:28.932 --> 00:54:30.557
Your Honour

00:54:30.557 --> 00:54:34.390
I'd like to summon our witness, Chan Sze-man

00:54:34.391 --> 00:54:38.016
Witness, please tell us
your relationship with the victim

00:54:38.016 --> 00:54:40.099
We were partners at work,

00:54:40.099 --> 00:54:41.974
and we hung out sometimes

00:54:41.974 --> 00:54:45.807
Sometimes we went out drinking,
we even traveled together

00:54:45.849 --> 00:54:48.849
I was drinking with Kwok Ka-yee
at King Pub that night

00:54:48.849 --> 00:54:50.765
When you were drinking

00:54:50.766 --> 00:54:54.099
What were you doing
when the defendant flirted with the victim?

00:54:54.099 --> 00:54:57.724
I had to catch a flight to Europe that night,
so I left early

00:54:58.141 --> 00:55:00.182
When did you come back to Hong Kong?

00:55:00.557 --> 00:55:04.390
Did you know about the death of the victim
when you were abroad?

00:55:04.391 --> 00:55:07.932
I didn't return to Hong Kong
until 2 weeks after the incident

00:55:07.932 --> 00:55:10.015
I turned off data roaming on my phone

00:55:10.016 --> 00:55:12.932
So I didn't even know that my friend died

00:55:12.932 --> 00:55:16.140
If I could turn back time,
I wouldn't have traveled

00:55:16.141 --> 00:55:17.391
I wouldn't have left her alone

00:55:17.474 --> 00:55:21.932
Did anyone reach out to you on your way
to the airport that night?

00:55:22.641 --> 00:55:23.349
No

00:55:23.807 --> 00:55:25.473
Do you know Tsang Chi-wai personally?

00:55:25.474 --> 00:55:28.474
I only know that he is up for an election

00:55:28.474 --> 00:55:30.140
I don't know whether Kwok Ka-yee knew him

00:55:30.141 --> 00:55:33.391
Tsang Chi-wai is your landlord,
how could you not know him?

00:55:33.391 --> 00:55:35.599
We only pay rent to the realtors

00:55:35.599 --> 00:55:37.849
Kwok Ka-yee was your friend

00:55:37.849 --> 00:55:39.932
And business partner

00:55:39.932 --> 00:55:44.182
I'm sure you'd notice
whom she frequently texted

00:55:44.182 --> 00:55:46.057
Or talked with over the phone?

00:55:46.057 --> 00:55:47.390
I didn't notice

00:55:47.391 --> 00:55:49.974
Did you know that Kwok Ka-yee
was involved in an affair?

00:55:49.974 --> 00:55:51.849
She had an affair with Tsang Chi-wai

00:55:51.849 --> 00:55:53.640
She wouldn't do that

00:55:53.682 --> 00:55:56.640
Then why did you use their intimate photos

00:55:56.641 --> 00:56:00.307
And messages to blackmail him for $5 million?

00:56:00.307 --> 00:56:03.682
I didn't, I don't know anything about it!

00:56:03.766 --> 00:56:05.557
Stop pushing me!

00:56:17.224 --> 00:56:21.057
Your Honour, no further questions

00:56:26.807 --> 00:56:28.015
Daddy

00:56:29.682 --> 00:56:32.723
It worked out, thank you

00:56:34.932 --> 00:56:39.432
Son, don't just look at the
golf ball by your foot

00:56:41.641 --> 00:56:43.599
You have to observe the hole ahead of you

00:57:41.641 --> 00:57:42.807
What's the matter?

00:57:42.807 --> 00:57:43.848
This is his attorney

00:57:44.266 --> 00:57:45.224
Come in

00:57:45.224 --> 00:57:46.432
Thank you

00:57:57.724 --> 00:57:59.057
Dicky

00:57:59.474 --> 00:58:01.099
Are you all right?

00:58:07.557 --> 00:58:09.890
Turn around and let me see you, okay?

00:58:13.391 --> 00:58:14.682
I'm all right

00:58:15.682 --> 00:58:19.057
I accidentally hurt myself in the shower

00:58:20.474 --> 00:58:22.140
Don't file any complaints

00:58:22.682 --> 00:58:23.848
Please don't

00:58:27.266 --> 00:58:28.891
I listened to you

00:58:30.016 --> 00:58:32.891
When people asked me about this case

00:58:34.141 --> 00:58:35.641
All I said was

00:58:36.307 --> 00:58:40.807
'I'm sorry, I'm unwell,

00:58:40.974 --> 00:58:43.557
I don't want to answer your questions'

00:58:45.391 --> 00:58:47.057
If I keep saying that

00:58:48.141 --> 00:58:50.516
Will I see Grandma soon?

00:58:55.641 --> 00:58:56.766
Barrister Lui

00:58:59.057 --> 00:59:00.515
Promise me

00:59:01.724 --> 00:59:03.515
Don't tell my grandma

00:59:04.266 --> 00:59:06.932
I don't want her to see me like this

00:59:09.432 --> 00:59:10.723
Please

00:59:17.349 --> 00:59:18.474
Thanks

00:59:22.432 --> 00:59:23.973
How's Fung?

00:59:23.974 --> 00:59:26.307
Don't worry, he's fine

00:59:26.307 --> 00:59:28.015
Can I go see him?

00:59:28.516 --> 00:59:30.432
You need to apply for a visitor's permit

00:59:30.432 --> 00:59:32.932
Come, I'll take you home

00:59:42.766 --> 00:59:44.141
Barrister Lui

00:59:45.682 --> 00:59:47.515
I'm already 69 years old

00:59:48.349 --> 00:59:52.474
If Fung can be released after 7-8 years

00:59:52.474 --> 00:59:54.140
I'll still be in my seventies

00:59:54.891 --> 00:59:57.182
He can still have a meal with me

00:59:58.474 --> 01:00:00.224
Let's make him admit to manslaughter

01:00:00.224 --> 01:00:02.390
We can't beat them

01:00:05.266 --> 01:00:06.307
Auntie Chu

01:00:07.266 --> 01:00:09.599
If you give up now,

01:00:09.599 --> 01:00:12.099
Dicky will never be
able to get back on his feet

01:00:14.141 --> 01:00:15.599
I'm not saying I'm giving up

01:00:15.599 --> 01:00:17.390
I know you're working hard

01:00:17.391 --> 01:00:19.016
Very hard

01:00:19.016 --> 01:00:22.266
But we've caused you pain and suffering

01:00:22.266 --> 01:00:25.766
Barrister Lui, I don't want to relive
what happened 10 years ago

01:00:25.766 --> 01:00:28.432
This is completely different from
the Sing Fu incident, Auntie Chu

01:00:28.432 --> 01:00:32.723
Barrister Lui,
you were sure you were right 10 years ago

01:00:32.724 --> 01:00:34.599
But we still didn't win

01:00:35.307 --> 01:00:39.807
If we lose this time,
I won't live to see his release

01:01:07.057 --> 01:01:08.765
Let's admit to manslaughter

01:01:15.349 --> 01:01:16.890
I just talked to Joe

01:01:18.099 --> 01:01:21.099
He said if Dicky confesses,
everything is negotiable

01:01:29.349 --> 01:01:30.474
What do you think?

01:01:35.891 --> 01:01:37.266
What's your opinion on it?

01:01:40.891 --> 01:01:42.599
What's up with you?

01:01:42.599 --> 01:01:44.015
Say something

01:01:44.682 --> 01:01:46.932
Tell me if there's another solution

01:01:47.516 --> 01:01:49.432
Can you say something?

01:01:51.057 --> 01:01:53.515
Cat is a lost cause, okay?

01:01:53.516 --> 01:01:55.807
We can't win this case

01:01:57.057 --> 01:01:59.932
It's murder! He'll be sentenced to life!

01:02:01.391 --> 01:02:03.349
From this day onwards

01:02:03.349 --> 01:02:06.015
Lee Yat-fung's case is none of your concern

01:02:06.557 --> 01:02:08.973
I'm his one and only defense attorney

01:02:09.432 --> 01:02:11.640
I know you don't want to lose

01:02:11.641 --> 01:02:14.724
I know you want to avenge for Tina and Jessica

01:02:14.724 --> 01:02:15.599
But that's not how it works

01:02:15.599 --> 01:02:17.349
You're the one who taught me

01:02:17.349 --> 01:02:21.640
As defense attorneys,
we should consider our client's best interest

01:02:22.182 --> 01:02:23.640
I'll say it again

01:02:24.641 --> 01:02:26.266
He can't hold on much longer!

01:03:01.307 --> 01:03:02.890
I'm very grateful that

01:03:03.807 --> 01:03:07.015
We are leading on the preliminary polls

01:03:07.599 --> 01:03:11.349
Let's hope we gather more support

01:03:11.349 --> 01:03:12.724
Let's keep up the unity, okay?

01:03:12.724 --> 01:03:13.849
Yeah!

01:03:13.849 --> 01:03:17.224
It's not much but consider this
as a mini celebration

01:03:17.224 --> 01:03:18.224
Also

01:03:19.932 --> 01:03:23.223
I'll make a toast with coffee instead, thank you

01:03:23.682 --> 01:03:28.057
Thank you, Mr. Tsang!

01:03:28.057 --> 01:03:29.390
Keep up the good work!

01:03:29.682 --> 01:03:30.848
Grab some food

01:03:30.849 --> 01:03:32.807
Feel free to eat up

01:03:38.849 --> 01:03:40.474
Mr. Tsang

01:03:43.432 --> 01:03:45.598
Don't you underestimate how much I know

01:03:46.516 --> 01:03:48.974
You killed Kwok Ka-yee and Tina

01:03:49.682 --> 01:03:51.890
Why did you have to hurt Jessica as well?

01:03:56.266 --> 01:03:59.266
I feel truly sorry

01:03:59.266 --> 01:04:01.474
For the death of these two ladies

01:04:01.974 --> 01:04:05.640
Hong Kong is governed by rule of law

01:04:06.349 --> 01:04:09.890
If you have proof, then report to the police

01:04:10.557 --> 01:04:12.640
Don't come and mess around here

01:04:13.182 --> 01:04:16.432
You have to be smart in order to survive

01:04:16.891 --> 01:04:18.099
Silly boy

01:04:19.057 --> 01:04:20.348
Barrister Lui

01:04:22.641 --> 01:04:24.141
You are an attorney

01:04:27.307 --> 01:04:30.723
Assault is a serious crime

01:04:32.849 --> 01:04:34.724
Remember what I said today

01:04:35.641 --> 01:04:39.141
Next time, I'll see you in court

01:04:57.016 --> 01:04:58.516
Elise's godmother

01:05:00.849 --> 01:05:03.140
Have you finished collecting this set of dolls?

01:05:04.391 --> 01:05:08.391
Every doll looks the same to me

01:05:14.557 --> 01:05:16.265
I don't care

01:05:17.224 --> 01:05:21.724
When you wake up,
you have to send the whole set to Elise

01:06:22.766 --> 01:06:25.391
I know you'll wake up soon

01:06:28.516 --> 01:06:30.766
If you don't see me when you are discharged

01:06:32.891 --> 01:06:35.182
You'll stay strong for me, right?

01:06:59.349 --> 01:07:01.932
Got a minute? Let's talk

01:07:03.099 --> 01:07:04.307
Frankie

01:07:08.849 --> 01:07:10.557
What is it? What do you want to talk about?

01:07:13.849 --> 01:07:17.474
You have all the details of the case

01:07:17.807 --> 01:07:21.140
I know we'll definitely lose in court

01:07:23.182 --> 01:07:25.807
But I don't intend to have
my client admit to manslaughter

01:07:26.391 --> 01:07:30.891
So you're meeting me
just to fulfil your duties?

01:07:32.307 --> 01:07:33.640
I'm not like you

01:07:33.641 --> 01:07:35.349
I don't charge by the hour

01:07:35.349 --> 01:07:37.474
But don't waste my time like this

01:07:38.724 --> 01:07:39.890
Joe

01:07:43.641 --> 01:07:45.557
When was the last time you took a tram?

01:08:06.307 --> 01:08:07.557
Sweetie

01:08:08.266 --> 01:08:09.474
Tell me

01:08:10.307 --> 01:08:11.723
Have I been selfish

01:08:11.724 --> 01:08:14.015
By insisting that you come back?

01:08:15.557 --> 01:08:18.932
If I let you stay in the United States

01:08:18.932 --> 01:08:21.765
Things might not have turned out this way

01:08:25.057 --> 01:08:28.640
You're the most important person in my life

01:08:30.932 --> 01:08:33.473
Why don't you tell me?

01:08:33.474 --> 01:08:37.515
What do I have to do to bring you back?

01:08:37.516 --> 01:08:39.224
Answer me

01:08:40.432 --> 01:08:42.973
Mr. Kwok, there's still something you can do

01:08:45.349 --> 01:08:49.849
I'm Lui Yau-fai,
the defense attorney on your daughter's case

01:08:51.766 --> 01:08:53.016
I'm sorry

01:08:54.474 --> 01:08:58.015
This is the only way I can approach you

01:08:59.474 --> 01:09:02.307
I recognize you, what do you want?

01:09:02.307 --> 01:09:03.682
To seek the truth

01:09:04.099 --> 01:09:07.765
So that the real murderer can be punished

01:09:52.349 --> 01:09:55.849
Tsim Sha Tsui, Central, Admiralty, Wan Chai

01:09:55.849 --> 01:09:59.015
You can see all of Hong Kong in a glance

01:09:59.016 --> 01:10:02.682
There are only a handful of rich
and powerful people

01:10:02.682 --> 01:10:04.390
There are two right here

01:10:05.474 --> 01:10:07.682
Kwok Group went public in 1984

01:10:08.516 --> 01:10:10.141
At the time, councillors like you

01:10:10.141 --> 01:10:13.349
Kept arguing with the Brits
at the Legislative Council

01:10:13.932 --> 01:10:16.015
I remember you once said

01:10:16.641 --> 01:10:21.141
'Kwok, the world will change

01:10:21.974 --> 01:10:26.349
If we work together then

01:10:26.349 --> 01:10:29.640
We'll be in charge of everything'

01:10:30.432 --> 01:10:34.932
But it seems that you're
the only one taking charge

01:10:37.932 --> 01:10:42.432
Things have changed, I'm old and faded

01:10:43.224 --> 01:10:45.140
How can I compare myself to you?

01:10:45.557 --> 01:10:46.973
Is that right?

01:11:12.474 --> 01:11:15.474
What happened to Angie will be over soon

01:11:15.474 --> 01:11:18.640
But we still need to live on

01:11:19.057 --> 01:11:23.390
When Chi-wai's election is over next month

01:11:23.391 --> 01:11:27.557
Let's go to Xi'an together with the delegation

01:11:27.557 --> 01:11:30.598
Let's take a break and enjoy ourselves...

01:11:30.599 --> 01:11:33.349
I finally know who the murderer is

01:11:35.057 --> 01:11:37.140
I've been looking for Angie all night

01:11:37.141 --> 01:11:38.891
Are you with her right now?

01:11:38.891 --> 01:11:40.724
I was at the workshop,
and the password was changed

01:11:40.724 --> 01:11:41.765
What do you want?

01:11:41.766 --> 01:11:45.974
I'm on my way to the airport,
she told me not to give you the password

01:11:45.974 --> 01:11:49.390
I'm outside the workshop, just tell me

01:11:49.391 --> 01:11:52.349
3690', don't let her know I told you

01:11:52.349 --> 01:11:53.974
All right, I got in

01:11:54.849 --> 01:11:59.349
These were all found in your daughter's computer

01:11:59.516 --> 01:12:01.349
And Cat's cellphone

01:12:02.349 --> 01:12:04.224
I'll take all the blame, as a father...

01:12:04.224 --> 01:12:06.557
Your bastard son killed my daughter!

01:12:06.557 --> 01:12:09.265
The vacuum cleaner was filled with his DNA

01:12:09.807 --> 01:12:13.140
This is a lab report of the vacuum cleaner
from your daughter's workshop

01:12:13.557 --> 01:12:15.723
It states clearly that

01:12:15.724 --> 01:12:19.265
Tsang Chi-wai's DNA was found in the bag

01:12:22.474 --> 01:12:25.807
No one can prove the authenticity of
this anonymous document

01:12:25.807 --> 01:12:28.848
The judge might not even
accept this as evidence in court

01:12:29.016 --> 01:12:33.307
Chi-wai will definitely be
elected in the by-election

01:12:34.974 --> 01:12:39.474
Eventually, he'll be the chairman of CFP

01:12:40.849 --> 01:12:44.765
His people will take over

01:12:47.391 --> 01:12:49.766
If you give him a chance

01:12:49.766 --> 01:12:51.766
You're also giving yourself a chance

01:12:51.974 --> 01:12:53.557
You should have guessed

01:12:54.224 --> 01:12:56.974
Who Angie's real murderer is

01:12:58.224 --> 01:12:59.932
I can help you put him behind bars

01:12:59.932 --> 01:13:02.598
This is the last thing
you can do for your daughter

01:13:02.682 --> 01:13:06.765
I funded his election campaign
and your entire organization

01:13:06.766 --> 01:13:09.766
He killed my daughter,
and I still have to prop him up?

01:13:09.766 --> 01:13:12.641
Are you two out of your goddamn minds?

01:13:13.599 --> 01:13:15.265
Did you forget?

01:13:15.891 --> 01:13:17.266
If no one supported you

01:13:17.266 --> 01:13:21.766
They wouldn't always be building
a subway station next to your land

01:13:21.974 --> 01:13:24.224
Or stop building public housing whenever
you introduce a new housing project

01:13:28.849 --> 01:13:30.890
Without CFP's support

01:13:30.891 --> 01:13:33.891
Your ship would've sunk a long time ago

01:13:33.891 --> 01:13:35.807
This is proof that for the past 12 years

01:13:35.807 --> 01:13:40.307
CFP councillors have been
reserving land along the subway

01:13:42.099 --> 01:13:45.557
To Kwok Group for private residential development

01:13:45.557 --> 01:13:49.432
Angie and Chi-wai are not our only burdens

01:13:49.432 --> 01:13:52.015
We are responsible for many people

01:13:52.016 --> 01:13:53.307
If we go down

01:13:54.141 --> 01:13:57.057
The economy will go down with us, Mr. Kwok

01:13:57.349 --> 01:14:00.974
How much are you willing to
sacrifice for your daughter?

01:14:01.266 --> 01:14:05.224
My daughter is the only one
I'm burdened with today

01:14:07.641 --> 01:14:09.266
I'm old

01:14:09.807 --> 01:14:11.723
I only realized after she's gone

01:14:12.599 --> 01:14:15.265
That we can't take anything to our graves

01:14:15.599 --> 01:14:18.140
Nothing here matters anymore

01:14:18.891 --> 01:14:22.057
I knew the boat would sink
the moment I invited you over

01:14:22.557 --> 01:14:24.015
You think I'm only taking you down?

01:14:24.016 --> 01:14:28.224
I'm taking the entire CFP down!

01:14:28.891 --> 01:14:30.432
Your son or CFP

01:14:30.432 --> 01:14:33.890
You make the call, not me

01:15:01.224 --> 01:15:05.640
I've been subpoenaed as a witness

01:15:09.057 --> 01:15:11.640
They just want you to testify

01:15:12.349 --> 01:15:15.182
Just be careful with what you say

01:15:16.141 --> 01:15:20.016
I don't know what other witnesses will be present

01:15:24.599 --> 01:15:27.932
I'll get a barrister to teach you what to say

01:15:28.766 --> 01:15:32.266
Just be calm and careful

01:15:33.974 --> 01:15:35.432
It'll be fine

01:16:45.307 --> 01:16:47.473
"Be a good lawyer"

01:16:50.016 --> 01:16:51.016
Court

01:17:01.724 --> 01:17:03.349
Your Honour

01:17:03.349 --> 01:17:07.224
I'll now summon our second defense witness,
Tsang Chi-wai

01:17:13.724 --> 01:17:15.099
Witness

01:17:15.099 --> 01:17:19.599
Reports claim that you had
an affair with the victim

01:17:19.932 --> 01:17:21.307
Is that true?

01:17:25.266 --> 01:17:27.766
Witness, please answer my question

01:17:28.349 --> 01:17:29.682
Is it true?

01:17:33.016 --> 01:17:33.974
Yes

01:17:33.974 --> 01:17:36.224
Can you explain

01:17:36.224 --> 01:17:40.724
Your relationship with the victim
before she was murdered?

01:17:43.391 --> 01:17:44.724
We had broken up

01:17:45.016 --> 01:17:46.307
Broken up?

01:17:46.807 --> 01:17:48.932
But Kwok Ka-yee said

01:17:48.932 --> 01:17:50.973
She'd never leave you

01:17:53.599 --> 01:17:56.682
How would I know
what she said to other people?

01:17:56.682 --> 01:17:59.515
I had severed ties with her

01:17:59.516 --> 01:18:02.349
Where were you that night?

01:18:02.349 --> 01:18:04.807
I was home, I didn't go anywhere

01:18:04.807 --> 01:18:07.223
Do you have a friend named Chiu Kwok-fai?

01:18:07.516 --> 01:18:09.182
I do not

01:18:09.182 --> 01:18:10.598
Your Honour

01:18:11.766 --> 01:18:13.266
Jury members

01:18:13.932 --> 01:18:16.848
There's a recording in this phone

01:18:16.849 --> 01:18:21.349
That states clearly that at 2am that night

01:18:21.682 --> 01:18:24.182
Tsang Chi-wai messaged a friend

01:18:29.016 --> 01:18:31.474
I messed up at Angie's house

01:18:31.474 --> 01:18:34.807
I accidentally killed her, come over now

01:18:34.807 --> 01:18:36.765
There's a drunk kid in the house

01:18:40.516 --> 01:18:41.474
Silence

01:18:42.266 --> 01:18:46.099
The owner of this phone is a police officer

01:18:46.099 --> 01:18:50.182
RCU Senior Inspector, Mr. Chiu Kwok-fai

01:18:52.432 --> 01:18:55.432
Witness, please introduce yourself

01:18:56.099 --> 01:18:57.599
I'm Chiu Kwok-fai

01:18:57.599 --> 01:18:59.682
RCU Senior Inspector

01:18:59.682 --> 01:19:02.848
Do you know Tsang Chi-wai?

01:19:03.807 --> 01:19:04.723
Do

01:19:05.307 --> 01:19:06.640
How did you know him?

01:19:06.641 --> 01:19:10.099
15 years ago,
when I was still at the traffic branch

01:19:10.099 --> 01:19:14.557
I had to testify for Mr. Tsang's innocence
after a traffic collision

01:19:14.557 --> 01:19:17.223
Can you describe your relationship?

01:19:17.224 --> 01:19:20.140
Mr. Tsang was thankful for my help

01:19:20.141 --> 01:19:23.349
And invested in my family's restaurant

01:19:23.349 --> 01:19:24.765
So I returned the favour

01:19:24.766 --> 01:19:28.391
I would lend a hand whenever he's in trouble

01:19:28.391 --> 01:19:32.391
Would that include helping him
get out of this murder?

01:19:32.391 --> 01:19:33.599
Objection

01:19:34.099 --> 01:19:36.974
Leading question

01:19:36.974 --> 01:19:38.349
Sustained

01:19:42.266 --> 01:19:46.599
Can you tell me where you were that night?

01:19:46.599 --> 01:19:47.599
What were you doing?

01:19:47.599 --> 01:19:49.432
I was home

01:19:49.432 --> 01:19:52.765
I received a text at around 2:30am

01:19:52.766 --> 01:19:56.682
Can you tell me who sent it to you?

01:19:56.682 --> 01:19:58.265
Tsang Chi-wai

01:19:58.266 --> 01:20:01.057
He texted you so late at night

01:20:01.057 --> 01:20:03.432
Was it something urgent?

01:20:07.349 --> 01:20:08.474
He said

01:20:08.474 --> 01:20:09.724
He killed someone

01:20:14.682 --> 01:20:16.890
I've been looking for Angie all night

01:20:16.891 --> 01:20:18.307
Are you with her right now?

01:20:18.307 --> 01:20:20.807
I was at the workshop,
and the password was changed

01:20:20.807 --> 01:20:21.890
What do you want?

01:20:21.891 --> 01:20:23.641
I'm on my way to the airport

01:20:23.641 --> 01:20:26.474
She told me not to give you the password

01:20:27.557 --> 01:20:30.515
I'm outside the workshop, just tell me

01:20:30.516 --> 01:20:33.807
'3690', don't let her know I told you

01:20:47.816 --> 01:20:49.066
Angie

01:20:49.066 --> 01:20:50.357
I'm sorry

01:20:52.149 --> 01:20:54.315
Didn't you ask for a break up?

01:20:54.316 --> 01:20:56.024
Why are you here?

01:21:12.599 --> 01:21:14.015
Want to take me down?

01:21:15.057 --> 01:21:16.557
Daddy's boy?

01:21:35.766 --> 01:21:38.641
I messed up at Angie's house

01:21:39.182 --> 01:21:41.307
I accidentally killed her

01:21:41.599 --> 01:21:43.349
Come over now

01:21:44.682 --> 01:21:47.015
Tell me what you've touched

01:21:48.974 --> 01:21:50.849
There's a kid in the bedroom

01:21:52.016 --> 01:21:53.891
There's a kid in the bedroom

01:22:16.307 --> 01:22:18.015
Tsang Chi-wai committed murder

01:22:18.016 --> 01:22:22.516
We blamed everything on that kid

01:22:24.849 --> 01:22:26.140
<i>Chi-wail!</i>

01:22:28.307 --> 01:22:30.640
That's not true, you're lying!

01:22:30.641 --> 01:22:31.182
<i>Chi-wail!</i>

01:22:31.182 --> 01:22:33.890
Your Honour, he's wrongfully accusing me!

01:22:34.682 --> 01:22:35.890
Daddy!

01:22:35.891 --> 01:22:37.307
Save me!

01:22:37.307 --> 01:22:38.807
Daddy!

01:22:39.391 --> 01:22:41.099
Daddy!

01:22:52.641 --> 01:22:55.016
This'll last you a lifetime
after your release

01:22:55.016 --> 01:22:57.641
Mr. Kwok hopes that you'll tell the truth in court

01:23:15.266 --> 01:23:17.349
Didn't I tell you

01:23:17.349 --> 01:23:19.890
We would meet again in court?

01:23:28.849 --> 01:23:30.974
- Grandma!
- Fung!

01:23:33.849 --> 01:23:35.099
Everything's fine

01:23:35.099 --> 01:23:36.974
It's all good

01:23:40.474 --> 01:23:42.432
Go and thank Barrister Lui

01:23:43.099 --> 01:23:45.640
- Thank you, Barrister Lui
- Congratulation

01:23:47.724 --> 01:23:49.307
- Thank you
- Congratulations

01:23:50.224 --> 01:23:51.849
Grandma

01:23:51.849 --> 01:23:54.724
Wash away your bad luck with pomelo leaves

01:23:57.099 --> 01:23:59.765
Why did Inspector Chiu turn
into an accomplice witness?

01:24:01.849 --> 01:24:04.265
You gotta pay your tuition

01:24:12.099 --> 01:24:13.890
I'm Kwok Sai-wing's attorney

01:24:13.891 --> 01:24:15.057
I'm here to see Inspector Fung

01:24:15.057 --> 01:24:16.515
Please wait

01:24:17.141 --> 01:24:21.016
All the trade details
between Kwok Group and CFP

01:24:21.016 --> 01:24:22.974
Are right here

01:24:23.557 --> 01:24:24.765
I'm here to turn myself in

01:24:24.766 --> 01:24:26.974
Don't act on impulse

01:24:26.974 --> 01:24:30.515
You're not doing anyone any good

01:24:31.057 --> 01:24:33.140
All I want is justice

01:24:33.141 --> 01:24:36.224
Whoever played a part in my daughter's murder

01:24:36.224 --> 01:24:38.724
Will not see the light of day

01:24:48.682 --> 01:24:51.390
Barrister Lui, these officers are here for you

01:24:51.391 --> 01:24:52.891
Mr. Lui Yau-fai

01:24:52.891 --> 01:24:54.141
We've received complaints

01:24:54.141 --> 01:24:56.266
Claiming that you've falsified documents

01:24:56.266 --> 01:24:58.891
Please come with us for further investigation

01:25:01.016 --> 01:25:01.891
Okay

01:25:09.516 --> 01:25:11.974
The falsification claim

01:25:11.974 --> 01:25:13.515
Might not go through

01:25:13.891 --> 01:25:17.141
It's just a routine investigation
by the Bar Association

01:25:19.266 --> 01:25:20.182
Oh yeah

01:25:21.599 --> 01:25:23.640
So I can write whatever I want?

01:25:23.641 --> 01:25:26.807
Joe, when was the last time you took a tram?

01:25:29.974 --> 01:25:31.932
Do you believe that
Lee Yat-fung committed murder?

01:25:31.932 --> 01:25:35.515
I shouldn't be answering this question

01:25:35.516 --> 01:25:37.266
Nor should you be asking it

01:25:49.474 --> 01:25:53.432
Same old mistake, interference with witness

01:25:54.474 --> 01:25:56.724
This is not the original recording

01:25:56.724 --> 01:26:00.224
It can't be presented as evidence in court

01:26:00.224 --> 01:26:01.807
Do you believe in it?

01:26:10.932 --> 01:26:12.682
Barrister Chan Hong-lai

01:26:14.266 --> 01:26:17.141
I would like to seek your legal advice

01:26:19.307 --> 01:26:21.473
Based on attorney-client privilege

01:26:23.307 --> 01:26:25.557
Are you willing to accept my employment

01:26:26.516 --> 01:26:28.724
And keep our conversation strictly confidential?

01:26:40.474 --> 01:26:41.890
Why not?

01:26:41.891 --> 01:26:43.266
How can I help you?

01:26:43.599 --> 01:26:45.015
Hypothetically speaking

01:26:45.682 --> 01:26:50.182
I have a friend who wants to prank another friend

01:26:50.849 --> 01:26:55.349
And put trash into his friend's vacuum bag
that isn't his friend's

01:26:56.891 --> 01:27:00.891
Then remember to tell your friend

01:27:00.891 --> 01:27:05.391
You cannot be certain that everything is 100% true

01:27:06.141 --> 01:27:08.724
It's just unprofessional conduct

01:27:08.724 --> 01:27:10.432
They won't confiscate everything

01:27:10.807 --> 01:27:13.640
If the price is reasonable,
I promise it'll go through

01:27:32.057 --> 01:27:33.182
Gentlemen

01:27:34.016 --> 01:27:36.307
On legal terms, falsification of documents

01:27:36.307 --> 01:27:40.098
Means forging or modifying a document

01:27:40.099 --> 01:27:42.349
With the intention to deceive

01:27:42.349 --> 01:27:44.224
In order to obtain benefits

01:27:45.599 --> 01:27:46.474
With this incident

01:27:46.474 --> 01:27:49.599
My client acted on impulse

01:27:49.599 --> 01:27:51.182
And pulled a prank

01:28:12.807 --> 01:28:17.057
My client took this vacuum bag for re-examination

01:28:17.057 --> 01:28:19.682
And received this new report

01:28:19.682 --> 01:28:24.182
My client gave this new report to
Mr. Kwok Sai-wing

01:28:25.724 --> 01:28:27.015
Theoretically,

01:28:27.016 --> 01:28:30.516
my client did not falsify this new report

01:28:31.141 --> 01:28:34.057
Therefore, my client did not commit

01:28:34.057 --> 01:28:37.265
The offense of forging or modifying a document

01:28:38.182 --> 01:28:42.015
This is a lab report of the vacuum cleaner
from your daughter's workshop

01:28:42.016 --> 01:28:45.974
It states clearly that there are
traces of Tsang Chi-wai's DNA

01:28:45.974 --> 01:28:50.224
When my client gave this report to Kwok Sai-wing

01:28:50.224 --> 01:28:51.682
He stressed that

01:28:51.682 --> 01:28:55.390
He's uncertain about
the authenticity of this report

01:28:55.391 --> 01:28:57.474
...who wants to prank another friend

01:28:57.474 --> 01:29:01.349
You cannot be certain that everything is 100% true

01:29:01.349 --> 01:29:04.849
No one can prove the authenticity
of this anonymous document

01:29:05.682 --> 01:29:08.140
The judge might not even accept this
as evidence in court

01:29:08.141 --> 01:29:11.849
Therefore, my client did not have
the intention to deceive

01:29:13.766 --> 01:29:17.182
Although this report indirectly
caused Tsang Chi-wai's conviction

01:29:17.182 --> 01:29:19.557
But what did my client gain from it?

01:29:19.557 --> 01:29:21.682
Tsang Chi-wai, or even Lee Yat-fung

01:29:21.682 --> 01:29:24.057
Whomever is the killer, or is punished by law

01:29:24.057 --> 01:29:25.723
Has nothing to do with my client

01:29:25.724 --> 01:29:27.682
And due to this falsification claim

01:29:27.682 --> 01:29:30.598
My client's professionalism has been challenged

01:29:30.599 --> 01:29:34.932
And he might even face disbarment

01:29:35.682 --> 01:29:37.473
I would like to ask

01:29:37.474 --> 01:29:41.349
What benefits did my client get from all this?

01:29:47.391 --> 01:29:48.891
Barrister Lui Yau-fai

01:29:48.891 --> 01:29:50.641
Before we make our ruling

01:29:50.641 --> 01:29:52.474
Do you have anything else to say?

01:29:57.932 --> 01:29:59.015
Gentlemen

01:30:00.724 --> 01:30:02.640
My daughter is 10 years old

01:30:04.016 --> 01:30:05.974
She was born

01:30:05.974 --> 01:30:07.890
On the day that her mother died

01:30:08.516 --> 01:30:12.557
That was also the day of the
Sing Fu Shopping Mall incident

01:30:14.974 --> 01:30:17.140
She was born prematurely

01:30:19.266 --> 01:30:23.766
I remember how afraid I was,
holding her for the first time

01:30:25.557 --> 01:30:27.598
I wasn't afraid that she wouldn't grow up

01:30:29.182 --> 01:30:32.557
I wasn't afraid of raising her alone either

01:30:35.807 --> 01:30:39.390
I was afraid of what kind of world
I have brought her in to

01:30:42.141 --> 01:30:44.141
I told my daughter

01:30:45.974 --> 01:30:49.890
That I'll make sure she grows up in a world
that is fair and just

01:30:53.057 --> 01:30:55.223
Someone once told me

01:30:57.682 --> 01:31:02.182
That no one needs justice and fairness anymore

01:31:04.641 --> 01:31:06.724
Even if you sacrifice yourself fighting for it

01:31:06.724 --> 01:31:09.057
No one will care or even remember

01:31:09.057 --> 01:31:11.723
Nobody needs these things

01:31:12.849 --> 01:31:15.140
If this is what our world has become

01:31:17.766 --> 01:31:19.474
Our children

01:31:19.474 --> 01:31:21.890
Will have to live in a world

01:31:21.891 --> 01:31:24.599
Without faith, principles, and justice

01:31:27.224 --> 01:31:28.849
Can you live with that?

01:31:32.099 --> 01:31:33.557
What about being an attorney?

01:31:35.557 --> 01:31:38.057
What can attorneys do for this world?

01:31:40.891 --> 01:31:42.974
I once asked myself

01:31:43.474 --> 01:31:45.599
How I can defend justice

01:31:50.474 --> 01:31:51.807
Should I be like everyone else

01:31:51.807 --> 01:31:54.473
Standing alongside the egg

01:31:54.974 --> 01:31:57.182
Against the high wall?

01:32:00.474 --> 01:32:01.807
The stability we enjoy today

01:32:01.807 --> 01:32:04.807
Is the result of hard work from
our previous generation

01:32:05.391 --> 01:32:07.849
No fine and no prison time

01:32:07.849 --> 01:32:09.432
Isn't it our responsibility

01:32:09.432 --> 01:32:11.640
To give our children a world

01:32:11.641 --> 01:32:14.724
Without prejudice against wealth and social status

01:32:14.724 --> 01:32:17.890
Where everyone is equal before the law?

01:32:59.307 --> 01:33:01.223
Daddy

01:33:04.224 --> 01:33:05.724
Daddy

01:33:06.974 --> 01:33:08.307
You've gained weight

01:33:08.307 --> 01:33:09.932
I've missed you, Daddy

01:33:09.932 --> 01:33:11.057
Me too

01:33:11.057 --> 01:33:13.515
Have you been smoking?

01:33:14.516 --> 01:33:16.932
- Nope
- Gross!

01:33:16.932 --> 01:33:18.140
Give me a kiss

01:33:19.474 --> 01:33:20.599
Let's go

01:33:22.724 --> 01:33:25.724
Count me in, let's rent an office together

01:33:25.724 --> 01:33:27.390
What about DoJ?

01:33:29.974 --> 01:33:32.307
Take it as my deposit

01:33:34.599 --> 01:33:35.765
What's wrong?

01:33:36.391 --> 01:33:38.557
Aren't you gonna give me a chance?

01:33:41.099 --> 01:33:42.307
Bye-bye

01:33:44.474 --> 01:33:45.807
What does this mean?

01:33:47.391 --> 01:33:49.016
That's your tuition

01:33:55.099 --> 01:33:58.057
Regarding the document falsification claim on
Barrister Lui Yau-fai

01:33:58.057 --> 01:33:59.390
Due to lack of evidence

01:33:59.391 --> 01:34:01.599
There will be no further investigation
from The Bar Association

01:34:02.016 --> 01:34:05.724
Barrister Lui Yau-fai is
guilty of unprofessional conduct

01:34:05.724 --> 01:34:08.265
His license will be suspended for 3 years